<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:media="http://search.yahoo.com/mrss/">
<channel>
<title>Evan Solomon — GZERO Media</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/author/evansolomon</link>
<description>Evan Solomon is a Member of Parliament in Canada&apos;s House of Commons, representing the Toronto Centre consitituency. From 2022 through March 2025, he was the…</description>
<language>en</language>
<copyright>© GZERO Media</copyright>
<atom:link href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/feeds/author/evansolomon.xml" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
<lastBuildDate>Mon, 09 Nov 2026 19:25:56 +0000</lastBuildDate>
<item>
<title>A Politically Game-Changing Year for Better or Worse</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/a-politically-game-changing-year-for-better-or-worse</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfzo1okm8z07my9b05ncq6</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 12 Dec 2024 20:29:43 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>elon musk</category>
<category>gzero game changers</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>budget</category>
<category>foreign aid</category>
<category>us foreign policy</category>
<category>Analysis</category>
<description>GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon responds to comments made by two of our top 2024 game changers, Donald Trump and Elon Musk, about cutting foreign aid. “A dramatic turn to US isolationism in a world of crisis,” Solomon writes, “would be a troubling, game-changing trend that would only make the US more vulnerable.”</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd2ki7dcqb07lq7z8d40ir" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Luisa Vieira</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd2ki7dcqb07lq7z8d40ir" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This week we rolled out GZERO’s <strong>Top 10 Political Game Changers of the Year</strong>, which you can check out <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/top-10-geopolitical-game-changers-of-2024"><u>here</u></a>.</p><p>Just hours ago, we named <strong>Donald Trump</strong> our No. 1 political <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/top-10-geopolitical-game-changers-of-2024"><u>game changer</u></a> of the year. <strong>Elon Musk</strong>, whose net worth just topped a record-breaking $400 billion, is No. 2.</p><p>Let’s do a quick detour on that just to get some sense of proportionality: How much is $400 billion? It’s bigger than the nominal GDP of Musk’s birth country, South Africa, as well as countries like Belgium, Portugal, New Zealand, and Qatar (net worth and nominal GDP, of course, are not directly comparable measures but are used here to illustrated the scale of Musk’s wealth).<strong>&nbsp;</strong>In fact, his net worth is higher than the nominal GDP of all but about 40 countries in the world, but that’s not even why we chose him as a top game changer of the year. Musk’s crucial help in electing Trump, the influence of his social media platform, X, in the culture and political wars around the world, and his breathtaking innovations in space, electric cars, tech, and AI were all factors.</p><p>But something both Trump and Musk said this week about foreign aid merits inclusion in our game-changer discussions.</p><p>As the Assad regime dramatically fell this week, President-elect Trump declared, “THIS IS NOT OUR FIGHT.” An aversion to foreign intervention and an America-first isolationism is not a surprising stance from Trump, and it’s one many Americans support. But Musk, who Trump tapped to lead the so-called Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, went even further: He expressed support for former Rep. <strong>Ron Paul</strong>’s desire to eliminate all US foreign aid. “Here’s an easy one for @DOGE !” Paul <a target="_blank" href="https://x.com/RonPaul/status/1865137982434415016"><u>posted</u></a> on X. “ELIMINATE foreign aid!”</p><p>Musk posted a reply: “Ron is not wrong.”</p><p>Musk’s partner in DOGE, <strong>Vivek Ramaswamy</strong>, picked up the baton, saying: “It’s an oxymoron that represents a waste of taxpayer dollars, but the real problem runs deeper: Americans deserve transparency on opaque foreign aid.”</p><p>There is a big difference between transparency in foreign aid and the elimination of it.</p><p>Transparency on all government spending is a net good, especially when it comes to foreign aid, so no issue there. But would eliminating foreign aid really save US taxpayers a material amount of money and make the world a safer place?</p><p>Again, some proportionality is in order.</p><p>The <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://fiscaldata.treasury.gov/americas-finance-guide/"><u>US budget</u></a> in 2024 was about $6.75 trillion — roughly $1.8 trillion more than it collected in revenue, which is why there is such a structural deficit problem. But how much does foreign aid contribute to that? Only about $70 billion. That is less than 1% of the budget.</p><p>Some more perspective. After World War II, the US spent about 3% on the Marshall Plan to help rebuild Europe, which led to the longest era of peace and prosperity in world history.</p><p>That’s important because Musk and Ramaswamy are playing off the perception that foreign aid is a major drain on the US taxpayer. The truth is, if you run the newly minted DOGE and are looking for savings, foreign aid amounts to the old pennies you find between your couch cushions.</p><h3>Where does US foreign aid money go?</h3><p>According to a <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/what-is-us-foreign-assistance/"><u>Brookings report</u></a>, the US spends about 25% on humanitarian aid, like helping countries during earthquakes and disasters, and 65% on development aid, like food, education, and medical programs to stop the spread of disease. The smallest part is spent on security and helping governments in allied countries stay stable. It is one of the United States’ most fundamental expressions of soft power, and in a global world where viruses, climate change, and migration issues are all serious cross-border threats, this is a low-cost insurance policy.</p><p>Foreign aid is distributed mainly to US government agencies and nonprofit organizations. About 20% goes to multilateral organizations like, say, the UN. Some does go to foreign governments like Ukraine, and there is waste and some corruption, but overall, it is highly regulated, especially when dealing with a country with high levels of corruption.</p><p>“Accountability of U.S. economic assistance is high — the U.S. imposes stringent, some would say onerous, reporting and accounting requirements on recipients of U.S. assistance, and the General Accounting Office and agency inspector generals investigate possible misuse,” according to the Brookings Institution.</p><h3>What harm could cutting it cause?</h3><p>Eliminating foreign aid will produce negligible economic savings for the US economy but consequential negative results on US public safety.</p><p>Power abhors a vacuum, and if the US does not support governments or areas that are in crisis — like Syria — someone else will, like Russia, China, or Islamic State.</p><p>Closing your eyes to the global neighborhood won’t make global troubles go away. It simply limits Washington’s ability to prevent them from growing into genuine threats that will have to be dealt with one way or another. And worse, it cedes global influence to bad actors that will, eventually, also threaten US and Western stability.</p><p>A dramatic turn to US isolationism in a world of crisis would be a troubling, game-changing trend that would only make the US more vulnerable.</p><p>Elon Musk is the richest man in history and he’s in charge of government efficiency. He may cut many parts of government, but foreign aid is not the place to be penny-wise and policy-foolish.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The end of US soft power?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/the-end-of-us-soft-power</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg23srlkwt07lqnxr4semj</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 06 Feb 2025 19:43:36 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>tariffs</category>
<category>usaid</category>
<category>soft power</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>humanitarian aid</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>Analysis</category>
<description>Is this the end of American soft power and, if so, how should allies respond? GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon explores the shuttering of USAID and the tariff taunts between the US and Canada.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd6fd8dxq207lqmxdauf9f" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1920" height="1080">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd6fd8dxq207lqmxdauf9f" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The world’s wake-up call came at 3 a.m.</p><p>In the early darkness on Saturday, Feb. 1, USAID was suddenly shut down. “This site can’t be reached,” read its homepage. The end of the great age of American soft power began.</p><p>It was shocking, but not surprising. When <strong>Elon Musk</strong> pulled the rip cord of his verbal chainsaw and declared that USAID was a $40 billion “criminal organization” that “must die,” the deep-cut result was inevitable. President <strong>Donald Trump</strong> agreed, saying the organization was run “by a bunch of lunatics.”</p><p>Today, the website message is more stark. “On Friday, February 7, 2025, at 11:59 p.m. (EST) all USAID direct hire personnel will be placed on administrative leave globally, with the exception of designated personnel responsible for mission-critical functions, core leadership and specially designated programs.”</p><p>The remnants of USAID will be rolled into the State Department.</p><p><strong>Is this really the end of American soft power and, if so, how should allies respond?</strong></p><p>Created by President <strong>John F. Kennedy</strong> back in 1961, USAID was meant to be the bicep in America’s muscular arm of diplomatic power. According to the Congressional Research Service, USAID “provides assistance to strategically important countries and countries in conflict; leads US efforts to alleviate poverty, disease, and humanitarian need; and assists US commercial interests by supporting developing countries’ economic growth and building countries’ capacity to participate in world trade.”</p><p>It was a broad mandate covering over 131 countries and hundreds of programs.</p><p><strong>What did they do?</strong> At its best, USAID helped fight deadly diseases through programs such as the Malaria Council in Uganda, or the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief. It supported NGOs working to stop the spread of Ebola and Marburg virus and to feed hungry people in Sudan.</p><p>The hyperpolarized culture wars rang the death knell of proportionality long ago, so when Musk dismissed the entire agency as “a radical left political psy ops” program, it fit the moment. Everything is now either the worst or the best. The middle ground is gone. But for all that, the facts remain and they are worth mentioning.</p><p>For example, the White House currently has a <a target="_blank" href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/uncategorized/2025/02/at-usaid-waste-and-abuse-runs-deep/"><u>website up</u></a> outlining its claims of waste and abuse at USAID, chronicling things like $70,000 for a DEI musical in Ireland and $32,000 for a “transgender comic book in Peru.” Those are making headlines in the culture war media. There will be other examples of programs the current administration chooses not to fund or accuses of corruption, but how many?</p><p>Turns out, the website only gives concrete examples of about $12 million worth of programs they don’t like, along with allegations but no data on “hundreds of millions” of others. Of USAID’s annual budget of $40 billion, that adds up to less than 2%. Is the best answer to a broken toe the complete amputation of a leg? Apparently so.</p><p>USAID was an important instrument of what <strong>Joseph Nye</strong> called “soft power,” achieving national security and goals through attraction, not coercion. “When you can get others to admire your ideals and to want what you want, you do not have to spend as much on sticks and carrots to move them in your direction,” Nye wrote in “Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics” back in 2004.</p><p>USAID was just that, projecting the ideals of the US in places where chaos, poverty, and insecurity are fertile grounds for malevolent forces that endanger the United States. It did this by supporting multilateral institutions, such as the World Health Organization and the Paris Climate Agreement. Soft power is a form of security and is supposed to work in conjunction with hard power. But if you think the cost of soft power is high, try the costs of hard power. Americans know that all too well from experiences in Iraq and Afghanistan.</p><p>What is striking about all this is that the Trump administration is not just trying to recalibrate US soft power to promote its own agenda. If that were the case, they would simply reform USAID, not kill it. This is radically different. What is now clear is that the Trump administration doesn’t believe in the value of soft power at all. It simply has no use in their political playbook.</p><p>There are no countries happier with the retreat of US soft power than China and Russia. Their influence in developing countries will now grow dramatically. Democracies are in retreat all over the world, as the <a target="_blank" href="https://freedomhouse.org/explore-the-map?type=fiw&amp;year=2024"><u>Freedom House map</u></a> shows, and the sunset of US soft power will make it worse.</p><p>But this is not the only example of the twilight of US soft power. The threat of 25% percent tariffs on allies like Canada is another. There is no closer ally to the US than Canada, with a shared border, a free trade deal, and deeply connected cultures. The tariff threat suddenly upended that, leading to scenes I have never witnessed in my lifetime, such as Canadians booing the American national anthem at hockey games.</p><p>The northern sense of confusion and betrayal is being amplified by the election cycles in Canada, with politicians now stoking a patriotism that comes at the expense of affection for the US. It is not a good trend but in context, completely understandable.</p><p>At this moment, the ubiquitous soft power of American culture has gone from inspiring to infuriating, the American beacon of freedom is now fried up into Canadian bacon. It will take a long time to reestablish trust between the friendliest of all neighbo(u)rs.</p><p>Let’s not overstate things. US soft power is not gone; it’s just diminished. American culture, innovation, and institutions remain resilient to challenges and attractive to billions of people. And for all the talk of diversifying trade, Canada will be economically tied to the US forever. There is simply no escaping geography.</p><p>But the end of the golden age of American soft power means that hard power options — militarily and economically – are now the most prominent tools on the table. Trump’s repeated claim that Canada should become the 51st state while threatening to economically destroy the country has gone from a bad joke to an ominous warning. How to respond?</p><p>As the US abandons its soft power strategy, its allies are having to develop their own versions of it to avoid punishment. Taking on Trump in a hard power fight is, after all, a lose-lose. A trade war may hurt the US, but it would hurt Canada much more.</p><p>The strategy now is to use soft power levers to try to convince the US president that what Washington wants, Ottawa wants too, without giving up too much in the process. So spending $1.3 billion at the border to stop illegal immigration and fentanyl is money well spent if it can help stave off tariffs that would likely push Canada into a recession. Of course, the tariffs aren't solely in response to fentanyl and immigration, but those are low-hanging fruit and, so far, addressing those issues has worked.</p><p>Then what? What are the rules of soft power in dealing with President Trump? Don’t celebrate and gloat over a win. Stay cool when threats don’t materialize. Don’t make it personal because with the president the personal is political. This is not a strategy of appeasement but simply using carrots, not sticks. To twist an old<strong> David Frost</strong> saying, soft power is the art of letting someone else have your way.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Does Canada need to prepare for a US attack?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/does-canada-need-to-prepare-for-a-us-attack</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg3s8ylpwq07lqniv73dgn</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 13 Mar 2025 19:48:49 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>defense spending</category>
<category>us-canada border</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Canada has begun thinking the unthinkable: how to defend against a US attack. It suddenly realizes — far too late – that the 2% GDP goal on defense spending is no longer aspirational but urgent. But what kind of military does it need? To find out, GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon spoke with retired Vice Admiral Mark Norman, the former vice chief of defense staff in Canada and currently a fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd95z1dat907myrqbw2rgj" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Paige Fusco</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd95z1dat907myrqbw2rgj" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Borderline frenemies meet in Quebec for the G7 as Canada begins thinking the unthinkable: how to defend against a US attack.</p><p>You know things are going badly when the first thing Secretary of State <strong>Marco Rubio</strong> has to do on his G7 visit to Canada is deny his intention to invade. “It is not a meeting about how we’re going to take over Canada,” he said, though no one believed him.</p><p>Why would they?</p><p>President <strong>Donald Trump</strong>’s mantra includes daily insults, threats, and acts of disrespect toward Canada as he launches his destructive trade war. But for a guy who’s all about high walls and protected borders, he has a very different view of it when it comes to his northern neighbo(u)r, dismissing it as an “artificial line” drawn “with a ruler.” “When you take away that,” he said this week in a moment of empire-building fantasy, “and you look at that beautiful formation of Canada and the United States, there’s no place anywhere in the world that looks like that.”</p><p>I have no clue what he means by that whole “beautiful formation” thing, but our hardcore GZERO trivia fans deserve a short backgrounder on the actual formation of the US-Canada border.</p><p>Since the Treaty of Ghent (oh yes, I’m going there!) ended the War of 1812, the boundary between Canada and the US has been relatively stable. Sure, some fellow history buffs will point out the border was tested in 1816 by the humiliating construction of a US military battery dubbed “Fort Blunder,” a battery mistakenly built on Canadian soil that had to be moved south, where it is now called Fort Montgomery. But we survived that tiff. Later, in 1842, the Webster-Ashburton Treaty (stay with me here) clarified the border with better surveys, and in 1909, the Boundary Waters Treaty determined how the Great Lakes would be divvied up. Since then, there have been updates and a few disputes, but prime ministers and presidents have happily memorized what might be called the Psalm of the 49th parallel, which starts with the famous line, “This is the longest undefended border in the world.”</p><p>So no, these are not artificial lines but ones mutually agreed upon in legally binding treaties. The nub is that President Trump has shown he doesn’t care about treaties, even ones he signed himself, like the USMCA back in 2020. He prefers the law of the jungle, where strong countries take what they want from weaker ones. And Trump wants Canada. He has repeatedly claimed that Canada would not be “viable as a country” without US trade, which is why his stated strategy is to annex Canada by “economic force.”</p><p>Trump’s administration regularly amplifies his imperialist sentiments. This week, White House Press Secretary <strong>Karoline Leavitt</strong> made the case that Canada should become a state to avoid tariffs, while US Commerce Secretary <strong>Howard Lutnick</strong> went on TV after Ontario Premier <strong>Doug Ford</strong> threatened to slap a 25% tariff on electricity to three northern US states, saying the best way to get a good trade deal with the United States is to “consider the amazing advantages of being the 51st state.”</p><p>It’s no wonder that Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>, who leaves office tomorrow, concluded this is about taking over Canada: “What he wants is to see a total collapse of the Canadian economy because that’ll make it easier to annex us.”</p><p>When Rubio arrived in Canada for the G7, his Canadian counterpart, Foreign Affairs Minister <strong>Mélanie Joly</strong>, was not in a joking mood. “If the US can do this to us, their closest friend, then nobody is safe,” she said. Her colleagues in the EU have already absorbed that message, which is why they are talking about a European-run nuclear shield and a massive buildup of their collective defense forces.</p><p>It was almost sad to see how the secretary of state tried to spin Trump’s agenda in a bid to lower the temperature. “He says if they became the 51st state, we wouldn’t have to worry about the border and fentanyl coming across because now we would be able to manage that,” Rubio said.</p><p>Oh, thanks a bunch.</p><p>Annexing Canada is necessary because less than 1% of the illegal fentanyl that enters the US goes across the northern border? By that logic, Canada should annex the US because of the <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/graphic-truth-the-north-american-gun-divide"><u>inflow of illegal guns</u></a> from the US. It is madness, of course, but it’s a madness that is now being measured.</p><p>Angus Reid recently conducted a <a target="_blank" href="https://angusreid.org/trump-carney-51st-state-canada-usa/"><u>poll</u></a> on the idea of annexation, and about 60% of Americans oppose it (including 44% of Trump voters), and about 30% would be interested only if Canadians supported the idea. They don’t. In the same poll, 90% of Canadians reject the idea outright, with one interesting exception. “One-in-five would-be CPC voters say they would vote yes, compared to almost zero Liberal (2%), NDP (3%), and Bloc Québécois (1%) voters,” reports Angus Reid.</p><p>Still, all this thought about annexation has the defense department in Canada running through scenarios they never imagined possible just months ago: what to do if the US ever attacked.</p><p>Trump has questioned the border lines in the Great Lakes, so what if US Coast Guard vessels started to cross that line and test the boundary? What about around the coast or in the Arctic?</p><p>Canada suddenly realizes — far too late – that the 2% GDP goal on defense spending is no longer aspirational but urgent. But what kind of military does it need? To find out, I spoke to retired Vice Admiral <strong>Mark Norman</strong>, the former vice chief of defense staff in Canada and currently a fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute.</p><p>I’ve edited the conversation for this article.</p><p><strong>GZERO: Some argue the US is still an ally, but others say we have to treat the US as a foe, one that could even potentially attack Canada. How would you describe the situation?</strong></p><p><strong>Norman:</strong> We’re outside the guardrails. To put it in nautical terms, we’re in completely uncharted territory here. What’s real and what’s not? How do you interpret what we’re hearing? How do we not overreact? There are many Canadians, both in the public domain and in the machinery of government, who I believe are banking on the faint hope clause, if I can put it that way, meaning they think that things will go back to the way they were. I think that is naive and irresponsible going forward. I don’t believe this is sort of a blip in the evolution of geostrategic affairs, specifically as it relates to the Canada-US relationship. I think we’re seeing a significant change — one could argue it’s almost a pivot.</p><p>Look at the Ukrainian situation and the public abandonment of European security. Then look at the ongoing threats of annexation as it relates to Canada.</p><p>Canadians have grown up far away from the kinds of threats to physical security and other types of security that many of our global neighbors have had to deal with. We have lived under the umbrella of the United States, and we have taken that for granted. There is some substance in the complaints that are being levied against us. The challenge is the nature of both the threats and the ongoing actions, and what that potentially means for us. I am concerned that the nature of Canada-US relations is changing fundamentally.</p><p><strong>What could it look like?</strong></p><p>There are two scenarios here, and there is risk in oversimplifying this ... One scenario is that this is simply transactional. This is Trump’s attempt to try and get us to do a bunch of things to up our game, our spending – to do more and contribute more. One could argue this transactional approach, this negotiating tactic, will lead to some magic tipping point at which everything falls into place, and we have some sort of agreement. That is scenario A.</p><p>Scenario B is the most threatening scenario. We’ll call it annexation. Not sure what that looks like, specifically, but we take this to mean that in some way or form, the United States is exercising a significant degree of control over what we would have traditionally seen as sovereign decisions made by Canada.</p><p>From a military perspective, much of what we would need to do is actually independent of those two scenarios. So we either have to step up and satisfy a whole series of unclear expectations on the part of the current administration, everything from border security to Arctic security to all these other things, or we’ve got to up our game, because if we don’t, then we risk the threat of some sort of loss of control.</p><p>I have difficulty imagining scenarios whereby Canada would be invaded or that Canada could respond to something like scenario B. I think there will be coercion. I think there are lots of tools left in Trump’s toolbox to coerce us and threaten us and basically put us off-balance and cause us to react. What’s interesting is we’re either on our own, at which point we need to do a hell of a lot more than we’re doing now, or we’re in the process of being shaken down, which also means we need to do a hell of a lot more. Those will be preconditions for what would be even the most benign and benevolent version of events.</p><p><strong>So Canada has to rebuild its military one way or another?</strong></p><p>Let’s start with national capacity, domestic capacity, and industrial capacity. One of the unintended consequences of the Ukrainian conflict has been the incredible growth in Ukrainian domestic capacity, notwithstanding the fact that they’re waging what many argued was an unwinnable war against a superpower with one of the largest armies in the world. A lot of that has to do with innovation, engineering, and agility, which has now made them a significant player in the European defense industry. It is particularly relevant to the Canadian situation, where a lot of our military capacity is tied to US technology. I think this is a huge vulnerability for us going forward, even if we were to find ourselves in scenario A. We cannot and should not rely on others for a lot of the stuff. Now, we cannot do everything, but there are enormous alternate sources of technology in our European and Asian partners. And we have to do a much better job of leveraging our own industrial capacity. What are we really good at? We’re really good at things related to AI, acoustic processing, and communications. We’re very good at things related to satellite technology. We have a number of emerging capabilities in unmanned systems, be they airborne or surface, and even underwater capabilities. We have enormous advantages in terms of understanding the technical challenges of the Arctic. It is our backyard. In military terms, we are good at combat management systems. So think of the computer architecture that allows you to do what you need to do from a command and control perspective.</p><p><strong>Is the point that Canada will have to build a new type of military faster, cheaper, and less dependent on the US and use more innovation?</strong></p><p>Canada will definitely need to explore alternative solutions, like drone capacity, to address the challenges of defending vast territories. But it will still need icebreakers, a navy, and tanks. It’s a new world. One other factor here. You need to be able to deploy and sustain your forces. A lot of people don’t think that’s sexy, but the reality is, this is all about logistics, and this is all about sustainment, which means you have to have an industrial base. You look at the kinds of distances that we’re dealing with in Canada — these are massive distances. These are not insignificant challenges, and we’ve never really dealt with them. You need to be able to control what’s going on. Do you just simply want to monitor what’s going on, or do you want to be able to influence what’s going on? This is where you get into the pointy ends, the more kinetic discussions around what are the hard capabilities that you need and don’t need, but you have to have all that other stuff sorted out first. The reason the Ukrainians are so effective in these asymmetric conflicts is because they figured out a lot of that back-end stuff. Canada needs to do that too.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Is the Trump revolution off to a good or bad start?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/is-the-trump-revolution-off-to-a-good-or-bad-start</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg3gazlp3u07lqhw1w9fvn</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 06 Mar 2025 19:53:40 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>tariffs</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>russia</category>
<category>ukraine</category>
<category>art of the deal</category>
<category>europe</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>You didn’t need to sit through all 99 minutes of Trump’s peroration to know that he gave himself an A++ on his first six weeks in office, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon. But if Trump gets to grade himself, maybe it’s time for a more objective report card — one that looks at two criteria: Trump as a dealmaker and Trump as a manager.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd8l60e0jp07lqaep9yayi" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="821">
<media:credit>Win McNamee/Pool via REUTERS</media:credit>
<media:text>President Donald Trump addresses a joint session of Congress at the US Capitol on March 4, 2025.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd8l60e0jp07lqaep9yayi" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Does <strong>Donald Trump</strong>’s revolutionary start make the grade?</p><p>On Tuesday, America once again celebrated the great presidential tradition called “marking your own homework,” also known as the Joint Session of Congress address. You didn’t need to sit through all 99 minutes of Trump’s peroration to know that he gave himself an A++ on his first six weeks in office.</p><p>“We have accomplished more in 43 days than most administrations accomplished in four years, or eight years, and we are just getting started,” Trump said, causing half the room to explode in applause while the other side sat and waved little paper signs of protest.</p><p>The thundering braggadocio of the speech came across with all the subtlety of a revving Harley-Davidson on the Vegas Strip, but give Trump this: He promised radical change, and he has overdelivered. Bigly. Too many politicians promise roses and deliver thorns.</p><p>Trump is doing what he has always done: go over the top. His biggest win so far has been the southern border, where his policies have brought illegal migration to a crashing halt. Democrats blew that issue and paid the price. With over 100 executive orders and 400 executive actions, public brawls with world leaders, a pivot into the open claws of <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong>, and the daily grumblings of his imperialist appetite for land expansion, the transition to Trump has been a transformation of Washington. 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue looks more like Fury Road in the “Mad Max” series, complete with a chain-saw-wielding sidekick.</p><p>Democrats look helpless, trying to choke down one half-digested policy—cancel USAID, cut off US intelligence to Ukraine, buy Gaza — as another one is jammed down their throats. You could give their entire party a political Heimlich maneuver, and they still wouldn’t be able to catch their breath.</p><h3>Trump’s Deal Chaos</h3><p>The rapid-fire, jump-cut scenes of Trump interventions — 25% tariffs on everything from Canada … except energy … and wait … not on cars for a month … or agriculture … or now … BREAKING NEWS today with Trump <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/114116432894994278"><u>suspending</u></a> tariffs for Mexico and <a target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/live/2025/03/06/us/trump-administration-news#trump-mexico-tariffs-suspended">Canada</a> on anything that falls under the USMCA, but only until April 2 — might as well come with those photosensitivity warnings you see before shows that include flashing lights: Ladies and gentlemen, the barrage of conflicting policy announcements may cause Democratic seizures.</p><p>One thing is certain: The volatility is causing seizures in the markets, which are whipsawing up and down.</p><p>But if Trump gets to grade himself, maybe it’s time for a more objective report card. Let’s use two criteria: Trump as a dealmaker and Trump as a manager.</p><p>The Platonic ideal of Trump, taken from his ghostwritten book, “The Art of the Deal,” is that he is the greatest dealmaker in history. Want to end the war in Ukraine? Easy-peasy. That should take 24 hours. Well, that deal, whatever it was supposed to be, never materialized.</p><p>Trump is now trying to hustle a mineral deal out of Ukraine by shaking down President <strong>Volodymyr Zelensky</strong> in public, falsely claiming that Ukraine started the war and that Zelensky is the dictator. Trump says that he and his pal <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong> (“We had to go through the Russian <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/trump-suggests-putin-was-victim-russia-scandal-reaching-new-low-rcna194488"><u>hoax</u></a> together”) are trying to pin Zelensky down for peace. The president claims the US has given $300 billion in aid to Ukraine, when it is actually <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cfr.org/article/how-much-us-aid-going-ukraine"><u>$175 billion</u></a>—and much of that going to US companies. Still, he’s demanding a $500 billion rare earth mineral deal as compensation and the key to a peace deal. “And they shall beat their swords into … Promethium, and their spears into Scandium,” to twist the old biblical saying.</p><p>In any case, that deal also fell through after he and Vice President <strong>JD Vance</strong> berated Zelensky in a stunning public press conference last Friday in the Oval Office. But it is the substance of the deal, not just the politics, that is also in question. Does Ukraine really have rare earth materials that could be worth that kind of money? Is there really a big prize here? Not according to expert <strong>Javier Blas</strong>, who <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-02-19/trump-s-insistence-ukraine-has-rare-earth-elements-is-wrong?accessToken=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJzb3VyY2UiOiJTdWJzY3JpYmVyR2lmdGVkQXJ0aWNsZSIsImlhdCI6MTczOTk1Mjk3OCwiZXhwIjoxNzQwNTU3Nzc4LCJhcnRpY2xlSWQiOiJTUldaOElEV1JHRzAwMCIsImJjb25uZWN0SWQiOiI0NEMyQzc4RTVBMjQ0NjdDOTU5MDI0NjRBQjUwQ0U2MSJ9.AUGgELhGWI8WZONll_P-dj1bQKtCcyyJWoYgVLAZJAU&amp;embedded-checkout=true"><u>wrote in Bloomberg</u></a> that “Ukraine has no significant rare earth deposits other than small scandium mines.” He points out that the US Geological Survey also doesn’t confirm that Ukraine has any rare earth reserves. “Simply put, ‘follow the money’ doesn’t work here,” Blas writes. “At best, the value of all the world’s rare earth production rounds to $15 billion a year … That’s equal to the value of just two days of global oil output. Even if Ukraine had gigantic deposits, they wouldn’t be that valuable in geo-economic terms.”</p><p>So, even if Trump gets the mineral deal, what’s it worth? It is a political win at best, but at the expense of ditching US allies in Europe, letting down Ukraine, and handing Putin a massive victory.</p><p>Is that a good deal?</p><h3>Trump’s Tariff-ization</h3><p><strong>What about tariffs?&nbsp;</strong>So far, the tariffs on Canada, Mexico, and China have proven to be an economic downer, and now Trump is rolling them back, fudging, and shifting as the trade war escalates. States like Kentucky that export to Canada are getting hurt. Prices are going up. The premier of Ontario is threatening to put 25% tariffs on electricity exports to three northern US states. Is this the deal people wanted?</p><p>And even if tariffs do bring back some US jobs in the long run, which is very possible, Trump has made the United States an unreliable trading and security partner. Who wants to sign a trade deal with him now, knowing he could rip it up or change his mind at any moment? What company wants to invest in long-term deals if there is no promise of stability? Do NATO countries still trust that the US would be a backstop? A deal today is gone tomorrow.</p><p>Perhaps this is all just the grinding gears of change. It’s only been 45 days, after all. Maybe the radical surgery Trump and <strong>Elon Musk</strong> are performing on the sclerotic body of the US government is needed and will make things more efficient. But so far, that has not been the case.</p><p>For now, inflation is back up, prices are up, allies are fleeing, and the markets are down. And this is just the start. It could get worse.</p><p>All this got me thinking about <strong>Clayton Christensen</strong>, the great thinker I had the chance to interview years ago. Back in 1997, he wrote the seminal book “The Innovator’s Dilemma” about how disruption happens, but he may just as well have been writing about what Trump and Musk are doing domestically and internationally today.</p><p>“Many think of management as cutting deals and laying people off and hiring people and buying and selling companies,” Christensen wrote. “That’s not management, that's dealmaking. Management is the opportunity to help people become better people. Practiced that way, it’s a magnificent profession.”</p><p>By that measure, we are clearly in the dealmaking phase of the Trump presidency. And the marks on that, so far, are not good<strong>.&nbsp;</strong>His big win on illegal immigration and Musk’s hacksawing of government must be measured against the chaos around the economy, the tanking markets, and the rise in inflation. Trump’s foreign policy deals have been a calamity for US allies, from the abandonment of Ukraine, the alienation of the EU, and the threats to and tariffs on Canada and Mexico, not to mention the pitch to take over Gaza. Russia is the big winner so far, so if that’s on the scorecard, you get the Cyrillic version of an A. <em>Otlichnyy!</em></p><p>As far as grading the management of the United States? Helping people become better people? The report card on the magnificent profession reads: More work needs to be done. Fast.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Make America … Alone?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/make-america-alone</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg340okxjc07myk5zy29gy</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 27 Feb 2025 20:10:49 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>us foreign policy</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>isolationism</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Is the free world lost without America, or is America lost without the free world? GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon weighs in and asks for your thoughts.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd802ydzqk07lqzbhpa4e6" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Paige Fusco</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd802ydzqk07lqzbhpa4e6" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Is the free world lost without America, or is America lost without the free world? We are looking for your answers today.</p><p>It’s a question no one thought about when <strong>Donald Trump</strong> assumed office just 38 days ago.</p><p>Though he promised to be a transformative, “drain the swamp,” America First leader, Trump 2.0 is exponentially more radical and less restrained than his first term as the 45th president.</p><p>In less than five weeks, Trump has upended the postwar world order, forcing America’s longtime allies to redraw their maps, literally in the case of the Gulf of Mexico/America and strategically in every other way. It is a new world.</p><p>To Trump supporters, he is simply fulfilling his campaign promise of delivering deep change to the “deep state.” After all, with a clean sweep of the presidency, Congress, and the popular vote, he has a genuine mandate — one that is strengthened by a right-leaning majority on the Supreme Court. Cue <strong>Elon Musk</strong>’s DOGE <a target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/21/us/politics/elon-musk-doge-cpac-chainsaw.html"><u>chain saw</u></a>.</p><p>But let’s pause for a moment and ask what exactly was included in the promise to make America great again:</p><ul><li><strong>Tax cuts?</strong> Those are coming as he just won a big victory in the House of Representatives on that.</li><li><strong>Cutting the size of government?</strong> Sure. Finding inefficiencies matters.</li><li><strong>Border security and cutting down on illegal immigration?</strong> That has already started, and he has support on that too from a wide array of voters.</li><li><strong>Ending the war in Ukraine?</strong> Yes. Who would be against that in principle?</li></ul><p>But the details of these things matter. You can treat a broken foot by amputating the whole leg with a chain saw, but then you can’t walk. In less than 40 days of mass policy amputations, you might start getting the sense that the treatment is already worse than the disease.</p><p>For example, do Republican voters, who wanted a more isolationist foreign policy, really want the US to take over the Gaza Strip? What part of the MAGA agenda saw that one coming?</p><p>Do they want to take over Canada, Greenland, and the Panama Canal too? Imperial land grabs were never part of Trump’s campaign promises.</p><p>What about threatening to destroy Canada’s economy in a trade war? Was that part of the promise? Because that’s a lot different from negotiating better trade deals with friends.</p><p>Trump is threatening to slap a 25% tariff on all EU goods because he argues, wrongly, that the EU was created in order to “screw the United States.” It was not. The EU was formed out of a desire for stability on a continent that had bled through two world wars. Do Trump supporters really think Russia is a better ally than the European Union?</p><p>What about the war in Afghanistan? Do MAGA supporters genuinely want US troops to go <em>back</em> to Afghanistan and take over the Bagram Air Base as the president promised on Wednesday? “We are going to keep Bagram,” he <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKTZYgdy4Os"><u>announced</u></a>. “We are going to keep a small force on Bagram.” A small force? How small? Trump believes Bagram has strategic importance as a forward operating base near China and its nuclear weapons. He also wants to take back the over $7 billion worth of military equipment that the Biden administration left there in 2021. How will he do all this? With another invasion of Afghanistan?</p><p>Maybe Republican voters believed Trump would end the war in Ukraine in 24 hours, but did that include siding with Russia, blaming Ukraine for starting the conflict, and calling President <strong>Volodymyr Zelensky</strong>, not <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong>, a dictator?</p><p>This past week at the UN, the US sided with Russia, Belarus, and North Korea against a resolution to mark the third anniversary of the Russian invasion. “This war is far more important to Europe than it is to us,” Trump said as he moved the US further away from its longtime allies. “We have a big, beautiful ocean as separation.”</p><p>Separation. That is the watchword of the moment. The Trump revolution that is meant to Make America Great Again is making America Alone and for the very first time.</p><p>The costs of reversing 80 years of US foreign and domestic policy are still being calculated, but here is one measure: A recent <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://leger360.com/us-as-ally/"><u>Leger</u></a> poll found that more than a quarter of Canadians, 27%, now regard the US as the “enemy.” The enemy. Meanwhile, 56% of Americans view Canada as an ally, while only 30% of Canadians see the US as an ally.</p><p>These are remarkable pieces of data, especially for countries that fought side by side in Afghanistan, Korea, and two world wars and worked together on countless peacekeeping missions.</p><p>To its closest allies, the US is giving away its reputation as the “indispensable nation” and risks becoming an indefensible nation.</p><p>Yesterday, Trump announced his new “gold card” idea targeted at “wealthy people” around the world. “We’re going to be putting a price on that card of about $5 million and that’s going to give you green card privileges, plus it’s going to be a route to citizenship," he said. Would he welcome Russian oligarchs to the program? There was no hesitation. “Yeah, possibly,” he said with a smile. “Hey, I know some Russian oligarchs that are very nice people.”</p><p>If you can afford the $5 million gold card, you are nice enough for America these days, even if you are a Russian thug.</p><p>Russia and China are cheering on this new alignment because it comes at a cheap price. Both are poised to test the limits of a world without US guardrails, a world where there is no global cop on the beat to enforce the rule of law. Watch to see how China moves to expand its influence in the South China Sea, around Japan and the Philippines, and, of course, Taiwan. Russia is already clamoring to digest 20% of Ukraine, with Trump’s blessing. Does anyone think that’s enough to satisfy Putin’s imperialist appetite?</p><p>What will this mean for global trade, where US enforcement of secure shipping lanes has been the foundational insurance policy of globalization? It is why you can buy such cheap goods from around the world at places like Costco. That backstopping of sea-lane security is now as up for grabs as the Panama Canal. As <strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> says, this is now the law of the jungle.</p><p>All these are deeply polarizing questions, and coming at such a pace that people may take refuge in the certainty of partisanship to avoid the hard work of answering them.</p><p>So I want to ask you for your thoughts. Do you think the US is still a trusted ally to its longtime friends in democracies around the world? Do you consider the US an ally to its fellow NATO members, an enemy, or just neutral?</p><p>We would love to hear your thoughts on this. Please email us <a>here</a>.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Trump through the looking glass</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/trump-through-the-looking-glass</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg2riwkwbe07myg1a7a3jr</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 20 Feb 2025 20:40:39 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>vladimir putin</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>europe</category>
<category>russia</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>nato</category>
<category>the upside down</category>
<category>ukraine</category>
<category>alice in wonderland</category>
<category>washington</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>The shocking US pivot to Russia has sent the world through the political looking glass and into the upside-down era of Trumpland. Is the US abandoning its historic allies in NATO, Europe, and Canada in favor of … Russia? The short answer is yes, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon. For now.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd7h3fd8r607myk5xjw7ky" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Luisa Vieira</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd7h3fd8r607myk5xjw7ky" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The shocking US pivot to Russia has sent the world through the political looking glass and into the upside-down era of Trumpland. Is the US abandoning its historic allies in NATO, Europe, and Canada in favor of … Russia?</p><p>The short answer is yes. For now.</p><p>Let’s start with exhibit A: the inversion of facts to justify the abandonment of Ukraine.</p><p>President <strong>Donald Trump</strong> has, to steal a Lewis Carroll phrase by the QAnon movement, followed the white rabbit down the disinformation hole. According to him, Ukraine started the war, not Russia. “You should’ve never started it,” Trump said this week about Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. “You could’ve made a deal.”</p><p>Wait, what?</p><p>Didn’t the war start when Vladimir Putin invaded Crimea in 2014? Didn’t it escalate when he invaded the country — three years ago this Saturday — in February 2022, bombing cities and trying to assassinate Zelensky?</p><p>Those are the facts that NATO nations have long accepted … because they are true. Putin was the dictator who started the war, and Zelensky the defender of democracy.</p><p>Not for Trump.</p><p>He now calls Zelensky “a Dictator without Elections,” not Putin. Parroting Russian propaganda, Trump claims that Zelensky has only 4% support in his country and so has no standing to be part of the peace negotiations.</p><p>“Curiouser and curiouser,” as Alice said, gazing around the new world of Wonderland. This just doesn’t make much sense.</p><p>Once you go through the political looking glass, the flow of disinformation threatens to overwhelm reality. Fact-checking is suddenly seen as a radical form of partisanship, but it shouldn’t be. Facts are facts. The truth is, in the last presidential election, Zelensky won 73% of the vote. It is also true that, since then, the war and martial law in Ukraine delayed the elections that were scheduled for last May, and concerns about that are legitimate. But as the UK prime minister pointed out, during World War II, Britain also suspended elections.</p><p>Zelensky responded in fury, saying that Trump “lives in this disinformation space.”</p><p>Europe is reeling at the pivot — suddenly aware that their closest ally and friend has shifted toward Russia. European leaders, who have been holding a series of emergency meetings, are now realizing that if they want to defend themselves from Russia, they have to do it themselves. It’s not so much a wake-up call as a lifesaving shock from a political defibrillator. But it will be expensive and fraught with internal obstacles.</p><p>The sense of betrayal in the EU is overwhelming. <strong>Kaja Kallas</strong>, vice president of the European Commission, described this as “appeasement,” while <strong>Friedrich Merz</strong>, the man most likely to lead Germany after Sunday’s election, called it “a classic reversal of the role of perpetrator and victim.”</p><p>Even former British Prime Minster <strong>Boris Johnson</strong>, who supports the idea of helping Trump end the war, couldn’t defend the absurdity of Trump’s view. “Of course Ukraine didn’t start the war. You might as well say that America attacked Japan at Pearl Harbor,” he wrote.</p><p>The truth is that European leaders are in full panic, watching the postwar multilateral world they worked so hard to build on the foundation of US support collapse.</p><p>Meanwhile, the Russians aren’t just throwing a Lewis Carroll-like tea party but a Kremlin-sponsored vodka chug-a-thon. The Russians have long courted far-right MAGA types like <strong>Tucker Carlson</strong> through their common interest in fighting “woke” culture and promoting Christian nationalism — all while maintaining their focus on weakening NATO and breaking up the alliance. Even they can’t believe their success.</p><p>“If you’d told me just three months ago that these were the words of the US president, I would have laughed out loud,” <strong>Dmitry Medvedev</strong>, the former Russian president <a target="_blank" href="https://x.com/MedvedevRussiaE/status/1892289659603910745"><u>wrote</u></a>, not bothering to hide his gloating. “Trump is 200 percent right.”</p><p>“He is the first, and so far, in my opinion, the only Western leader who has publicly and loudly said that one of the root causes of the Ukrainian situation was the impudent line of the previous administration to draw Ukraine into NATO,” said Russian Foreign Minister <strong>Sergei Lavrov</strong>, cementing Russian propaganda as a Trumpian truth.</p><p>As I argued last week, this is part of Trump’s <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/trumps-empire-state-of-mind"><u>empire state of mind</u></a>, his neo-imperialist goal of dividing the world into spheres of influence controlled by strongman leaders in countries like Russia and China. China is seeing all this through the lens of invading Taiwan, something that must look far more palatable to the current US administration as it retreats from its role as a global police officer and looks increasingly likely to join the mob looting weaker sovereign territories. Small countries who get in the way — Ukraine in this case, the Panamanians in another, and maybe Taiwan — have little or no say in the outcomes.</p><p>Other countries that have been threatened by Trump, like Canada, are watching nervously. After all, the propaganda Putin uses to talk about Ukraine — there is an artificial border where one never should have existed, that Ukrainians actually <em>want</em> Russia to come and protect them — sounds eerily familiar to the language Trump has used about Canada. He has called the US-Canada border an “artificially drawn line” and claimed, without proof, that most Canadians would welcome the US taking over the country to offer protection.</p><p>Earlier today, just hours before the 4 Nations hockey final between the US and Canada, Trump made it political. The event has been supercharged by the political climate to the point where Canadian fans booed the US national anthem during a round-robin matchup last weekend in Montreal. Expect the Canadian anthem to receive a similar treatment tonight in Boston. “I’ll be calling our GREAT American Hockey Team this morning to spur them on towards victory tonight against Canada, which with FAR LOWER TAXES AND MUCH STRONGER SECURITY, will someday, maybe soon, become our cherished, and very important, Fifty First State,” Trump <a target="_blank" href="https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/114036421460956478">posted</a>.</p><p>The threats are by now familiar, but the pivot toward Russia adds a more concerning element. Once he went through the looking glass and accepted the lie that Ukraine started the war, Trump implicitly accepted the idea that a manufactured threat can be a justifiable pretext for the most radical action.</p><p>Trump 1.0 already used the pretext of national security to slap tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum, and his Trump 2.0 tariff wars and threats are no different. What happens when Canada responds in kind with reciprocal tariffs designed to hurt the US economically? Will it be long before Canada is accused of <em>starting</em> the tariff war? Does that quickly evolve into a pretext for more drastic US action to make Canada the 51st state? After all, it is just … self-defense.</p><p>All this sounds like phantasmagorical, political hyperventilating, and frankly paranoid. The rhetoric about the US taking over Canada the way Russia invaded Ukraine must be a joke, a trick to gain the upper hand in good old-fashioned trade negotiations. Right? Right?</p><p>Let’s hope.</p><p>But then, Trump has a Napoleonic view of his powers and the rule of law. “He who saves his Country does not violate any Law,” he <a target="_blank" href="https://x.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1890831570535055759">posted</a> on social media last weekend. If he does not see himself bound by US constitutional law, why would he feel bound by international law?</p><p>This US pivot toward Russia marks the most dangerous threat to the multilateral world’s adherence to the rule of law and the NATO alliance in general. It is not a bug of the Trump presidency; it is a feature. Everything has changed. “I can’t go back to yesterday because I was a different person then,” Alice says as she absorbs what has happened to her.</p><p>The Western world can’t go back either. There is malice in Wonderland now, and it is no longer just Russia; it’s the United States itself.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Trump’s Empire State of Mind</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/trumps-empire-state-of-mind</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg2fmhlm3y07lqamhzweky</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 13 Feb 2025 20:02:26 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>realism</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>imperialism</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>From his threats to make Canada the 51st state, buy Greenland, reclaim the Panama Canal, and, almost implausibly, “take” the Gaza Strip, Trump isn’t hiding his imperial ambitions. In his inaugural address, he explicitly said he sees an America that “expands its territory.” Is he serious, and, if so, what does it mean for its closest neighbor and biggest partner, Canada? GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon weighs in.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd6y3fd8by07mydl74b7rh" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1920" height="1080">
<media:credit>Jess Frampton</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd6y3fd8by07mydl74b7rh" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Donald Trump</strong> has an empire state of mind.</p><p>From his threats to make Canada the 51st state, buy Greenland, reclaim the Panama Canal, and, almost implausibly, “take” the Gaza Strip, Trump isn’t hiding his imperial ambitions. In his inaugural address, he explicitly said he sees an America that “expands its territory.” Is he serious about this, and, if so, what does it mean for its closest neighbor and biggest partner, Canada?</p><p>Let’s start with the first question: Is territorial expansion a real threat or just rhetoric he is using to shake down opponents in trade negotiations? It’s both. Trump is using these threats to gain better access to markets for American goods, and he’s flexing his imperial desires.</p><p>No moment better illustrated Trump’s empire state of mind than on Tuesday, when he met <strong>King</strong> <strong>Abdullah II</strong> of Jordan at the White House. With Trump’s radical promise to take Gaza and <a target="_blank" href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c07kpjyzgllo"> <u>“clean out that whole thing</u></a> ” — choice words not lost on anyone remotely familiar with the worst crimes under international law — the meeting was expected to be about as uncomfortable for the royal as a crown of porcupine quills. But it got even more interesting than expected.</p><p>The president was asked how he would buy Gaza, as he had initially proposed. “We’re not going to have to buy,” he said. “We’re going to <em>have</em> Gaza. We don’t have to buy. There’s nothing to buy. We will have Gaza.”</p><p>We will <em>have</em> Gaza.</p><p>Pause there for a moment because that was a foundational shift in US policy. The president of the United States declared he could unilaterally pluck up pieces of land the US has no legitimate claim over in blatant violation of international law. Because the statement was so shocking, Trump was immediately asked to clarify. You won’t even buy it?</p><p>TRUMP: No reason to buy. There is nothing to buy. It’s Gaza. It’s a war-torn area. We’re going to <em>take</em> it. We’re going to hold it. We’re going to cherish it.</p><p>We are going to “take” it.</p><p>The next moment was the one that Canadians, Greenlanders, and Panamanians took to heart.</p><p>The king was visibly uncomfortable with what he and every Arab leader have said is a totally unacceptable idea, so he tried to deflect a confrontation, saying the Arab leaders would propose a solution, but then Trump doubled down.</p><p>“Mr. President,” a journalist asked, “take it under what authority? It is sovereign territory.”<br><br>“Under the US authority,” the president answered, as if that was enough.</p><p>This is exactly the law of the jungle we described in Eurasia Group’s <a target="_blank" href="https://www.eurasiagroup.net/live-post/risk-1-the-g-zero-wins"><u>2025 Top Risks Report</u></a>, where international laws and norms — the same laws and norms the US built and underpinned after World War II — are no longer enforced. Under this rule, strong countries — the United States, China, and Russia — divvy up the world into their own imperial spheres of influence. In a cogent piece this week in the Financial Times, <strong>Gideon Rachman</strong> <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.ft.com/content/8d1afb00-57ee-4b59-abe3-df0ff18084fb"><u>called</u></a> this the age of neo-imperialism, a world “based around spheres of influence — with the US concentrating on the Western Hemisphere, Russia on Eastern Europe, and China on East Asia.”</p><p>It is exactly right. This week, Trump and Russian President <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong> had a long phone call during which – without input from Ukraine – they appeared to unilaterally decide the terms on which the war, which Russia started, would end. On favorable terms for Russia. How do we know? Because US Defense Secretary <strong>Pete Hegseth</strong> said the same day while he was in Europe that Ukraine joining NATO is now off the table and that US support for Ukraine and European defense is a low priority. Putin must be popping vodka bottle tops. His war aims have been largely vindicated.</p><p>More importantly, it shores up Rachman’s thesis that Trump is reverting to the imperial spheres of influence model, where great powers gobble up land in their orbits and let other great powers, like Russia and China, do it in theirs. The empire state of mind in action.</p><p>How should Canada read this?</p><p>On his way to the Super Bowl, Trump was asked by Fox News’ <strong>Bret Baier</strong> whether taking over Canada is a real goal. “Yes it is,” Trump <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2025/02/09/trump-confirms-hes-serious-about-wanting-canada-as-51st-state/"><u>responded</u></a> before sharing his rationale that Canada, in his view, is a leech on the American economy and military and that he believes it should be the 51st state. So, yes, he is serious about it.</p><p>Again, not to be a scold, but facts should matter here. On that day, Trump’s rationale for taking over Canada was a “$200 billion” deficit. That is wrong. According to Stats Canada, in 2023, the trade deficit was $94 billion, which includes the cheap energy Canada supplies. But to the empire state of mind, facts don’t matter. Neither does the rationale. Today, it could be about trade deficits, fentanyl, and illegal immigration, and tomorrow, it could be about banking or cars. The goalposts will shift. All that matters is what the US wants to “take.” The rest is pretext and commentary.</p><p>So how could Trump take Canada by “economic force”? Again, the president is not hiding his plan.</p><p><strong>Step one: Weaken the Canadian economy with devastating tariffs.</strong></p><p>The 25% tariffs on steel and aluminum will be punishing for Ontario and Quebec but not existential. That is just a start. Layer another 25% tariff on all Canadian goods crossing the border, and there will be a meltdown.</p><p>“If we stop allowing them to make cars — through tariffs and other things: cars, trucks, etc., what they make — they’re not viable as a country,” Trump told Baier in a chilling moment.</p><p><strong>Step two: Sow divisions in Canada.</strong> By excluding energy from his threats — or by putting much lower tariffs on energy than on other goods – Trump heats up East-West tensions in Canada that have long been on a medium boil.</p><p>It also has the benefit of self-interest. The US needs Alberta energy for its Midwest refineries. Otherwise, voters there will see a price jump at the pumps. So, Trump cuts Alberta a break. The rest of Canada, meanwhile, will want to retaliate against his tariffs, and energy is a powerful weapon in the arsenal. The Alberta premier has said that is a no-go. Other leaders are not ruling it out. If – no, when – the tariffs come, the external threat of Trump will be strengthened by the internal disputes within Canada.</p><p><strong>Step 3: Spread disinformation.&nbsp;</strong>Separatism has always been an issue between English-speaking provinces and French-speaking Quebec. The separatist PQ party has been steadily on the rise in Quebec, with the promise of a referendum in the near future. Fomenting that movement with more disinformation is not out of the question for a president who wants to swallow up Canada and take its minerals, water, and access to the Arctic.</p><p>These could add up to the “winning conditions” Trump needs. Does he start with an offer to let part of Canada split off and join the union? Maybe. Suddenly, Canada is in fragments and ready to be swallowed up, bite by bite.</p><p>Of course, this is all dark speculation. Annexing Canada is not just a matter of political barking any more than it was in the War of 1812, when taking Canada was supposed to be a mere matter of marching. It wasn’t then, and it won’t be today.</p><p>Former Canadian Prime Minister <strong>Stephen Harper</strong> was roundly celebrated by leaders of all parties when he said, “I would be prepared to impoverish the country and not be annexed, if that was the option we’re facing.” Trump’s threats have led to a dramatic spike in Canadian patriotism. Canada is gearing up for a fight it doesn’t want or need. The US is picking a fight to win a prize it already has: free and fair trade with its best friend.</p><p>The empire state of mind, however, doesn’t allow for the logic of mutual benefit. It is a radical shift in global politics and a warning to countries that once called themselves allies, neighbors, and friends.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Exclusive New Poll: US-Canada – Tariff-ied of What’s to Come?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/exclusive-new-poll-us-canada-tariff-ied-of-whats-to-come</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg1ru0ljjq07lqnamryymp</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 30 Jan 2025 19:05:33 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>american views of canadians</category>
<category>tariffs</category>
<category>abacus data</category>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>trade</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>It’s not a beautiful day in the North American neighborhood. Two days before the Feb. 1 deadline Donald Trump set to impose tariffs on Canada, Abacus Data and GZERO Media have an exclusive new poll on American attitudes toward their closest ally and neighbor. Publisher Evan Solomon dives into the numbers and what they mean.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd5wemdwcr07lqdv6g6hpk" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd5wemdwcr07lqdv6g6hpk" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Won’t you be my … frenemy?<br><br>It’s not a beautiful day in the North American neighborhood. Two days before the Feb. 1 deadline <strong>Donald Trump</strong> set to impose tariffs on Canada, Abacus Data and GZERO Media have an exclusive new poll on American attitudes toward their closest ally and neighbor. The upshot? This is the dawn of the new age of the <em>political frenemy.</em> Longtime American allies like Canada have reshaped their view of their largest trading partner into something much more threatening, going from friend to frenemy.</p><p>The <strong>Abacus Data-GZERO</strong> poll surveyed 1,500 Americans on politically radioactive issues like tariffs, fentanyl, and immigration. On the big one, tariffs, 47% of Trump voters support a 25% tariff on Canadian goods, while 67% of Democrats oppose it. Why the split? Republicans see it as a pain-free exercise. Only 19% of Trump voters believe tariffs on Canada will have a negative impact on them, as opposed to 65% of Democrat voters. “It’s striking how many Trump supporters appear unfazed by the impact of tariffs or Canadian retaliation,” says <strong>David Coletto</strong>, CEO of Abacus. “They may see it as cost-free now, but that blind spot could become a real liability if people start feeling the economic hit.”</p><figure><img src="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvr9ixfe6anq07mymvncc6vw" alt="exclusive-new-poll-us-canada-tariff-ied-of-whats-to-come-56121734.png" width="1200" height="581"><figcaption>Credit: Abacus Data</figcaption></figure><p>Abacus Data</p><p>Canadian officials have made an extraordinary effort to convince Americans that punishing Canada with high tariffs will drive up the cost of their goods, but it’s worked about as well as using winter boots to skate on ice. “Everything the American consumers buy from Canada is suddenly going to get a lot more expensive,” Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> told CNN a few weeks ago, using examples like energy. “Canadian energy powers American manufacturing, businesses, and homes,” he said.</p><p>Clearly this has not landed with Trump voters, who not only see tariffs as a net benefit to Americans but also believe that Canadians are taking advantage of them. That’s right, even though the free trade deal was negotiated by <strong>Ronald Reagan</strong> and Trump, somehow crafty ol’ Canada pulled a fast one on both of them. According to the poll, 67% of Trump voters believe the free trade pact benefits Canada “way more” than it does the US. Overall, 50% of Americans believe there is a huge trade deficit between the US and Canada, which means that Americans are basically “subsidizing” their northern neighbor.</p><figure><img src="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvr9ixvy6v8r07lqbyhra5dn" alt="exclusive-new-poll-us-canada-tariff-ied-of-whats-to-come-56121736.png" width="1200" height="582"><figcaption>Credit: Abacus Data</figcaption></figure><p>Abacus Data</p><p>That’s not true, by the way. The trade deficit between the US and Canada is not $250 billion, as Trump repeats, but less than $100 billion, mainly because Canada supplies the US with 24% of its energy, at a discounted price.</p><p>On immigration, there is another consequential gap between perception and reality. Fifty-four percent of Trump voters think “millions of illegal immigrants” come from Canada (44% of Americans overall believe this). The reality? It’s about 1% of the total number of immigrants crossing illegally into the US. And Canada just spent another <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.canada.ca/en/public-safety-canada/news/2024/12/government-of-canada-announces-its-plan-to-strengthen-border-security-and-our-immigration-system.html"><u>billion dollars</u></a> to stop that amount in hopes of appeasing Trump into calling off the tariffs.</p><p>Finally, on the other tariff trigger point: drugs. Thirty-two percent of Americans believe that a lot of the fentanyl that comes into the US originates in Canada. There are drug labs in Canada, for sure, but they account for less <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/30/world/canada/canada-fentanyl-trump.html"><u>than 1% of the fentanyl</u></a> that comes from places like Mexico, China, and other countries.</p><p>You might think from all this that the US really doesn’t like Canada, but here is the weird part:<strong>&nbsp;</strong>87% of Americans have a <em>positive</em> or <em>very positive&nbsp;</em>view of Canada, according to the poll. An optimist might see the fact that less than half of Trump supporters want these tariffs as evidence that he doesn’t really have a mandate from his base. So what is it?</p><p>“These findings paint a portrait of an American public torn between long-standing goodwill toward Canada and the view that Canada may be getting the better end of existing trade deals,” says Coletto. “On one hand, most Americans describe Canada as an ally … On the other hand, more than half believe Canada benefits ‘way more’ from free trade, echoing President Trump’s narrative that tariffs are needed to level the playing field.”</p><p>The partisan difference is notable, but geography matters as well. “Americans in border states register deeper anxiety about the fallout from a potential trade war,” Coletto says. “This underlines the importance of these border communities: Their direct exposure to cross-border trade could serve as a bellwether for how the broader American public will ultimately judge the practicality and fairness of tariffs.”</p><p>All this leaves a massive challenge in a very short time: Canadian leaders need to somehow convince Americans — or, more concretely, President Trump — that high tariffs on Canada will hurt Americans.</p><p>“The more Canadians can demonstrate that these punitive measures undermine shared prosperity, the likelier they are to sway uncertain or moderate Americans and mitigate the worst outcomes of an escalating trade dispute,” says Coletto. “But we also have to be aware that Trump voters are captive to his rhetoric, and what they think and feel is likely all he cares about.”</p><p>This is what the age of the frenemy looks like. Won’t you be my neighbor?</p><p>___________</p><p><em>To see the full Abacus Data-GZERO poll and David Coletto’s deep dive into the numbers, please click&nbsp;</em><a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://abacusdata.ca/what-americans-think-about-canada-tariffs-and-a-possible-trade-war-abacus-data-poll/"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The Big Tar-iffs: Will he or won’t he start a trade war?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/the-big-tar-iffs-will-he-or-wont-he-start-a-trade-war</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg1fjflihi07lqtf4spg48</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 23 Jan 2025 19:56:53 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>trade</category>
<category>tariffs</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>trade war</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon writes that Donald Trump’s planned tariffs mean the US and Canada are headed for a trade war they don’t need over a prize they both already have.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd5cfcd12r07myc71a6i84" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1181" height="671">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Yves Herman</media:credit>
<media:text>President Donald Trump makes a special address remotely during the 55th annual World Economic Forum meeting in Davos, Switzerland, on Jan. 23, 2025.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd5cfcd12r07myc71a6i84" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The big Trump <em>tar-“iff”</em> now has a <em>when</em>: Feb. 1.</p><p>That’s when the busy new US president has promised to slap 25% tariffs on both Canada and Mexico. In his virtual address to the folks attending the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, on Thursday, President <strong>Donald Trump</strong> again singled out Canada for harsh treatment. “We have a tremendous deficit with Canada,” he said, reiterating his usual inaccurate tariff mantra. Trump claims the trade deficit is between US$200 and US$250 billion a year when it is significantly less than half of that, mainly due to energy exports.</p><p>Trump then followed up with his favorite new expansionist taunt. “You can always become a state,” he said to Canadians. “If you’re a state, we won’t have a deficit. We won’t have to tariff you.”</p><p>But what he said next was more dire because it was aimed directly at the industries that are core to the Canadian economy. “We don’t need them to make our cars,” President Trump said. “We don’t need their lumber, because we have our own forests. We don’t need their oil and gas. We have more than anybody.” In other words, we don’t need Canada at all.</p><p>Cue the economic <em>peril</em> clutching.</p><p>Let’s slow-walk through all this.</p><h3>Will President Donald Trump really follow through with tariffs, or is it a negotiating tactic?</h3><p>Yes, tariffs are coming the way cold comes in winter. Why so certain? Our general rule is to take the president of the United States both seriously and literally. As Trump said in his inaugural address, tariffs are now his primary source of government revenue, not just a tool for negotiation.</p><p>“Instead of taxing our citizens to enrich other countries, we will tariff and tax foreign countries to enrich our citizens,” he announced. “It will be massive amounts of money pouring into our treasury coming from foreign sources.” He even floated the idea of an “External Revenue Service,” so tariffs are the flywheel in the engine that Trump promises will drive a golden age.</p><p>In his Davos speech on Thursday, the president emphasized the warning. “If you don’t make your product in America,” he said to a large group of CEOs, “then, very simply, you will have to pay a tariff, differing amounts, but a tariff which will direct hundreds of billions of dollars, even trillions of dollars, into our treasury to strengthen our economy and pay down debt.”</p><h3>Is he right that high tariffs will really work for the US?</h3><p>Not as promised. This is where the Trump math breaks down and politics and economics collide. Trump’s tariff threats will drive some businesses to keep factories in the US instead of, say, Canada. For example, this week Stellantis announced it was going to build the new Dodge Durango in Detroit and not move it to Canada as initially thought. It will also reopen a previously closed plant in Illinois to build another vehicle. So, expect some short-term “wins” from the America-first, protectionist agenda.</p><p>After all, in his first term, Trump used tariffs on goods like steel, aluminum, and products from China to more than double the amount the government collected from duties to about $111 billion.</p><p>Sounds like a lot, but it’s not. In 2023, the US government took in over $4.2 <em>trillion</em> in income and payroll tax. Even with 10% tariffs on all goods from China and 25% tariffs on Canadian and Mexican goods, the US government would take in only another $140 billion in 2025, according to the Committee for a Responsible Budget.</p><p>That’s not nearly enough to finance new tax cuts. For example, Trump has promised to extend his 2017 tax cuts in 2026. The Congressional Budget Office estimates doing so will cost about $4.7 trillion in lost revenue between now and 2035. That leaves a Grand Canyon-size hole that revenue from tariffs and savings from government cuts can never fill. Deficits will explode.</p><h3>So will tariffs really be 25% across the board on Canada and Mexico, or will President Trump come down to a more manageable level on a few select goods?</h3><p>That remains very unclear. The president didn’t slap these tariffs on week one, revealing they may have dropped as a symbolic priority for him. That opens up some room to maneuver to negotiate until the Feb. 1 deadline, and now there is even further hope for exceptions. The president has also asked for a report on trade and unfair practices to be delivered to him by April 1, which offers yet another potential delay in the tariff war. There will be lobbying, networking, and a full-bore strategy to give Canada some kind of carveout.</p><p>Still, neither date removes the possibility of the promised tariffs happening at some level. The president needs revenue, and tariffs are his preferred tool, despite the math.</p><h3>Will Canada retaliate dollar for dollar?</h3><p>Yes. The same strategy Canada deployed in Trump 1.0 during the steel and aluminum tariffs will be deployed again, and the list amounting to CA$37 billion worth of goods — including things like Florida Orange juice — is already made and ready to be deployed. After all, if Trump goes through with the tariffs, Canada could get pushed into a recession, with up to 5% of its GDP hit. While goods and services in both countries will get more expensive for citizens, it will hurt Canada much more for one reason: Canada sends almost three-quarters of its exports to the US, compared to just a little more than 17% of US exports crossing the other way.</p><h3>If there are 25% tariffs across the board, will Canada use the nuclear option and try to cut off energy exports to the US, risking a full national unity crisis?</h3><p>Very unclear. All the premiers and territory leaders met this week with <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> to align their retaliation strategy, which includes energy … except for Alberta Premier <strong>Danielle Smith</strong>, for whom any inclusion of fossil fuel exports in a trade war is strictly off-limits. This is the lifeblood of the Alberta economy, after all, and she is protective of her province. However, her position deeply hampers a united Canadian response and allows the new US administration to deploy a divide-and-conquer strategy, knowing they can absorb any trade shocks better than Canada, especially if they do not include energy.</p><h3>Is Trump still serious about taking over Canada by economic force?</h3><p>Unclear. That view has certainly created a surge of patriotism in Canada and escalated tough trade talk as politicians jockey to wear the “Captain Canada” label. But if there is a desire to have an integrated North American economy — newsflash! — we already have one.</p><p>Energy alone is the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cer-rec.gc.ca/en/data-analysis/facilities-we-regulate/canadas-pipeline-system/2021/crude-oil-pipeline-transportation-system.html"><u>best example</u></a>. The US imports 24% of its crude oil from Canada, and that is very hard to replace because US refineries are retooled to process Canadian heavy crude oil, not the kind of oil the US extracts from fracking. Not only that, when looking at all energy products that flow across the border, like natural gas, there is a combined network of pipelines in North America that is over <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.canadianenergycentre.ca/circling-the-earth-11-times-key-facts-about-the-canada-us-energy-pipeline-network/"><u>281,000 miles long</u></a>! With the free trade agreement, integrated fossil fuel pipelines, and hydroelectric systems in the East <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://connect2canada.com/2022/04/mapping-the-canada-u-s-energy-relationship-2/"><u>supplying electricity to the Northeastern states</u></a>, it would be hard to find two more interconnected economies anywhere in the world.<br><br>In other words, on Feb. 1, the US and Canada are headed for a trade war they don’t need over a prize they both already have.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Hot heads, cold comfort: How Trump is upending the race in Canada</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/hot-heads-cold-comfort-how-trump-is-upending-the-race-in-canada</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg12afkqqk07myuq06m302</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 16 Jan 2025 19:17:15 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>liberal party leadership</category>
<category>pierre poilievre</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>chrystia freeland</category>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>mark carney</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>With the changing of the guards in both the US and Canada, where are these two countries headed? For a hot trade war – and one made hotter by Donald Trump’s threats to take over Canada by escalating counter-threats from patriotic Canadian leaders who are locked in their own election cycle, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd4sixcs8007myw3cuovhp" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Dylan Martinez/Patrick Doyle/Chris Wattie/Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>Conservative Party of Canada leader Pierre Poilievre; Mark Carney, former Governor of the Banks of England and Canada; and Canada&apos;s former Foreign Minister Chrystia Freeland.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd4sixcs8007myw3cuovhp" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s an old saying: “If you do not change direction, you may end up where you are heading.” With the changing of the guards in both the US and Canada, where are these two countries headed?</p><p>The short answer? They’re headed for a hot trade war, one made hotter by <strong>Donald Trump’s</strong> threats to take over Canada by escalating counter-threats from patriotic Canadian leaders who are locked in their own election cycle. The political barometer is rising.</p><p>This has upended conventional wisdom about the political landscape in Canada, where the Liberals are in a leadership race (former Banks of Canada and England Governor <strong>Mark Carney</strong> announced his leadership bid in Edmonton today), and a federal election is likely to kick off at the end of March.</p><p>Just weeks ago, it was all about <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> and his legacy. The Conservatives, led by <strong>Pierre Poilievre</strong>, have been up in the polls, with a lead ranging from 20 to 25 points. That may well hold, but the election is no longer only about Trudeau. It is also about Trump’s threat to take over Canada and which leader has the best response.</p><p>Outside threats have a way of healing some internal divisions and, already, we’ve seen two long-time former prime ministers, Stephen Harper, a conservative, and Jean Chretien, a Liberal, speak out forcefully against Trump’s threat. That catalyzed all political leaders to boost their own tough patriotic talk as<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://angusreid.org/canada-51st-state-trump/"> <u>polls</u></a> show the vast majority of Canadians reject Trump’s expansionist dream.</p><p>A common outside threat doesn’t help an opposition party looking to focus on domestic issues, but it also creates new internal divisions.</p><p>For example, Ontario’s Premier <strong>Doug Ford</strong> believes Canada must retaliate against the US with every weapon possible, including cutting energy supplies, while Alberta Premier <strong>Danielle Smith</strong> says cutting off energy exports will spark a national unity crisis. She wants it off the table. Smith went to visit President-elect Trump in Mar-a-Lago to get an exemption for Alberta energy, where she was joined by the self-appointed champion of Trump’s Canadian union strategy, <strong>Kevin O’Leary</strong>.</p><p>Will Poilievre side with Smith on the energy issue, and if so, does that risk being linked to O’Leary, who openly supports an economic union between the US and Canada? Or, will a new Liberal leader side with Ford and drive the old East vs. West internal tensions at a time when unity is needed?</p><p>The Canadian federal election cycle and the Liberal leadership race are now being driven by three factors:</p><p>Change. The Economy. And Trump.</p><p>All of Canada’s leadership candidates are pitching themselves as a change from Trudeau, especially the Liberal contenders, which is a harder case to make than it is for Poilievre.</p><p>On Monday, <strong>Mark Carney</strong> <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zs8St-fF0kE"><u>soft launched his campaign</u></a> on “The Daily Show with Jon Stewart,” calling himself an “outsider” and talking about his long economic experience in dealing with serious disruptions like the 2008 financial collapse. (Disclosure: Carney is a close family friend, and <strong>Diana Fox-Carney</strong> is an adviser at Eurasia Group, our parent company). Former Finance Minister <strong>Chrystia Freeland</strong> is also expected to launch her bid, with reports saying she will try to position herself as a change candidate by scrapping the carbon tax, a policy she long championed that has become controversial.</p><p>So defining yourself as a change candidate is vital. When it comes to the economy, inflation and home prices are still crucial to the domestic agenda, but will these drop back as the impact of the Trump tariffs is felt? Expect the tariffs to dominate the economic agenda if they come next week.</p><p>Does changing the focus of the upcoming federal election to an outside threat change the current polls? That will be the most critical question in the next Canadian federal election. Trump is now the most disruptive and important political figure in Canada, and every day he makes that more clear.</p><p>For example, as the California fires raged, the president-elect talked covetously about water from Canada, claiming – erroneously – that water from Canada would have prevented the California fires. “When I was President, I demanded that this guy, the governor (of California), accept the water coming from the north, from way up in Canada,” Trump told Newsmax, likely referring to the Columbia River. “It flows down right through Los Angeles … They would have had so much water they wouldn’t have known what to do with it. You would have never had the fires.”</p><p>Like Trump’s claims about the US subsidizing Canada to the tune of $100 billion – most recently debunked by economist <strong>Jim Stanford</strong> in<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://centreforfuturework.ca/2025/01/12/whos-subsidizing-whom/"> <u>this</u></a> report from the Center for Future Work – this is provocative but false. The Columbia River flows through Washington state and parts of Oregon before emptying into the Pacific Ocean, but it never reaches Los Angeles. And this water issue isn’t some new thing either. In 1961, the US and Canada signed the<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.state.gov/columbia-river-treaty/"> <u>Columbia River Treaty</u></a>, a treaty that has been under renegotiation since 2018. Those 15 rounds of negotiations have never included bringing water to LA.</p><p>Still, these kinds of jabs, taunts, and threats make Trump the leading opposition figure in Canada, the person changing the direction of politics. Every leader in Canada – whether they like it or not – is now forced to run primarily against Trump, not Trudeau.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>51st or Fight: Trudeau leaves, Trump Arrives</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/51st-or-fight-trudeau-leaves-trump-arrives</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrg0p02kpmx07myohl05cwp</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 09 Jan 2025 20:23:10 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>51st state</category>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Justin Trudeau is leaving you, Donald Trump is coming for you. The timing couldn’t be worse. The threat couldn’t be bigger. The solutions couldn’t be more elusive, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd48wlcqnb07myjhwbv1wo" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Paige Fusco</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd48wlcqnb07myjhwbv1wo" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> is leaving you, <strong>Donald Trump</strong> is coming for you.</p><p>The timing couldn’t be worse. The threat couldn’t be bigger. The solutions couldn’t be more elusive.</p><p>Canada and the US are headed for a serious and economically dangerous trade war in less than two weeks, and President-elect <strong>Donald Trump</strong>, seeing Canada in a vulnerable leadership moment, smells blood.</p><p>In politics, as in most things, there is no opponent more powerful than time and, after nine years in power, time crushed <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>’s political career. The “Sunny Ways” majority government of 2015 for Trudeau gave way to the medieval darkness of his current minority government, beset by dire polls, recurring scandals, and painful internal betrayals. What happened?</p><p>In short, there were no new policy ideas to bring back the light. The list of victories that Trudeau mentioned in his resignation speech (some genuinely transformative, others still deeply divisive) — the Canada Child Benefit that lifted over 300,000 children out of poverty (child poverty rates in Canada are now going back up), the first G7 country to put a price on carbon, renegotiating NAFTA, leading the country through the pandemic, legalizing cannabis and medically assisted dying, negotiating a health accord with the provinces, bringing in universal daycare — all these were, in the end, not nearly enough. Politics is all about tomorrow, not yesterday, and the tomorrow promise of Trudeau, once his brand, was gone.</p><p>Since the pandemic, Trudeau has been, like incumbents around the world, on his back foot on the trinity of core issues galvanizing populist support: inflation, immigration, and housing prices. His policies to address these were reactive, well behind the instincts of the leader of the official opposition, <strong>Pierre Poilievre</strong>. It didn’t help that the fiscal guardrails Trudeau had set up were blown. The Liberals were more than CA$20 billion past their target ahead of the fall fiscal update, an update his finance minister was set to give on Dec. 16. Instead, she dropped a radioactive resignation letter that very morning, pointing to Trudeau’s fiscal strategies as “costly political gimmicks” — and laying bare the internal divisions within the Cabinet. He was out of supporters, out of ideas, and looked out of touch.</p><p>It finally ended on Monday, an icy Ottawa day with the kind of cold that you can almost grab with a gloved hand and snap over your knee. The prime minister stood alone in front of the cottage where he had done so many press conferences during the pandemic and where I recall sitting to <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.google.com/search?q=evan+solomon+justin+trudeua+interview+power+play+end+of+year&amp;sca_esv=c40a88bc622d6705&amp;sxsrf=ADLYWILBd4RFXUlV2ric58i8oORi-5D-mg:1736453247329&amp;ei=fyyAZ7HcE8etiLMPpvOOsQQ&amp;ved=0ahUKEwjxl-e3uOmKAxXHFmIAHaa5I0YQ4dUDCBA&amp;uact=5&amp;oq=evan+solomon+justin+trudeua+interview+power+play+end+of+year&amp;gs_lp=Egxnd3Mtd2l6LXNlcnAiPGV2YW4gc29sb21vbiBqdXN0aW4gdHJ1ZGV1YSBpbnRlcnZpZXcgcG93ZXIgcGxheSBlbmQgb2YgeWVhcjIHECEYoAEYCjIHECEYoAEYCjIHECEYoAEYCjIHECEYChirAkigM1D5BFjOMnADeACQAQCYAWqgAboQqgEEMjEuM7gBA8gBAPgBAZgCGqACghGYAwDiAwUSATEgQIgGAZIHBDIxLjWgB_qdAg&amp;sclient=gws-wiz-serp#fpstate=ive&amp;vld=cid:0b0bed47,vid:253115FIU6w,st:0"><u>interview</u></a> a gray-bearded version of him on a similarly frigid winter day back in 2020. Now, he was notably different. Stripped of the pretense and dramatics that sometimes characterized his tenure, he presented a more authentic version of the man most Canadians had long ago lost sight of, telling them that he was resigning as leader and prime minister.</p><p>For a boy born on Christmas Day, the pathetic fallacies that marked Justin Trudeau’s life had one last small signal to send. Just before he left the shelter of the cottage to make his resignation announcement, a gust of wind suddenly <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXx6StjR8mI"><u>blew his speech</u></a> off the podium, papers scattering into the January air. It was over.</p><p>For his party, Trudeau’s departure could not come soon enough, and while Liberal Party leaders are still dithering on the rules for a leadership race, the math is cruel. Parliament is prorogued — suspended — until March 24, on Trudeau’s orders. There will be a confidence vote soon after, so expect a Canadian federal election to kick off immediately and run into May. In other words, Trudeau gave the next leader a short runway — more like a cliff. The next PM will barely have time to find the bathrooms and grab a cup of coffee before they will have to hit the hustings and try to climb out of the political hole that finds them 25 points behind the Conservatives.</p><p>For Canada, this could not come at a worse time. In less than two weeks, Trump will be sworn in as US president, and he has promised to slap Canada with 25% tariffs and use “economic force” to try to absorb the country as the 51st state.</p><p>As I wrote last year, Trump’s threat to absorb Canada as the 51st state has gone from a joke to a trial balloon — and it is quickly becoming a policy goal.</p><p>Trump the Isolationist has looped inside out and become Trump the Expansionist, with designs on Greenland, Canada, and Panama. His foreign policy for Central America is basically now the famous palindrome: a man, a plan, a canal, Panama.</p><p>Is he serious?</p><p>Yes.</p><p>Always take the president of the United States seriously, especially when he says he’s being serious. He may be using aggressive rhetoric as a negotiating tool to get better deals, but the threats are very real. Trump believes in tariffs like a priest believes in God.</p><p>When Trump threatens to beggar Canada with the economic force of 25% tariffs, it is the ONLY THING THAT MATTERS.</p><p>Canadian industry is bracing for a dramatic, painful economic shock. From. Its. Closest. Biggest. Trading. Partner.</p><p>All this lines up perfectly with the Top Risks of 2025 that our parent company, Eurasia Group, released this week, as you have read about. Risks such as Trumponomics — high tariffs on all allies and foes — mixed with the risk of The Rule of Don, a mercurial leader who has destroyed norms and wants the rule of the jungle over the rule law, is a lethal combination for a middle power country like Canada.</p><p>The rules-based international order is the architecture of the multilateral world, one that the US built in its own image after World War II and, until now, has been the backstop. This order has led to incredible prosperity for both the US and Canada, and billions of others. It is now disappearing faster than the fact-checkers at Meta.</p><p>As Trump throws economic bombs, Canada will have to muddle through the next three to five months without a leader who has a national mandate, leaving premiers like Ontario’s <strong>Doug Ford</strong> to lead the fight. And credit to him: Ford, so far, has done a superb job defending his province and speaking out.</p><p>Trump is coming for Canada and wants it to be the 51st state, in part or in whole — and if there was ever a time for someone to prove they have the stuff for leadership in a time of crisis, it is now. To twist an old expression, it is the 51st or fight.</p><p>Canadians better be up for a fight.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Trudeau’s Darkest Hour</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/trudeaus-darkest-hour</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfzzzile7707lqd87fz6fx</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 19 Dec 2024 20:58:48 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>economy</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>chrystia freeland</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>This is Justin Trudeau’s darkest hour.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd33y3cos407mykofv2a2c" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Christinne Muschi</media:credit>
<media:text>Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau speaks after signing an infrastructure agreement in Montreal, December 16, 2016.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd33y3cos407mykofv2a2c" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>’s darkest hour.</p><p>Even as he shuffles his Cabinet tomorrow, it will not shuffle his political future. This is the endgame.</p><p>Eventually, all successful politicians turn into Dorian Gray — gazing into the mirror and seeing a reflection of beauty they believe voters will find irresistible. All the while, however, somewhere under a parliamentary staircase, a portrait of their political face is being ravaged by time, scandal, and betrayal. That is the bargain leaders inevitably make as they fight to stay in power.</p><p>There was President <strong>Joe Biden</strong> earlier in the year, still seeing the reflection of a robust man ready to govern for another four years despite the fact that he couldn’t get through 40 minutes of a presidential debate. He had to be pried out of the presidential limo by the Jaws of Pelosi.</p><p>In 2015, former Conservative Prime Minister <strong>Stephen Harper</strong> thought he too saw another big election win in the mirror, but instead, insulated from reality inside his powerful prime minister’s office, he suffered a stunning defeat. The wheel of change is not partisan, but it is powerful.</p><p>Trudeau is now seeing the real portrait for the first time. After nine years in power, down 20 points in the polls, he has long refused to look, but his once trusted Finance Minister <strong>Chrystia Freeland</strong> just swiped the picture from under the stairs, waved it around publicly, and then lit it on fire.</p><p>It’s hard to imagine a more shambolic ending. Freeland was told by the PM — on a Zoom call, no less! —that she was going to be replaced as finance minister right after she presented the Fall Economic Statement (a kind of mini-budget in Canada) that would reveal the government blew past its own key deficit target by more than CA$20 billion. In other words, “Please wear this fiscal mess and let me move on to a new thing.”</p><p>How was that ever going to work? Naturally Freeland refused, but she didn’t simply quiet-quit and go gently into that good political night. Instead, just hours before she was set to deliver the FES, she chaos-quit with a controlled rage, rage-against-the-dying-of-light letter, dismissing Trudeau’s entire economic agenda as a self-serving “political gimmick.”</p><p>It blew the government apart.</p><p>It’s hard to declare winners and losers in this carnage, as everyone in the government is a casualty. The PM is now facing an open revolt by a growing number of MPs. <strong>Wayne Long</strong>, an outspoken Liberal, went on CTV’s ‘Power Play’ to say Trudeau is <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/ctv_powerplay/status/1869159481235419214?s=46&amp;t=ilTUBzZedGznNcs76x1I6A"><u>“delusional”</u></a> and claimed that up to 40 MPS want him to resign, though that number has yet to be confirmed. Still, his sentiments were reflected in comments MPs told me, one saying bluntly, “I hope he announces he is stepping down.”</p><p>Freeland herself says she is running again, which basically kicked off the next leadership race, and she is likely the front-runner. But, as the saying goes, “The hand that wields the knife shall never wear the crown.” Freeland delivered four budgets for Trudeau, and even if she rightly fought back against the $1.6 billion goods and services tax holiday boondoggle, that hardly adds up to the over $20 billion overage on her own targets. If Canada is facing a fiscal reckoning and an angry electorate, isn’t Freeland as responsible as Trudeau? Would Canadians be able to disaggregate the two?</p><p>All this could not come at a worse time for Canada, now under direct threat from President-elect <strong>Donald Trump</strong>. He promises devastating 25% tariffs on Canada the day after he is inaugurated, and, with a hyena’s nose for weakness, he has persistently and publicly tormented Trudeau with the threat of making Canada the 51st state.</p><p>Pause on that for a second because it is unprecedented in Canadian-US history, unless you want to go back to … 1812, before Confederation. What started out as a Trump taunt is starting to look more like a Trump trial balloon. Trump’s son Eric has amplified the idea on social media, and now, on places like Fox News, taking over Canada is a topic of genuine debate.</p><p>With Trump, the first question is always: Do we take him literally, or seriously, or both?</p><p>And the lesson people have learned in the last eight years is: both.</p><p>Even as government officials have dismissed the threat as a joke, others are taking it seriously. Ontario Premier <strong>Doug Ford</strong> is showing up on American news programs defending Canada and threatening to cut off energy exports.</p><p>Trump trades in three currencies: power, fame, and loyalty. A lame duck leader of a foreign country who has only one of these three may come to Mar-a-Lago for dinner, but he might well end up on the menu.</p><p>The best hope Canada has is for the 35 state governors who depend on Canada as their top trading partner to act as de facto proxies for Canada, and push back against tariffs that will hurt their workers and economies.</p><p>Now what?</p><p>A few paths:</p><p>One, Trudeau stays and runs again after tomorrow’s Cabinet shuffle. There are no polls or signs that would suggest this is the most productive path, but, until he leaves, it has to be an option.</p><p>Two, Trudeau leaves, prorogues parliament, and the leadership race kicks off. The rules around that election will be crucial for the Liberal Party.</p><p>Can Liberals afford to take three months to elect a leader while Trump launches trade tariffs and the Conservatives consolidate their lead in the polls? It is not advisable.</p><p>On the other hand, can they afford to do a short 30-35-day process, in which case very few Canadian voters and new candidates will get involved? That might not end up injecting any fresh blood into the party at all. The Democrats tried it in the US and ended up with a frothy <strong>Kamala Harris</strong> campaign start and a miserable end.</p><p>There are few good options for the leader and the party right now, but if the government falls on a confidence motion in the new year, then the race is one with Trudeau at the helm, which is exactly what the opposition parties want most of all.</p><p>Nothing can happen until the prime minister decides what he will do.</p><p>It’s coming on Christmas, as <strong>Joni Mitchell</strong> once sang, the day the prime minister was born, but instead of seeing a star in the sky, even he knows this is his darkest political hour. The only guide he has might be those portraits of other prime ministers that hang in the halls of Parliament, each of whom has had to ask the same impossibly hard question: When is my time up?</p><p>Only a few of them got to choose their own answer.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Don’t Panic: 4 Rules for Responding to Trump Threats</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/dont-panic-4-rules-for-responding-to-trump-threats</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfzcc6lc3x07lq3ldrirsk</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 05 Dec 2024 19:57:00 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>trade</category>
<category>washington</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Amid all the geopolitical chaos, the best advice of the year: Don’t panic.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd2131dc4f07lqz8b91j5o" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1124" height="666">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Marco Bello</media:credit>
<media:text>President-elect Donald Trump attends the 2024 Senior Club Championship award ceremony at his Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida, back in March.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd2131dc4f07lqz8b91j5o" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Amid all the geopolitical chaos, the best advice of the year: Don’t panic.</p><p>As they dined at Mar-a-Lago on a main course of tough, over-cooked tariff talk, President-elect <strong>Donald Trump</strong> suggested to Canadian Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> — in what the Canadians present later called a joking manner — that Canada might make a good 51st state. Naturally, people freaked out. First, Trump threatens to destroy the Canadian economy with 25% tariffs on everything, and now this? An invasion?</p><p>As the breathless coverage spilled over the international media, my colleague <strong>Gerry Butts</strong> went on Bluesky with a <a target="_blank" href="https://bsky.app/profile/gmbutts.bsky.social/post/3lcfnnuw3n22p"><u>message</u></a>: “Trump used this 51st state line all the time with Trudeau in his first term. He’s doing it to rattle Canadian cages. When someone wants you to freak out, don’t.”</p><p>It is sound advice. Don’t freak out.</p><p>Canada is no more going to become the 51st state in the next four years than California, British Columbia, and Oregon are going to break away and become Cascadia. Jokes are not policy.</p><p>So what’s up?</p><p>Trump is a zero-sum negotiator. He uses the powerful leverage he has to create “I win, you lose” deals. Threats give him a real negotiation advantage before the actual negotiations happen. That is the prerogative of the Big Dog countries, especially those run by strongmen, mercantilist leaders like Trump. Trump threats are simply the expected prelude to any deal. But what is real and what is rhetoric? And how to respond?</p><p><strong>Invasion:</strong> Rhetoric. Dismiss.<br><strong>Tariffs:&nbsp;</strong>Real. Discuss.</p><p><strong>Rule One:</strong> <strong>Stick With Facts.</strong> Don’t get caught up in the torrent of tweets and taunts. Don’t give anything away until the actual negotiations start. Facts are your best friends.</p><p>Facts? Really? You might think that since Trump has ushered in the post-fact world, facts are a diminishing currency. That is a dangerous bet. For example, at the root of the 51st state jab are the much more dangerous Trump threats to slap 25% tariffs on all goods coming in from Canada and Mexico. Trump based this threat on what he says is the heavy flow of fentanyl and illegal migrants across the border.</p><p>Initially, that threat caused panic. Alberta Premier <strong>Danielle Smith</strong> immediately went into appeasement mode, telling the CBC’s Power and Politics, “It’s incumbent, I believe, on the federal government, along with all of the provinces, to work together to address those concerns if we want to be able to avoid these devastating tariffs that’ll hurt all of us.”</p><p>She’s not wrong that the Trump rhetoric needs to be addressed, which is why Trudeau immediately got on a plane and took his team for a strategic schmooze fest at Mar-a-Lago. Trump prizes personal relationships above all else, so a connection matters.</p><p><strong>Rule Two: Don’t Take It Personally.</strong> Even though Trump has a long-standing sour relationship with Trudeau — he’s even called the Canadian PM “two-faced” — in Trumplandia, that doesn’t matter. His relationships with people change like the weather in the Rocky Mountains: If you don’t like what is happening, wait five minutes. It will change.</p><p>Trump is quick to anger and quick to forget. Can he get over his past irritations with Trudeau? Well, he got over <strong>JD Vance</strong> comparing him to … that guy who ran Germany in the war. He nominated former rival <strong>Marco Rubio</strong>, whom he used to mock as “Little Marco,” for secretary of state. Trump doesn’t hold the very grudges he creates, and the best way to get over that is to find a way to make nice, show loyalty, and suck up. That’s what the Trudeau visit was all about. Feelings first. Facts second.</p><p>That doesn’t mean giving anything away. And that’s where the facts come in. On fentanyl and border security, the reality is far different than the rhetoric. Canada is hardly a major threat to the US on either issue.</p><p>“The facts are hard to deny,” <strong>Kirsten Hillman</strong>, Canada’s whip-smart ambassador to the US, pointed out on X. “Last year, 0.6% of illegal crossings and 0.2% of fentanyl seizures by US authorities were at the northern border.”</p><p>That’s right. Only .2% of fentanyl seizures happened at the Canadian border. If you want to go deeper, check out the latest <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/drug-seizure-statistics"><u>stats</u></a> from the US Customs and Border Protection agency, which shows that the problem of fentanyl is largely at the Mexican border, not the Canadian one.</p><p>In fact, the CBP’s top official, <strong>Troy Miller</strong>, has an extensive <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cbp.gov/frontline/frontline-against-fentanyl-interview-cbps-top-official"><u>interview</u></a> on the US government website about fentanyl coming over the US border. Guess what? He mentions the southwest border 21 times and Mexico specifically seven times. Canada? Not a word. Canada and the northern border are not mentioned a single time. Why? It is simply not a major issue.</p><p><strong>Rule Three: Know What Actually Needs Work.</strong> On the other hand, illegal migration is a real issue, both internationally and domestically. There is a key section along the US-Canadian border called the Swanton Sector (which covers parts of New York, Vermont, and New Hampshire), and illegal immigration rates there have <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/nationwide-encounters"><u>spiked</u></a> according to stats from the CBP. But how bad is it? 23,000 <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/26/us/trump-canada-border-migrants.html"><u>arrests</u></a> were made at the northern border between October 2023 and September 2024. That is up from 10,000 in 2023. Compared to Mexico, where over 47,000 arrests were made in November of this year alone, it’s a trickle (700 were arrested in November in Canada). Still, politically it is an issue Canadians will have to deal with if they want to avoid tariff punishments. Doing nothing is not an option.</p><p>Illegal migration is now driving election outcomes in France, Ireland, Germany, and many other places, so this ain’t a surprise. But proportionality matters, and the facts that prove that point can get lost in the storm of threats. It is critical this doesn’t happen.</p><p><strong>Rule 4: Follow the Money.</strong> There is a high probability that a tariff-driven trade war — or skirmish — is coming very soon, and the facts here will be crucial. After all, high tariffs will hurt the very people Trump represents — namely, American workers. High US tariffs on Canadian goods will raise prices for US consumers and make life for them more miserable. That is a political loss for Trump.</p><p>Over 34 US states rely on Canada as their major <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.weforum.org/stories/2021/07/usa-us-trade-canada-mexico-china-imports-exports/"><u>trading partner</u></a>, so expect state governors to pressure the White House to ease up on the tariff talk so as not to jeopardize the bilateral trading relationship that sees over US$2.7 billion worth of goods and services crossing the border each day.</p><p>To protect that, Canadian leaders will have to think hard about decoupling their trade relationship with Mexico, especially when the new US-Mexico-Canada trade deal gets renegotiated in 2026. The politics of the southern border have always cross-infected the northern one, but if the infection threatens to be economically fatal, there will be a change. The famed three amigos might be reduced to two.</p><p>But that is not for right now. Trade deals are not made on social media; they are negotiated face to face, when genuine swaps and deals can happen. Better to build relationships now over dinner, and serve up facts for dessert.</p><p>And don’t panic.</p><p>It hasn’t even started yet.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The pre-Trump G20 and the patron saint of lost causes</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/the-g20-already-got-trumped-and-he-s-not-even-in-office-yet</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfytkolalc07lql1sxoxdt</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 21 Nov 2024 20:14:51 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>middle-east</category>
<category>economy</category>
<category>europe</category>
<category>latin america-caribbean</category>
<category>Analysis</category>
<description>With Trump about to take power again, one of the world&apos;s most important multilateral gatherings was an exercise in cowardice and smallness.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd1931cmng07mye2bedq4p" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="800">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Ricardo Moraes</media:credit>
<media:text>World leaders assemble for a group photo at the G20 summit in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on November 19, 2024. The gathering was overshadowed by Donald Trump&apos;s impending return to the White House.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd1931cmng07mye2bedq4p" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>At the G20 gathering this week in Brazil, a key question emerged: Has Donald Trump already cowed world leaders, two months before he even takes power? It certainly seems like it.</p><p>The G20 leaders arrived in Rio de Janeiro to deliver their best ideas for how, collectively, to solve urgent global problems like poverty, climate change, inequality, and war.</p><p>These summits are always a little about the old ultra-verbiage, sure, but they are also meant to burnish the legitimacy and importance of multilateral approaches to global challenges.</p><p>This time, the G20 got Trumped. Loudly. The president-elect’s America First 2.0 agenda hung over the proceedings like the fearsome black cloud in Don Dellilo’s novel White Noise.</p><p>How do we measure the Trump cloud’s impact? Just look at the summit’s final communiqué, the pre-negotiated summary these gabfests always release. They merit attention not only for what they say, but also for what they don’t. This time, what it didn’t say was a lot.</p><p>Take Russia’s illegal invasion of Ukraine, for example. With Kyiv now using Western-made long-range missiles, and Putin responding by hinting at a nuclear response and flinging larger and larger missiles of his own, the communiqué’s authors played dentist, carefully extracting any teeth that might nip at the Russian leader, who of course did not attend.</p><p>“We highlight the human suffering and negative added impacts of the war with regard to global food and energy security, supply chains, macro-financial stability, inflation and growth,” it said, clearly using the secret diplomatic formula for verbal vanilla. If that alone weren’t enough for the toothless, it continued by calling for “the promotion of peaceful, friendly, and good neighborly relations among nations.”</p><p>No mention of Russia by name.<br>No mention of the illegal invasion.<br>No reminder that Putin continues to slaughter civilians and wreck critical infrastructure.<br>Nothing about human rights abuses.</p><p>This alone was a triumph for Putin as he eagerly awaits the return of Trump, who ran in part on questioning support for Ukraine and pledging to end the war in “24 hours.”</p><p>No one saw this more clearly than Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.</p><p>“G20 countries are sitting in Brazil. Did they say something?” he asked. “Nothing.”</p><p>The impotence of the G20s Ukraine statement was probably best summed up by a man who is himself hanging by a thread politically these days: German Chancellor Olaf Sholz, who muttered, “It is too little when the G20 cannot find the words to make it clear Russia is responsible.”</p><p>Too little.</p><p>That might be the epitaph of this pre-Trump G20.</p><p>Knowing that Donald Trump will not continue support for Ukraine, and highlighting the truth that the Global South has never supported the US and EU’s hardline views of the Russian invasion, the G20 slinked away from calling out Moscow, just as they did last year. This signals that a Trump-brokered ceasefire, which will likely give Russia much of what it wants in terms of Ukrainian territory and neutrality, looks much more likely.</p><p>But Ukraine was just the start of the smallness.</p><p>The language on the Israel-Gaza war was a boilerplate call for a two-state solution and more humanitarian aid, without a mention either of the Hamas-held hostages, the Oct. 7 attack, or the 40,000 dead in Gaza. The statement on a global billionaire tax — a decades-old idea that was particularly dear to summit host and Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva — was equally eye-glazing: “We will seek to engage cooperatively to ensure that ultra-high-net-worth individuals are effectively taxed.” OK … and then what?</p><p>Perhaps the only real positive was the launch of the Alliance Against Hunger and Poverty, in order to deal with the stunning fact that over 733 million people face food shortages every year. That could mean microfinance, food programs, and investment in sustainable food production. It is a good thing to see countries sign on to this even if the failure to eradicate hunger and poverty is, sadly, perennial.</p><p>Watching the leaders try to spin the summit’s accomplishments was like watching Rafael Nadal retire from tennis: a once-powerful champion reduced to swatting at balls he can’t reach, limping off the court to applause not for what he just did, but for what he no longer can do.</p><p>Like Nadal, these leaders know they are ceding the world to a new champion for the next four years, and they still have no idea what to do about it, except duck, stall, evade, and suck up.</p><p>Was there any pushback from these multilateral champions against a world shifting toward strongman isolationism, tariffs, and an American president who will begin the great retreat from the global stage of cooperation?</p><p>Not much.</p><p>The next G20 will be very different from this one, where leaders gazed up to see Rio’s famous Christ the Redeemer statue overlooking their meeting.</p><p>At the next one, they might need to find the Patron Saint of Lost Causes.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Trump’s Team of … Reprisals?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/trumps-team-of-reprisals</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfyifjkiqn07my03i6la65</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 14 Nov 2024 19:03:53 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>kristi noem</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>trump administration</category>
<category>cabinet</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>elon musk</category>
<category>homan</category>
<category>lincoln</category>
<category>matt gaetz</category>
<category>marco rubio</category>
<category>pete hegseth</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Cabinet-building has long been crucial for both the success of a presidency and the direction of the United States. From the presidencies of Abraham Lincoln to Donald Trump, the team often tells the tale of power. Publisher Evan Solomon looks at what Trump’s Cabinet picks are telling us all.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd0rlddalc07lq5pvbykmm" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Luisa Vieira</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd0rlddalc07lq5pvbykmm" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Trump team … Assemble!<br></p><p>Usually, obsession with team building is reserved for the world of sports, not politics. There are Hollywood movies about NFL <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2223990/">draft day</a>, and the trade deadlines in basketball, hockey, and baseball command all-day TV specials. But those seem trivial compared to the global obsession with Trump Team 2.0. Who is on it, and what does it mean for the next four years?</p><p>Cabinet-building has long been crucial for both the success of a presidency and for the direction of the United States. From the presidencies of <strong>Abraham Lincoln</strong> to <strong>Donald Trump</strong>, the team often tells the tale of power.</p><p>After narrowly winning the election of 1860, Lincoln knew the United States was lurching toward civil war. He needed a united team to take on the emerging secessionist Confederacy, but he didn’t choose loyalists. Instead, he made a radical choice to bring in his chief opponents like <strong>William Seward</strong>, <strong>Salmon Chase</strong>, and <strong>Edward Bates</strong>. In her bestselling <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Team_of_Rivals#:~:text=Team%20of%20Rivals:%20The%20Political,cabinet%20from%201861%20to%201865.">book</a>, <strong>Doris Kearns Goodwin</strong> called this a “Team of Rivals.”</p><p>Initially, it looked like a rookie mistake. Seward tried to sabotage Lincoln, leaking false announcements about a surrender of Fort Sumter, the place where, soon after, the first shots of the Civil War were fired.</p><p>But Lincoln asserted his leadership without alienating his team, and Seward soon became one of his closest confidants. Co-opting and including his chief opponents is roundly hailed as one of Lincoln’s finest strategies.</p><p>If Lincoln put together a team of rivals, Trump has assembled a team of reprisals. This is a group of ardent MAGA loyalists, not rivals — as Ian Bremmer pointed out in our <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/video/quick-take/trumps-plans-for-policy-personnel">GZERO video</a>. Their job is to radically transform every part of government, from trade policy to foreign policy. There are three goals: reformation, reduction, and reprisal. And that last point is critical. The foundational promise Trump made to voters was to smash “the enemies within.” And that is exactly what this team is built to do.</p><p>Here is a starter menu:</p><ol><li>The Deep State: <strong>Elon Musk</strong> and <strong>Vivek Ramaswamy</strong> have been appointed to actively find “efficiencies” and dismantle large swaths of the government. “You’re fired” will be the watchwords.</li><li>The Military: <strong>Pete Hegseth</strong>, the veteran and Fox News commentator, is headed for the secretary of defense job, where he has long said he would fire all generals who support programs like Diversity, Equity and Inclusion.</li><li>The Border: <strong>Tom Homan</strong>, the nominated “border czar,” has warned all illegal aliens to get ready for mass deportation, while South Dakota Gov. <strong>Kristi Noem</strong> will be Trump’s Homeland Security chief working alongside Homan.</li><li>The Department of Education: Trump has promised to close this down completely to stop the so-called “woke agenda.”</li><li>The Environmental Protection Agency: Expect former New York Rep. <strong>Lee Zeldin</strong> to gut EPA regulations. He has already signaled his priorities, with a social media post saying he will “restore US energy dominance, revitalize our auto industry to bring back American jobs and make the US the global leader of AI. We will do so while protecting access to clean air and water.” The EPA might have to change its initials to the DBD, for Drill, Baby, Drill. Still, there are some signs of resistance here. Even the CEO of ExxonMobil pushed back, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.politico.com/news/2024/11/12/exxon-ceo-us-climate-policy-00188927">saying</a>, “I don’t think the challenge or the need to address global emissions is going to go away.”</li><li>Trade: China hawk Sen. <strong>Marco Rubio</strong> will be the secretary of state, likely overseeing a world of high tariffs that will trigger trade wars alongside the existing wars already raging.</li><li>The Legal System: <strong>Matt Gaetz</strong>’s nomination for attorney general is taking the most incoming. Gaetz believes he and Trump are victims of Democratic “lawfare,” and he’s ready to hit back. “The hammer of Justice is coming,” <a target="_blank" href="https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1856809119115522499">declared</a> Elon Musk on X, lest anyone think there will be no reprisals.</li></ol><p>To Trump supporters — and that means the majority of voters — this is exactly what they wanted. Expect them to follow through on everything you heard on the campaign trail. As folks used to say, take Trump and his team both seriously and literally.</p><p>The president-elect has long claimed he is the victim of multiple attacks from the establishment because he promised to “drain the swamp” and, unlike in 2016, he’s wasting no time assembling a team to fight back. Of the many things to expect from Donald Trump, reprisals are at the top of the list.</p><h3>How to cover the Trump team fairly?</h3><p>Covering this transition in a meaningful, insightful way requires genuine balance and adherence to fairness. In the current climate of hyper-polarization, anything but praise for the president-elect can be cast as “woke” bias from the “lamestream” media. On the other hand, anything positive about Trump is often cast as supplicant cozying up to a kleptocracy.</p><p>Neither is helpful.</p><p>The key is not to focus on the fertilized fears on social media but on the real actions of the Trump team. What will they actually do? Who is benefiting from the radical change?</p><p>What will be the impact of their policies on the economy, rights, security, climate, and social coherence?</p><p>Each question will have a specific answer, and tracking them with facts and credibility will be key over the next four years. In an environment where distrust and disinformation are weaponized, straight talk and nonpartisan insight will become more valuable than ever.</p><p>This is just the beginning of the second Trump era, and it will be significantly more transformative than the first. Trump’s Team of Reprisals is ready to do exactly what they promised on the campaign trail, best summed up in three words: fight, fight fight.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Great expectations, grave concerns</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/great-expectations-grave-concerns</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfy5aokhh807my0ppu12lp</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 07 Nov 2024 19:52:00 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>us foreign policy</category>
<category>trump administration</category>
<category>republicans</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>What to expect when you’re expecting Trump 2.0? Can he live up to the great expectations he set and alleviate the grave concerns? Publisher Evan Solomon spells it out, in true T.R.U.M.P. style.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd06b4d9tg07lq9st33fov" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1920" height="1080">
<media:credit>Jess Frampton</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrd06b4d9tg07lq9st33fov" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What to expect when you’re expecting Trump 2.0? Can he live up to the great expectations he set and alleviate the grave concerns? Let’s spell it out, in true T.R.U.M.P. style.</p><h3>1. Tariffs and Taxes</h3><p><strong>Expectation:</strong> <strong>Donald Trump&nbsp;</strong>will quickly ratchet up his America First tariffs policy, potentially slapping 10% to 20% tariffs on all goods coming into the United States — and much higher duties on goods from China, especially cars. The bet is that this will stimulate job growth in the United States and stop the hollowing out of manufacturing caused by globalization and free trade. The Trump promise: Tariffs are “not going to be a cost to you, it’s a cost to another country.”</p><p><strong>Concern</strong><strong>:</strong> In reversing decades of Republican free trade policy, expansive tariffs will drive up the cost of goods for US consumers and increase inflation, as <a target="_blank" href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24777566-nobel-letter-final">16 Nobel prize-winning economists</a> wrote in June. The Peterson Institute for International Economics — an independent nonprofit research group — <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.piie.com/blogs/realtime-economics/2024/how-much-would-trumps-plans-deportations-tariffs-and-fed-damage-us">wrote a paper</a> arguing that Trump’s tariffs and tax cuts will push inflation up four points higher by 2026 than it would otherwise. Make America expensive again is one way to see it.</p><p>To counteract that, Trump will extend the major <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/issues/2024/5/22/effects-of-permanently-extending-tcja-expiring-provisions">tax cuts</a> which he put forward in 2017 and are set to expire next year. That will keep stimulating the economy alongside new tax cuts for corporations and individuals, but it won’t be enough to stop inflation. It also raises another concern: deficits.</p><p>According to studies like <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/issues/2024/8/26/trump-campaign-policy-proposals-2024">this</a> one from Wharton, Trump’s deficits could reach between $3 and $7 trillion, up from <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://fiscaldata.treasury.gov/americas-finance-guide/national-deficit/#:~:text=What%20is%20the%20national%20deficit,resulting%20in%20a%20national%20deficit.&amp;text=Fiscal%20year-to-date%20(,has%20increased%20by%20$138%20billion.">$1.83</a> trillion today. “We project that conventionally estimated tax revenue falls by $5.8 trillion over the next 10 years, producing an equivalent amount of primary deficits. Accounting for economic feedback effects, primary deficits increase by $4.1 trillion over the same period,” the Wharton report says.</p><p>What will Trump do with big industrial policy programs like Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act, which so far has provided over $240 billion in spending and has earmarked another $60 billion for various green industries? Kill it and rescind all the unspent dollars. “To further defeat inflation,” he said recently, “my plan will terminate the Green New Deal, which I call the Green New Scam.” For the green tech world and industries like wind, solar, and even electric cars, this will be a major setback. There will be quick deregulation for oil and gas companies, and new and fast “drill, baby, drill” offshore leases will open up, along with more fracking and pipelines. Not all tax credits from the IRA will be removed, but support for buying EVs will. Expect this to be where <strong>Elon Musk</strong> makes a dramatic impact.</p><p><strong>Prediction</strong><strong>:</strong> Trump acts fast on some tariffs but not all. He will get a lot of internal pushback as members of his party worry that a series of international trade wars will be triggered, hammering their crucial exports and hurting their economies. Biden will scramble to get the Inflation Reduction Act money out the door, but I am already hearing reports that departments are freezing funds to prepare for the new administration.</p><h3>2. Retaliation and Revolution</h3><p><strong>Expectation:&nbsp;</strong>With a strong mandate, Trump will have few checks and balances to stop him from taking action against those he has labeled “enemies of the people” or “the enemy within.” What’s more, Trump believes the Supreme Court has given the president total immunity from prosecution for actions undertaken as commander in chief.</p><p>An <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.npr.org/2024/10/22/nx-s1-5155032/trump-makes-more-than-100-threats-to-prosecute-or-punish-perceived-enemies">NPR investigation</a> lays out over 100 threats that Trump has made in the last few years, ranging from prosecuting political opponents like President <strong>Joe Biden</strong> to taking away licenses from news outlets like CBS, NBC, and ABC.</p><p><strong>Concern</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>Trump will try to dismantle what he calls the “Deep State” by reviving his infamous <a target="_blank" href="https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/522339-trump-order-strips-workplace-protections-from-civil-servants/">“Schedule F,”</a> which would allow him to fire bureaucrats he doesn’t like and hire ones who agree with his policies.</p><p>Trump’s new team is much more experienced and ready than they were in 2016, and the agenda for a radical overhaul of the US government will be led by folks like <strong>Elon Musk</strong> and <strong>Robert F. Kennedy Jr.</strong> While there will be massive deregulation, the biggest concern will be a government that launches investigations into any group that challenges its policy.</p><p><strong>Prediction</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>Mass layoffs in the federal government, overhauls of the Department of Education and the FBI, and legal challenges with multiple news organizations.</p><h3>3. Ukraine</h3><p><strong>Expectation</strong><strong>:</strong> While lame-duck Biden will try to get as much money and material to Ukraine before January, Trump will cut it off and try to force a peace. He promised to end the war within 24 hours and to do that he would have to force Ukraine to cede a massive amount of territory to <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong>.</p><p><strong>Concern</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>NATO allies are in no shape to fill the US gap in aid. Without US assistance, Russia — now with the support of North Korean troops — will start to grab more land. How far will they go before they make a deal? That is up to Trump, but it is bad news for Ukraine.</p><p><strong>Prediction</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>The war grinds on for a year, but eventually Ukraine — running low on equipment and money – will be forced to give up huge swaths of territory in the east. Putin has waited out the US and now has a sympathetic ear in the White House.</p><h3>4. Mexican Border and the Middle East</h3><p><strong>On the Mexican border</strong></p><p><strong>Expectation</strong><strong>:</strong> Trump will rapidly end birthright citizenship and begin a massive deportation program of up to 20 million people, which will require building detainment camps. Also, expect the so-called Muslim ban on certain countries to be revived from his first term.</p><p><strong>Concern</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>Besides the key questions about the legality, morality, and practicality of mass deportations, there is the economic impact.</p><p>The American Immigration Council wrote a <a target="_blank" href="https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/mass-deportation">study</a> saying that the deportation program would cost over $315 billion and be extremely difficult to manage. At the height of deportation efforts in recent US history, the country deported approximately half a million people in a single year — and most of those were turned away as they tried to cross, rather than being forced out of the country after they had settled. The long-term impacts of mass deportation on the US economy could add to a crisis. “Due to the loss of workers across U.S. industries, we found that mass deportation would reduce the U.S. gross domestic product (GDP) by 4.2 to 6.8 percent,” according to the AIC. “It would also result in significant reduction in tax revenues for the U.S. government. In 2022 alone, undocumented immigrant households paid $46.8 billion in federal taxes and $29.3 billion in state and local taxes. Undocumented immigrants also contributed $22.6 billion to Social Security and $5.7 billion to Medicare.”</p><p><strong>Prediction</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>This is a core promise of the Trump 2.0 administration, and despite the fury this will cause, deportation programs will be set up quickly.</p><h2>On the Middle East<br></h2><p><strong>Expectation</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>Trump is a strong supporter of the policies of Israeli Prime Minister <strong>Benjamin Netanyahu</strong> and his fight against Iran and proxies Hamas and Hezbollah. Trump will tell Bibi that he has a clear road ahead to finish the war — though what that means strategically remains unclear — but he will likely demand that the heavy fighting stop before the inauguration. Trump wants to fulfill his promise to end the war in Gaza and, in the process, defeat Iran’s Jihadist allies and ambitions.</p><p>Trump’s greatest foreign policy accomplishment in his first term was the <a target="_blank" href="https://www.state.gov/the-abraham-accords/">Abraham Accords</a>, in which both Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates recognized Israel’s sovereignty and established full diplomatic relations. Could his hard line on Iran build on this and turn the terrible war into a larger peace? That is the hope.</p><p><strong>Concern</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>The biggest issue is that Trump’s unfettered support for Netanyahu will encourage Bibi to double down on his most aggressive strategic goals and undermine any possibility for a two-state solution by continuing massive bombardments in Gaza and Lebanon and by moving more settlers into the West Bank. It could trigger a major war with Iran and light up the entire region. It could also push the Iranians to finally build a nuclear bomb, which would incentivize the US to take military action.</p><p><strong>Prediction</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>The war ends before Trump’s inauguration, but there is no plan for what comes next. Who governs Gaza or southern Lebanon? What is the plan for any rebuilding? What happens to the refugees? The hostages? The festering wounds of this bloody war are not going away soon, and expect ongoing protests in the US and around the world. Other terror groups, like the Houthis in Yemen, will continue to upend any attempt at peace. Worst-case scenario, the war on the battlefield turns into asymmetric terror attacks around the world. Things will get worse before they get better.</p><h3>5. Pomp and Partisanship</h3><p><strong>Expectation</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>2026 marks the 250th year of the great American experiment in democracy, and Trump has planned for a <a target="_blank" href="https://www.donaldjtrump.com/agenda47/celebration-of-250-years-of-american-independence-at-the-iowa-state-fairgrounds"><u>yearlong celebration</u></a> that will include parades, a full-year US fair in Iowa, and multiple other events.</p><p>This will be the ultimate American and MAGA moment, twinning his remarkably resurrected political movement with the key US anniversary. The Trump dynasty will be tied to the American destiny.</p><p><strong>Concern</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>This year would be celebrated by any president, so there is no over-concern in principle, but President-elect Trump is also the commander in chief of the culture war against what he calls wokeness. The culture war has animated his entire movement and its loudest proclaimer, Tucker Carlson. Expect these celebrations to reflect the administration’s values and to be strategically allied with the anti-woke messaging that has been so divisive across the country.</p><p><strong>Prediction</strong><strong>:&nbsp;</strong>Great parties in places like Iowa, increased tourism, and probably a military parade in Washington, which Trump has always wanted — but also big controversy. In a country where athletes quietly kneeling during the singing of the national anthem before a football game can become a major battle in the culture wars, there is a real risk that partisan politics will turn a year of unity into one of deep divisions. Let’s hope not.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Political endorsements: Do they help or hurt trust in journalism?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/political-endorsements-help-or-hurt-trust-in-journalism</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfxsh0l5qk07lqzf1llw8b</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 31 Oct 2024 18:19:05 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Yanking endorsements days before a close election is like giving yourself a political wedgie, an awkward, painful experience that seems inappropriate and undermines the integrity of the decision — and yet, while the timing looks weak, the merits of the argument are strong, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon. He weighs in on Washington Post owner Jeff Bezos’ last-minute decision to no longer publish political endorsements — and explains why GZERO never endorses candidates.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrczl08d93h07lqikhs7sem" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1920" height="1080">
<media:credit>Jess Frampton</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrczl08d93h07lqikhs7sem" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Smart or spineless? Should newspapers endorse candidates, or does it undermine their objectivity?<br></p><p>When Washington Post owner <strong>Jeff Bezos</strong> announced last week that his paper would no longer publish political endorsements — as they have done for decades — the backlash was swift. 200,000 people canceled their subscriptions, according to NPR. Retired Post Executive Editor Marty Baron unleashed a <a target="_blank" href="https://x.com/PostBaron/status/1849847940761657353"><u>furious volley on X</u></a>. “This is cowardice, with democracy as its casualty,” he raged. “Disturbing spinelessness at an institution famed for courage.”</p><p>For Baron, missing editorial vertebrae is a virtual news pandemic. The Los Angeles Times also canceled endorsements. Gannett, which owns 200 papers including USA Today, banned presidential endorsements earlier in the year.</p><p>Was the Post’s move, as Baron suggested, a lame, last-minute attempt to appease <strong>Donald Trump</strong> (should he win) and curry political favor?</p><p>The timing sure looks bad. If Bezos wanted to change the Post’s policy, he should have done it much earlier. Yanking endorsements days before a close election is like giving yourself a political wedgie, an awkward, painful experience that seems totally inappropriate. It undermines the integrity of the decision and gives it the sour sniff of desperation, a weak obeisance to Trump’s anti-media threats. Showing fear of the powerful is a malignant condition for any news organization.</p><p>But while the timing looks weak, the merits of the argument are strong. Bezos is right to point to a<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/651977/americans-trust-media-remains-trend-low.aspx"> <u>Gallup poll</u></a> from October showing that trust in the media is at an all-time low, with only 31% saying they are confident the media reports the news fairly and accurately.</p><p>“For the third consecutive year, more US adults have no trust at all in the media (36%) than trust it a great deal or fair amount,” wrote Gallup. “Another 33% of Americans express ‘not very much’ confidence.” As a comparison, in the 1970s, trust in the media was closer to 70%. Even in the early 2000s, trust was still about 55%.</p><p>Bezos sees endorsements as one reason for this collapse. To him, endorsements are a dangerous vestige of a bygone era that undermines the trust in objective journalism. “What presidential endorsements actually do is create a perception of bias,” <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/10/28/jeff-bezos-washington-post-trust/"><u>he wrote</u></a>. “A perception of non-independence. Ending them is a principled decision, and it’s the right one.”</p><p>Gannett took a slightly more nuanced position than Bezos, banning national endorsements for president but letting its local papers endorse at the local level. “We believe America’s future is decided locally – one race at a time,” Gannett announced in a statement to CNN.</p><p>This may be a distinction without a difference, but nuance matters. Papers have long published editorials on various subjects, and readers look to those positions for some guidance. They should and will continue. Editorials are marked as such and function as separate sections for readers to discern. An election endorsement is different. It taints all reporters’ work with a political hue.</p><p>Outlets that openly skew to one political side — right or left — should be happy to continue to endorse and present their reasons. Why not? They are open about their partisanship and political bent, and they make money selling their papers to people who like that view.</p><p>But for any media organization fighting to maintain an objective, nonpartisan reputation, political endorsements alienate readers from one or another side, driving them to partisan outlets that may have no journalistic standards at all. Readers can make up their own minds on who to vote for without a paper picking sides.</p><p><strong>At GZERO, we have never endorsed a political candidate.</strong> Our policy is to maintain objective, nonpartisan journalism and analysis, without becoming toothless bores whose neutrality masks an unwillingness to call out facts or press back against the tide of disinformation and bullshit. But who you vote for is up to you. Our job is to present the facts, the stories, and the policies clearly, put them in perspective, and make sure you have the tools to make an informed decision.</p><p>Speaking of election tools, we have a full <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/us-election/"><u>toolbox for you here</u></a> to get all the insights you need for the wild events surrounding this election, from our <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/bloc-by-bloc-america-s-changing-voting-patterns"><u>Bloc by Bloc</u></a> series on America’s changing voting patterns and key factors that may sway the election, to a deep dive into the <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-7-swing-states-that-could-decide-the-election"><u>seven swing states</u></a> that will determine the next president.</p><p>Also, please tune in to <strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> and <strong>Van Jones</strong> tomorrow on our new <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://substack.com/@ianbremmer?liveStreamShare=true&amp;liveStreamDate=2024-11-01T14:15:00-04:00&amp;liveStreamGuest=Van%20Jones">Substack channel</a> (subscribe today) at 2:15 p.m. ET for a great chat about the drivers of the election so far.</p><p>We will also have election night coverage on our website and on Substack, where you can participate in the virtual watch party. And join us for <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1lDxLljBbLZxm"><u>our live X space</u></a> at 11 a.m. ET on Nov. 6, even if there is no confirmed winner.</p><p>So while we don’t endorse endorsements, however you choose to vote, please join in the conversation. We keep it civil and fact-based, and we don’t think it is a crime to enjoy talking politics.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Eagle Claw and the death of the October surprise</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/eagle-claw-and-the-death-of-the-october-surprise</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfxf08kcaa07myozrxpf88</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 24 Oct 2024 19:06:18 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>us election</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>october surprise</category>
<category>jimmy carter</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>voting</category>
<category>2024 presidential election</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Will there be an October surprise this year? The answer is likely no, and that’s one of the biggest mysteries of the 2024 campaign. Publisher Evan Solomon looks at why.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcz8nmck7307myc6memv8p" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1131" height="671">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein and Octavio Jones/File Photo via Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>Democratic Vice President Kamala Harris and her Republican opponent, former President Donald Trump, are seen in a combination of file photographs taken on the campaign trail in October.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcz8nmck7307myc6memv8p" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Is there an October surprise that might make or break a president?<br></p><p>The October surprise dates back to President <strong>Jimmy Carter</strong>, who turned 100 this month and, surprising many, managed to cast his vote for <strong>Kamala Harris</strong>.</p><p>During his 1980 campaign against <strong>Ronald Reagan</strong>, Carter believed a daring rescue of the 52 hostages that Iranian revolutionaries held after storming the American Embassy on Nov. 4, 1979, would turn things around.</p><p>So Carter launched Operation Eagle Claw. On April 24, 1980, eight helicopters and a C-130 plane secretly landed in the desert outside of Tehran to start the rescue operation. It was a colossal failure. Several choppers malfunctioned in a sandstorm and one crashed, killing eight US servicemen. Their bodies were later recovered by the Iranians and used in a sickening public display in Tehran.</p><p>Years later, I traveled to Atlanta, Georgia, to interview Carter, and he told me that, in his unequivocal view, had that helicopter not crashed, the hostages would have been rescued, and he would have won the election.</p><p>Still, even after Eagle Claw failed, the Reagan campaign feared an “October surprise,” where, at the very last moment, Carter would announce a dramatic arms-for-hostages deal with Iran. It never happened, and the hostages were released under Reagan, but since then, campaigns have braced for a late-breaking event that might change the course of an election.</p><p>There have been other examples of October surprises since then. In October 1992, former Defense Secretary <strong>Caspar Weinberger</strong> was indicted, derailing <strong>George H.W. Bush</strong>’s reelection bid. And, of course, in October 2016, FBI Director <strong>James Comey</strong> dropped the news that he was opening up an investigation into <strong>Hillary Clinton</strong>, helping Trump win that election.</p><p>Will there be an October surprise this year?</p><p>The answer is likely no, and that’s one of the biggest mysteries of this campaign: Why not?</p><p>First off, the most consequential surprises this year came much earlier than October — Biden was pushed out in favor of Harris, while Trump was convicted of 34 felonies and survived two assassination attempts. Few things can top those.</p><p>What about this week’s revelation that Trump’s former Chief of Staff John Kelly, a retired Marine general, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/22/us/politics/john-kelly-trump-fitness-character.html"><u>alleges</u></a> that Trump wanted to have generals like Hitler’s and that he’s an “authoritarian” who “admires people who are dictators”? The Trump campaign has denied this, but for all the press it’s getting, it’s hardly a surprise. Kelly and other former disgruntled Trump folks have long said all kinds of nasty things about the GOP nominee, and none of it has made a bit of difference to the campaign.</p><p>Trump remains slightly ahead in most national polls. Harris has run a solid, billion-dollar campaign, and while she can be vague and tends to serve up word-salad answers without any policy protein — as she did last night on CNN — Trump has had a far more ragged, rant-filled road, with significantly worse blunders, lies, and outbursts. And yet, it is still a coin toss, with the odds slightly favoring him.</p><p>That’s frustrating to Democrats, who think Trump has made a litany of disqualifying errors and statements, but none of them have stuck. Why not?</p><p>One reason may be that Trump’s main issues — when he stays on message — are the economy, immigration, and security, and those are proving to be more salient than the ones the Democrats focus on, such as democracy, abortion, and their record. They carry the weight of incumbency, and in 2024, that’s a drag.</p><p>A second, deeper reason is that Trump has become, essentially, surprise proof. He has so normalized personal character flaws and institutional distrust that it makes an October surprise impossible.</p><p>That merits a moment of reflection. The inherent assumption supporting an “October surprise” is that there are widely accepted conventions of behavior and social norms. When those are undermined or contradicted by a “surprise,” it will destroy a campaign. In past campaigns, that has been the exposure of lies, infidelities, corruption, a spelling error (the bar was so low for Dan Quayle), or a financial scandal. But we have had all of those in this run and … bupkis. Nothing moves. Harris might be more susceptible to a surprise because she is less well-known, but even her supporters don’t care about allegations of plagiarism or her policy flip-flops on fracking.</p><p>In 2024, the October surprise just doesn’t exist anymore. Polarization has so ossified the USA that partisans are shockproof. That may be a good thing as it means avoiding a cheap, manufactured scandal changing an election outcome, but it is also a sign that a healthy democracy is losing some of its early warning signals. Pain and surprise are signals to your body that something is wrong or threatening. It looks like today, the body politic feels no pain and, so, no surprise.</p><p>No matter what new story emerges in the final 12 days, don’t think for a moment it will make any difference. The biggest surprise will be on Nov. 5.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Crisis time for the politically homeless</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/crisis-time-for-the-politically-homeless</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfx1c4kazx07myfu2tl9hx</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 17 Oct 2024 19:00:11 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>us election</category>
<category>evan solomon</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>centrism</category>
<category>us politics</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>The right and left have drifted away from the political center in response to pressure from extreme positions on the fringes of their movements. Welcome to the age of the politically homeless.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcxvj7d6y607lqbm3r6fwg" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="665">
<media:credit>Paige Fusco</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcxvj7d6y607lqbm3r6fwg" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is decision time for the politically homeless.<br></p><p>With 18 days left in the coin-toss US election campaign, both Republicans and Democrats are engaged in a form of political fracking, desperately trying to extract pockets of votes in hard-to-reach places. That’s why you saw <strong>Kamala Harris</strong> take on <strong>Bret Baier</strong> on Fox News on Wednesday night.</p><p>On the surface, it seemed like a waste of time. Most people who watch Fox News are not going to vote for Harris, but she’s betting that <strong>Donald Trump</strong> has alienated many long-standing Republicans, like <strong>Mitt Romney</strong> or <strong>Dick Cheney</strong>, and she wants to offer them a temporary political home. In an election where a few thousand voters in the key seven swing states may change everything, Harris believes polls telling her that disaffected Republicans are a growing, available group.</p><p>A recent New York Times/Siena College <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/10/13/us/elections/times-siena-poll-likely-electorate-crosstabs.html"><u>survey</u></a> found that 9% of self-identified Republican voters nationally are voting for Harris, a number nearly twice what it was just five months ago. When Dick Cheney no longer feels at home in the big Republican tent, that’s not a Cheney problem, it’s a tent problem.</p><p>Democrats have their own tent problems. Some young people disaffected by the situation in Gaza are opting out of the Democratic Party, while some Jewish voters, traditionally Democrats, are backing Trump because of his overt support for Israel and his tough stance on Iran. And let’s not forget that about 20% of Black and Latino voters — especially men — see Trump as a better leader on the economy. As I have written about before, these men idolize the entrepreneurial genius and give-no-F’s aura of Trump hype man <strong>Elon Musk</strong>, who is consolidating that support. It is no surprise that former President <strong>Barack Obama</strong> is frantically out on the stumps chastising Black men for their lack of support for Harris.</p><p><strong>This is the age of the politically homeless.&nbsp;</strong>Don’t like the MAGA Republicans because of their embrace of extreme voices like Marjorie Taylor Greene, or the rejection of free trade in favor of high tariffs and protectionism? Where do you go? The left has also embraced tariffs, and it too has an extreme side, with protest groups calling President Biden “genocide Joe” for supporting Israel’s fight against the terrorist group Hamas.</p><p>The right and left have drifted away from the political center in response to pressure from extreme positions on the fringes of their movements.</p><p>“There are a lot of politically homeless folks out there, which is a function of the political realignment we’re seeing to a large degree across the Western world,” my colleague Graeme Thompson, senior analyst at Eurasia Group, told me. “Some former Republicans can’t stand Trump, some former Democrats don’t like left-wing campus politics, but neither have a comfortable place to land.”</p><p>In Canada, a country that could face a federal election at any time given the precarious nature of<strong> Justin Trudeau</strong>’s minority government, it’s not so different.</p><p>“More than 4 in 10 people likely consider themselves homeless in Canada,” <strong>Nik Nanos</strong>, chief data scientist and founder<strong>&nbsp;</strong>of Nanos Research, told me. “Major swaths of voters are not voting FOR anything — they are voting against things — in many cases someone they dislike. The enthusiasm is directed against someone.”</p><p>What this means is that the center cannot hold. “The Liberals’ move to the economic and cultural left under Trudeau has forced out a lot of fiscally conservative, socially moderate ‘blue Liberals’ who might end up voting for the Tories but don’t feel it’s a natural fit. Similarly — although to a lesser degree — this is true for so-called ‘red Tories,’” says Thompson.</p><p>One consistent error the bleeding center makes is to blame the extremes for the polarization. There is a relentless focus on the “weird” or “crazy” things that happen on the edges. But all this misses the larger point. It’s not that the fringes are inherently attractive — most voters live in the center — but the center has failed to make its case for relevance. There is precious little self-reflection on why the center is suddenly so soft and why it has failed to deliver for so many voters.</p><p>“Small ‘l’ liberals seem to have forgotten that liberalism isn’t self-evident, revealed truth — its case has to be made in the political arena,” says Thompson. “Moderates are on the back foot, in part, because “the other guys are worse” isn’t compelling enough in difficult times when voters are demanding answers.”</p><p>In his book “Trumpocalypse: Restoring American Democracy,” <strong>David Frum</strong>, maybe the most famous politically homeless Republican, does a superb job of outlining how the Burkean conservatives he championed squandered their arguments, especially on issues like the Middle East, the economy, and climate change. “In the twenty-first [century],” he writes, “that movement has delivered much more harm than good, from the Iraq War to the financial crisis to the Trump presidency.”</p><p>So while Republicans are trying to pick off small groups of politically homeless Democrats, like Black men and Jewish Americans, and Democrats are going after disaffected Republicans who believe Trump is bad for the country, the larger question remains: What can be done about it? Is the political center doomed, or can a new center emerge?</p><p>In the UK,<strong> Keir Starmer</strong> tacked to the political center to lead the once-more leftist Labour Party to a huge majority just a few months ago — a majority he now seems to be squandering.</p><p>But merely mouthing centrist words is just political lip-synching to cover up the fact that small “l” liberals no longer know how to play the instrument of government in a way that will solve the problems. Genuinely alienated voters have bolted to the fringes because they no longer believe government can actually solve the problems it promises it will solve. What to do about the cost of living, housing costs, and a feeling of powerlessness? These are deep problems that small “l” liberals have to solve to earn trust. That requires more than blame-game slogans.</p><p>“Being moderate isn’t a political program. You have to stand for <em>something</em>,” Thompson argues. “If there’s going to be a liberal, centrist, moderate political revival, it has to speak to the concerns of people.”</p><p>The paternalism of a government that spends money and gets involved in solving every problem for people not only fails to live up to its promises — it can’t solve everything — but it also creates a passive dependency, sending an implicit message that citizens can’t solve their own problems, only the government can. “When liberalism was successful in the past, it was about <em>empowering</em> people,” Thompson says. It doesn’t just rely on technocratic solutions from on high.</p><p>This doesn’t mean a new centrist party will emerge in the US or Canada. There is no real pattern for that, while the mainstream parties in both countries have a long history of changing and self-renovating, going from the extremes to the center and back again.</p><p>But for now, the fringes are ascendent, leaving behind wandering, zombie-like groups of politically homeless folks who can’t stand either side. These people are looking for reasons to vote Republican or Democrat without betraying their core principles, excusing crude mendacity, ignoring pressing problems, or ending up on the wrong side of history.</p><p>“With the advent of social media, voting against candidates or parties has been on the increase, which supercharges a negative political discourse,” says Nanos. “This has corresponded with increased anti-establishment sentiment. The impact is short-termism. Who can we punish today? Where can we vent our anger? The casualty is that discussions about long-term decisions are punted in favor of immediacy.”</p><p>That immediacy will likely mean most voters will ignore things they can’t stand and pick one salient issue — tax rates, climate, abortion, Israel, or Gaza — and cast a reluctant ballot.</p><p>“It’s hard to see the politically homeless being decisive this time around, either in the US or Canada,” says Thompson. “Except to the extent that they’ll hold their noses and pick a side.”</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>To the victim belongs the spoils: Why is there such a big political fight to become a victim?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/to-the-victim-belongs-the-spoils-why-is-there-such-a-big-political-fight-to-become-a-victim</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfwp42k9vu07mygp4qt3r3</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 10 Oct 2024 17:31:24 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>us election</category>
<category>economy</category>
<category>marjorie taylor greene</category>
<category>milton</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>hurricane</category>
<category>hurricane helene</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>The real victims of the deadly hurricanes Helene and Milton are the citizens of Florida, North Carolina, and four other states.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcxbfnci1507myoentd5uy" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>USA TODAY NETWORK via Reuters Connect</media:credit>
<media:text>Homes and cars were damaged in the Avenir development by a tornado from Hurricane Milton on October 10, 2024, in Palm Beach Gardens, Florida.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcxbfnci1507myoentd5uy" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The real victims of the deadly hurricanes Helene and Milton are the citizens of Florida, North Carolina, and four other states. Republicans and Democrats alike. Hurricanes don’t distinguish between voters, and all people are deserving of the same level of support. At least 230 people were killed by Hurricane Helene just weeks ago, and now, as I write this, the carnage of Milton, which just ripped through Florida, is still being assessed. How these victims vote should have no place in the discussion.</p><p>Georgia Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, aka MTG, has pitched a different theory: She believes the real victims of the hurricanes are Republicans, who are being targeted by Democrat-controlled storms to tilt election results.</p><p>“Yes they can control the weather,” she wrote on X after Hurricane Helene. “Anyone who says they don’t, or makes fun of this, is lying to you. By the way, the people know it and hate all of you who try to cover it up.”</p><p>Who are “they,” exactly?</p><p>MTG explained on social media that the hurricanes are partly controlled by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (I assume that is …“Deep Weather”?). Then she <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/mtgreenee/status/1841839254143381961"><u>brought out the maps</u></a> for the kicker.</p><p>“This is a map of hurricane affected areas with an overlay of electoral map by political party shows how hurricane devastation could affect the election,” she wrote on X, suggesting that Republican voting districts are being targeted by the … Democrat-controlled hurricanes.</p><p>A few months back, I wrote an article called “<a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/fake-clouds-seeding-doubt"><u>Fake Clouds, Seeding Doubt</u></a>” to debunk the weather conspiracy about a well-known program called cloud seeding that has been used to promote small amounts of rain in drought-prone areas. It has been used for more than 50 years and is not even close to controlling the weather with massive hurricanes. That is all paranoid nonsense, but very much on-brand for a Category 5 conspiracy theorist like MTG. Who can forget her 2018 antisemitic theory that Jewish-controlled space lasers caused forest fires?</p><p>As <strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/by-ian-bremmer/kamala-harris-and-donald-trumps-economic-plans-compared"><u>wrote</u></a> yesterday, the disinformation surrounding the genuine FEMA support for the victims of Hurricane Helene has proven dangerous, but it is just part of a bigger storm surge of campaign disinformation about everything from abortion to immigration to taxes to crime. Beneath it all, there is one strategy: Make your supporters feel like victims.</p><p>This is an old political tactic because it bonds a tribe of voters with a sense of identity against perceived and real threats, and, more importantly, it provides moral validation for counter-action. If the system is stacked against you, then any response — including, say, peaceful or violent protests — becomes justified. Vandals become activists. Insurrectionists are transformed into patriots.</p><p>A strategically cultivated sense of victimization is where the extremes on the right meet the extremes on the left. Some left-wing groups discovered the benefits of self-declared victimization long ago, and they have used it as a cudgel to silence debate, destroy property, and create odious conditions of political correctness.</p><p>Some groups on the right see themselves as constantly targeted by Big Pharma, Big Tech, fake media, biased justice systems — and now, by hurricanes.</p><p>This dynamic played out in painful ways on Oct. 7, marking one year since the brutal massacre of 1,200 innocent people in Israel and the kidnapping of 250 more by the terror group Hamas. For many in Israel and around the globe, the anniversary of Oct. 7 was a day to remember and honor those victims of Hamas.</p><p>But for some who have criticized Israeli Prime Minister <strong>Benjamin Netanyahu</strong>’s policy toward Palestinians and see his military actions in Gaza as an illegal form of collective punishment, Oct. 7 was a day of resistance.</p><p>Each side made the case that <em>they</em> are the real victims and therefore their response is justified, but in the endless regression of victimization and partisanship — you did this, but you did that first, etc. — basic morality got lost. One case of victimization doesn’t invalidate another.</p><p>Protesting Israel’s war tactics in Gaza against Hamas and the horrifically high civilian death toll is valid in any democracy — and it’s as common an occurrence inside Israel as it is outside of it. But should that prevent the acknowledgment and condemnation of the massacre of 1,200 innocent people in Israel? Should that disqualify a sovereign country’s right to self-defense against a terror group?</p><p>At its worst, the self-identifying of victimhood can be used to lend a moral fig leaf to cruel actions, but even victims of the worst violence must adhere to the rule of law, the rules of war, and the protection of human rights. That is not a sign of weakness in a society, but a sign of strength.</p><p>It also doesn’t mean you have to fall into the trap of false moral equivalency or mealymouthed both-sidesism. Calling out lies or excesses does not always reveal political bias, but an adherence to facts and humanity.</p><p>In the military, one of the worst sins is stolen valor, when someone pretends to have done things they didn’t do or pretends to have served when they didn’t. On the campaign trail, we see something else: stolen victimization.</p><p>Instead of focusing on the actual victims of violence — or weather — the stolen-victim folks make it all about them, hoarding the attention so it can be used for their political agendas, treating the suffering of people as props for their latest campaign.</p><p>In the hurricane of voices on the extreme right and left claiming the mantle of victimization, the partisanship divides grow deeper, and what democracies need most to solve problems gets lost: basic empathy.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The Likable Lies of Campaign 2024</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/the-likable-lies-of-campaign-2024</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfwd97l09b07lq24ozgj1m</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 03 Oct 2024 18:59:56 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>tim walz</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>jd vance</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Are likable liars the secret weapon of campaign 2024? After watching the screed-filled mayhem about immigrants eating pets that characterized the Donald Trump-Kamala Harris debate, the VP face-off was like sipping a cold beer in the middle of a heat wave. But something about this new political “decency” beer doesn’t taste right, and it’s causing a massive hangover.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcwrk7chh507myo32xhzyg" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcwrk7chh507myo32xhzyg" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Are likable liars the secret weapon of campaign 2024?</p><p>After the Tuesday night vice presidential debate ended, there was widespread praise about the demeanor of the candidates, Gov. <strong>Tim Walz</strong> and Sen. <strong>JD Vance</strong>. “Voters overwhelmingly characterized the debate as positive in tone,” <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/vp-debate-ratings-2024/"><u>wrote CBS News</u></a>, which hosted the debate and then conducted a poll right immediately afterward. The BBC headline used the word “<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/crr5j1q8wlno"><u>politeness</u></a>” to characterize the debate. GZERO used “<a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/civility-wins-vance-and-walz-play-mostly-nice-spar-on-policy"><u>civility</u></a>.” It’s true. A much-needed Midwestern decency prevailed throughout the VP debate, the expected personal attacks giving way to a wider policy discussion.</p><p>After watching the screed-filled mayhem about immigrants eating pets that characterized the <strong>Donald Trump-Kamala Harris</strong> debate, the VP face-off was like sipping a cold beer in the middle of a heat wave.</p><p>But something about this new political “decency” beer doesn’t taste right, and it’s causing a massive hangover. The common decency displayed by Vance and Walz cleverly masks constant deceptions, and yet that doesn’t seem to have any impact on the campaign. In fact, there’s more controversy about the candidates being fact-checked by journalists — that is their job! — than about candidates lying.</p><p>Vance won the debate because he had one job: Don’t look like the “weird” guy Democrats say you are, don’t insult women, don’t alienate voters by being the extreme Trump attack dog. He exceeded all expectations. He was prepared, likable, and polished, sawing off Trump’s rough edges with the candor and geniality that appeal to independent voters in swing states. On the surface, it was a master class and might well help secure Vance’s role as the Republican standard-bearer of the future. Below the surface, though, there was an indelible flaw: Vance kept lying.</p><p>For example, Vance claimed that Trump didn’t try to destroy the Affordable Care Act, known as Obamacare — but that he actually saved it! That was such a revisionist spin that it took me a while to even process it.</p><p><strong>“</strong>When<strong>&nbsp;</strong>Obamacare was crushing under the weight of its own regulatory burden and healthcare costs,” Vance declared smoothly, “Donald Trump could have destroyed the program. Instead, he worked in a bipartisan way to ensure that Americans had access to affordable care.”</p><p>It sounds so reasonable that you might forget that it has no connection to reality. Trump repeatedly claimed his goal was to “let Obamacare fail” and, in 2017, he brought in the “repeal and replace” vote to finally kill it. That vote failed when Trump’s nemesis, the late Sen. <strong>John McCain</strong>, famously gave it the 1 a.m. on-the-floor thumbs-down. Claiming Trump saved Obamacare is the equivalent of “We had to destroy the village to save the village,” the logical contradiction that became a parody of perfidy during the Vietnam War.</p><p>Vance’s likable lies extended to the violence of Jan. 6, 2021, and Trump’s overt attempt to illegally stop the peaceful transition of power. “It’s really rich for Democratic leaders to say that Donald Trump is a unique threat to democracy when he peacefully gave over power on January 20,” Vance said, as if the mob, the deaths, and the arrests of Jan. 6 never happened. The guy Vance replaced, former VP <strong>Mike Pence</strong>, has starkly contradicted this nonsensical claim, telling Fox News back in 2021 that he refused to comply with Trump and “his gaggle of crackpot lawyers” who “didn’t just ask me to pause. They asked me to reject votes, return votes, essentially to overturn the election.”</p><p>Just a reminder: Trump was impeached in the House of Representatives in 2021 because of his actions supporting the insurrection, and he was the first president in 150 years to be a no-show at the inauguration of his predecessor. Of course, Trump still claims the results of the election were fake, and this week he is facing new allegations about his potentially criminal actions leading up to the events of Jan. 6 as revealed in the recently unsealed legal brief from special counsel <strong>Jack Smith</strong>.</p><p>Later in the debate, it got worse, as Vance would not admit that the last election results were fair, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Rebranding Jan. 6 as a peaceful transition of power where a bunch of curious patriots took a friendly tour of the Capitol building is swampland in Florida that no sucker needs to buy.</p><p>Finally, Vance claimed that he “never supported a national ban” on abortion. “I did, during [sic] when I was running for Senate in 2022, talk about setting some minimum national standard.” Again, this sounds reasonable, and maybe Vance’s position has changed, but in <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oR_nD-pOWvA"><u>2022 he said on stage</u></a>, “I certainly would like abortion to be illegal nationally.”</p><p>Walz also had his likable liar moments. He had two jobs in the debate: Don’t look like the radical the Republicans claim you are and do no harm. Walz simply had to keep up his straight-talk, friendly neighbor, America’s coach persona. Apart from being nervous off the top and ragged and jumpy in his points, Walz for the most part did no harm, even if he was roundly seen as losing the debate by a slight margin. But he also could not explain his past lies.</p><p>Back in 2014, Walz declared to a congressional hearing that “as the events were unfolding [in Tiananmen Square, China], several of us went in. I still remember the train station in Hong Kong." Except he didn’t. Walz was in Nebraska at the time. When asked about it in the debate, Walz was flummoxed and fumbled badly, first saying he gets “caught up in the rhetoric,” then admitting that he is “a knucklehead at times” and then, finally, “All I said on this was, I got there that summer and misspoke on this. That is what I have said.” He never admitted that he had lied but made the weird case that being a good guy makes this excusable.</p><p>Walz later claimed that Trump hasn’t paid taxes in over a decade and half, which is also not true. According to a <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23559304-trumptax-joint-committee-final-report"><u>report by the Committee on Ways and Means</u></a>, Trump has paid taxes in some years, even if the rates were shockingly low. For example, he listed $641,931 in federal income tax in 2015 but only $750 in the next two years. Trump didn’t pay any taxes in 2020. Walz didn’t need to lie about Trump’s taxes as the evidence is already damning, but he did it anyway.</p><p>Revealing that politicians lie is about as shocking as saying the pope is Catholic. And to the credit of many organizations like CBS, CNN, and others, there were a lot of articles <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fact-check-vp-debate-2024/"><u>fact-checking the debate</u></a>. Still, no matter how frequently it happens, you wonder why it doesn't cause an anaphylactic voter reaction? After all, someone who lies to voters in a campaign will, logically, lie to them in power, and who wants that? Would voters rather have likable over believable?</p><p>Four years ago, Newsweek published a <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.newsweek.com/american-politics-poll-lying-more-acceptable-1540585"><u>survey</u></a> with Redfield and Wilton Strategies that showed 54% of Americans agree that “lying has become more acceptable in American politics.” Voters don’t care about a lying candidate because the end justifies the means. A new <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/4y28x"><u>study</u></a> called “When Truth Trumps Facts: Studies on Partisan Moral Flexibility in American Politics” examined “explicit moral justification for politicians’ statements that flagrantly violate the norm of fact-grounding.” The study found that when lies help push the overall political aims of a candidate to victory, their supporters have no issue with it.</p><p>“A lot of people’s support for politicians who say things that aren’t true isn’t because they believe those statements per se, but they view that misinformation as supporting political goals that they believe in,” one of the authors of the study, assistant professor <strong>Ethan Poskanzer</strong>, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.colorado.edu/today/2024/03/04/facts-ignored-truth-flexible-when-falsehoods-support-political-beliefs"><u>told</u></a> the University of Colorado.</p><p>The other factor at work here is sowing doubt in everything. The <strong>Steve Bannon</strong> “flood the zone with shit” strategy has tainted the political process, so partisan voters are urged to disbelieve anything that harms their candidate while believing everything their own leader says.</p><p>Lying can sometimes come off as crude, aggressive deception: “Immigrants are eating your pets!” And there are different kinds of lies: Some statements are blatant lies, others are exaggerations, and some are misleading, out-of-context statements used to make a point. So there are degrees, but let’s focus on the blatant lies because they are so obvious.</p><p>One other key factor to consider is frequency. Some candidates lie much more than others and so get called out for it more. In the presidential debate, Trump lied over 30 times while Harris told one lie and made a few misleading statements. Trump’s rate of lies might seem like a vulnerability, but he has cleverly turned it into an attack line, claiming that fact-checking proves that the fake news machine is biased against him. Repeat a lie, get called out for it, and claim you are the victim of a media conspiracy. It works. But it works even better when the candidate can do that and still be likable, and grab headlines for their decency, not their deception. That is what Vance and, to a lesser degree, Walz did.</p><p>In 2024, the likable liars may end up being the difference in a close election.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Scandals and hope at the UN: Is it worth it?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/scandals-and-hope-at-the-un-is-it-worth-it</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfvx40k7b807my5g971w0d</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 26 Sep 2024 16:55:45 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united nations</category>
<category>middle-east</category>
<category>geopolitics</category>
<category>israel</category>
<category>gaza</category>
<category>lebanon</category>
<category>unga</category>
<category>war</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>What good is the United Nations in 2024? With wars raging, AI disrupting, inequality growing, and climate change accelerating, UN Secretary-General António Guterres says that “a powder keg risks engulfing the world.&quot; That’s one reason, writes Publisher Evan Solomon, why the GZERO team is paying close attention to a giant gabfest, where leaders like President Joe Biden and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, policymakers, diplomats, and influencers from 193 countries have gathered this week to try to solve some of the world’s most intractable problems.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcvuzvcgm607my3324hf5a" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1179" height="674">
<media:credit>Belga Photo Nicolas Maeterlinck via Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>UN flags and logo.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcvuzvcgm607my3324hf5a" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What good is the United Nations in 2024?<br></p><p>With wars raging, AI disrupting, inequality growing, and climate change accelerating, UN Secretary-General <strong>António Guterres</strong> says that “a powder keg risks engulfing the world.”</p><p>That’s one reason why the GZERO team is paying close attention to a giant gabfest, where leaders like President <strong>Joe Biden</strong> and Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>, policymakers, diplomats, and influencers from 193 countries have gathered this week to try to solve some of the world’s most intractable problems.</p><p>It’s why you saw <strong>Ian Bremmer’s</strong> <a target="_blank" href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/video/gzero-world-with-ian-bremmer/why-antonio-guterres-believes-the-un-should-lead-on-ai-exclusive-interview">exclusive interview with Guterres</a> on our PBS TV program <strong>GZERO World</strong> or, as we reported today in our morning newsletter, we have Iran’s Vice President for Strategic Affairs <strong>Mohammad Javad Zarif</strong> on the show denying that Iran was involved in the assassination attempts on former President <strong>Donald Trump</strong>, while admitting that US election hacking came from someone in his country. <em>Watch the clip&nbsp;</em><a target="_blank" href="https://gzeromedia.us12.list-manage.com/track/click?u=7404e6dcdc8018f49c82e941d&amp;id=e365344f93&amp;e=5872c95bb9">here</a><em> and tune in next week for the full interview on GZERO World with Ian Bremmer.</em></p><p>It’s also why we hosted and broadcast a series of key livestreams with world leaders covering everything from <a target="_blank" href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/global-stage/un-general-assembly/can-we-use-ai-to-secure-the-worlds-digital-future">governing AI</a> to the conflicts in Europe, Lebanon, Gaza, and Ukraine.</p><p>I have been incredibly proud of the work the team has done sorting through the global noise to get at the clear political signals while highlighting the issues in an insightful, nonpartisan way.</p><p>But the question remains: Why bother paying attention to the UN?</p><p>It’s easy to be cynical about the UN. As Brett Stephens once <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/23/opinion/john-bolton-un-united-nations.html?mtrref=t.co&amp;gwh=342F43855D97176A5FE37AB9EF606EA1&amp;gwt=pay&amp;assetType=opinion&amp;fbclid=IwY2xjawFiYA5leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHZwN1TPFMU-PmObhlg3J8NKF_zBgTRWO0vtaFzFCtZ7QVR0fOnBAEMoc7w_aem_bLKKg4m9dU1_OUrdSksCrg">described it</a>, “The U.N. is a never-ending scandal disguised as an everlasting hope. The hope is that dialogue can overcome distrust, and collective security can be made to work in the interests of humanity. Reality says otherwise.”</p><p>Scandals, failures, hypocrisies, and disappointments fly around the UN as prominently as the flags around its New York City headquarters, and Stephens waved many of them, from the failure to stop the genocide in Rwanda and the massacre in Srebrenica, to corruption in the oil-for-food program in Iraq. That was back in 2018.</p><p>Today there are even more, from the outrage surrounding allegations that some UNRWA workers worked with Hamas during the Oct. 7 massacres, to the obstructive dysfunctions of the five permanent members that have veto powers, which has proven to be a tragic obstacle to real global action in key conflicts, like Sudan. It’s hard to take the UN seriously when Iran gets a turn chairing its Human Rights Council Social Forum.</p><p>Even reading through the main agenda of the 79th General Assembly session, it’s understandable why some critics experience high-speed eye-rolling that rivals the backspin on a <strong>Roger Federer</strong> backhand. For example, one goal says: “Achieving global nuclear disarmament is the highest disarmament priority of the United Nations.” How’s that going? Just yesterday, Russian leader <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong> announced that he was alerting his nuclear doctrine to lower the threshold needed to justify the use of nuclear weapons, a major escalation in the war in Ukraine.</p><p>Meanwhile, less than 20% of the famed 17 Sustainable Development Goals are on track to be completed by 2030.</p><p>“The Secretariat Building in New York has 38 stories. If you lost 10 stories today it wouldn’t make a bit of difference,” quipped <strong>John Bolton</strong>, the US ambassador to the UN under former President <strong>George W. Bush</strong>. Many critics today still think he’s right.</p><p>But is he?</p><p>Only pointing out the UN’s failures to solve complex global problems is like describing <strong>Ted Williams</strong> as a guy who failed to get a hit 60% of the time, instead of noting that a baseball player hitting .400 is one of the greatest feats in sports. It’s like dismissing venture capital investors as losers because at least 80% of their investments go bust, instead of focusing on the ones that succeed and more than make up for the other losses. In very hard challenges, a low success rate can still be a major victory.</p><p>Back in 1973, <strong>Horst Rittel</strong> and <strong>Melvin Webber</strong> coined the term “wicked problem” to describe political, environmental, or security challenges that are uniquely difficult to solve and may have no single right answer. That’s where the UN is needed most, to pull in global voices that often disagree or are at war with each other and make a genuine attempt to solve wicked problems. That takes time.</p><p>The fact is, there are many UN successes, notably the World Food Programme, which helps over 80 million people, delivering food, medicines, and vaccines to countries in crisis. There are peace treaties and accords establishing norms and conventions, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, its most famous document.</p><p>This past week, there was a major success in global governance on AI with the Global Digital Compact, which was signed by most major countries except Russia. They agreed to everything from global standards on accessibility, use, and design, to the establishment of an international scientific panel, which will — like the IPCC does for climate — create a measuring tool and a road map for how AI governance might unfold. There is literally no other place in the world where this could happen.</p><p>Is there a need for UN reform? Of course. That is why, for example, there is a strong push to create two permanent seats for Africa on the Security Council. In this <a target="_blank" href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/video/ian-explains/ian-explains-why-is-the-un-s-summit-of-the-future-so-important">video</a> that I urge you to check out, <strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> argues that despite the challenges facing the world’s largest multilateral organization, the UN is more relevant than ever.</p><p>But the institution is only as good as the members make it through their financial contributions, attendance, and support. One of the key challenges is making all the work that is happening — and there is a lot — understandable and relevant to the wider public in order to overcome the massive trust deficit the UN faces.</p><p>Reestablishing trust takes radical transparency, and that’s why GZERO has made such an effort to pull back the curtain and give people a chance to see, hear, and debate the real policies and ideas that are being pitched. You should be able to judge for yourself if the UN is useful or not. We hope our coverage gives you the tools to do just that.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The Real Campaign Hunger Games</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/the-real-campaign-hunger-games</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfvj53k6b707my0dxgs88s</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 19 Sep 2024 19:17:34 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>food crisis</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>This is campaign season, which is the time when political leaders serve up all kinds of promises to fix stuff. But so far food insecurity has drawn as much political interest as a slab of tofu at a steakhouse.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcuxlncfkk07myd2fs4o4q" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>WSCAH</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcuxlncfkk07myd2fs4o4q" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the madness that is the US presidential race, there’s been a lot of rancid talk about immigrants and food. The relentless Trump-Vance disinformation about Haitians in Springfield, Ohio, eating pets, which I <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/its-raining-cats-dogs-and-disinformation"><u>wrote about last week</u></a>, has now led to bomb threats, online hatred, and more negative attention than finding a finger in a box of french fries.</p><p>But something is missing. No one is talking about the obvious underlying issue here: <em>hunger</em>.</p><p>The thought occurred to me this week when I met chef <strong>Greg Silverman</strong>, CEO and executive director of New York based nonprofit <a target="_blank" href="http://www.wscah.org/">West Side Campaign Against Hunger</a>, or WSCAH, which has been giving out high-quality meals to low-income New Yorkers for more than 40 years.</p><p>Tall, bearded, and enveloped <em>en papillote</em>-style in a loosely tailored suit, Chef Greg has the natural charisma of a great restaurateur, but also the happily harried air of a dad raising two young kids while working his ass off on a passion project. He is both.</p><p>He is also something of an oddity in the world of chefs. Silverman studied politics and anthropology at Ithaca College in western New York, and did a stint in the Peace Corps after that. Drawn to the food scene, he opened three successful restaurants in Ithaca. But he soon realized that the people who really needed good meals were not the ones who could afford to come to a restaurant. That’s when he found his mission: get good food to people who need it most.</p><p>He got a Master’s degree in food policy in London, returned to the US as an activist working to end child hunger, and after a stint running Michelle Obama’s Chefs Move to Schools initiative, Silverman was tapped to lead WSCAH.</p><p>Founded in the basement of a church on Manhattan’s Upper West Side in 1979, WSCAH’s mission is to provide New Yorkers of all income levels with high-quality fresh food. When the organization first started it served about 900 people. Today it gives out some 5 million pounds of food annually to more than 25,000 families. And 50% of it is fresh, not canned!</p><p>I met Greg this week at a small gathering in New York where he was talking about WSCAH’s work. Having only moved here within the last few years, I had a general sense that food insecurity plagues America’s largest city, as it does my native stomping grounds of Ottawa and Toronto. But I didn’t realize just how severe the crisis was right now.</p><p>“The situation in NYC continues to get worse and worse,” Greg told me. “The pandemic was our greatest number of customers ever but the post pandemic has blown that away. With stagnating city and state dollars, ending of pandemic era supports like child tax credits and reduction of the SNAP allotments for seniors, it’s a horrifically perfect storm.” SNAP stands for the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, what many used to call “food stamps.”</p><p>Silverman told me that rising food prices generally have forced WSCAH to spend a million more dollars on food this year, while the growing migrant crisis in New York – in which more than 150,000 people have arrived without access to long-term housing, work, or benefits like SNAP – has exacerbated the city’s food insecurity situation. More than 1 in 7 NYC residents are now food insecure, he said, a significant increase from previous years.</p><p>And it is not just the Big Apple. According to the<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition-assistance/food-security-in-the-u-s/key-statistics-graphics/"> <u>USDA</u></a>, 13.5% of all US households, or about 18 million people, were “food insecure at some time during 2023.” That’s a million more than the year before. And of that group, nearly 7 million people suffer “very low food security,” meaning they actually go hungry at times. These are households where someone’s mom, dad, brother, or sister is <em>not</em> eating in order for another member of the household to get enough food.</p><p>Hunger, of course, is a cascading problem, particularly for kids. It is hard to focus on class if you’re hungry, and that can <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://apnews.com/article/free-school-lunch-child-hunger-7d38b5a84e533129f507d76cc05c622f"><u>start a bad cycle</u></a> of stunted learning, school dropouts, and derailed lives. If you think the cost of eating is high, try the costs of not eating.</p><p>But what can we do about it?</p><p>This is campaign season, which is the time when political leaders serve up all kinds of promises to fix stuff. But so far food insecurity has drawn as much political interest as a slab of tofu at a steakhouse. Greg wants to change that.</p><p>It turns out there are some basic policy solutions that could make a big difference to millions of hungry Americans, at substantially lower cost than, say, building a border wall or trying to federally manage grocery prices. And it can happen in a SNAP, literally.</p><p>Greg says there are two bills in Congress that would strengthen SNAP. The Closing the Meal Gap Act, which would boost benefits for all participants, and the Hot Foods Act of 2023, which would enable beneficiaries to purchase hot prepared foods from food retailers.</p><p>At the state level, Greg argues there is even more to do. “States could create a program that would fund food benefits for people currently ineligible for the federal SNAP program due to their citizenship status,” he says.</p><p>That would help to end surreal situations like the one where a migrant woman came to WSCAH, ineligible for SNAP support because she didn’t have a Social Security number. When she mentioned she was pregnant, WSCAH pointed out to her that when a child is born in the US, he or she automatically becomes eligible for SNAP, along with the mother.</p><p>In other words, in the United States in 2024, a pregnant migrant woman can’t get support to eat until her child is born. It makes no sense.</p><p>“By removing immigrant exclusions, we can ensure that every New Yorker has the food they urgently need,” Greg says. You wish a politician would talk so clearly.</p><p>Maybe making America great – in whatever way we imagine that – isn’t about riling people up or demonizing hungry, vulnerable people like the folks in Springfield.</p><p>Maybe it’s about restoring dignity to people who long ago were pushed to the floor, left to crawl around for political crumbs<strong>.&nbsp;</strong>After all, “dignity” is part of the core mandate of WSCAH, and it matters.</p><p>“Folks need to bring this back to communities and people,” Greg says. “It’s hard to hate people as individuals once we meet each other, when we break bread, when we help each other. We don't ask about politics, income, we just help each other and as the Ohio controversy shows, we forget the biggest thing: that hunger may be driving people to desperate ends.”</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>It’s Raining Cats, Dogs, and Disinformation</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/its-raining-cats-dogs-and-disinformation</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfv6f3kwoq07lqcad21g7e</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 12 Sep 2024 19:20:46 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>politics</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>We are now in the “debate over the debate” phase of the presidential campaign. Who actually won? Were the moderators biased? How will it impact votes in the swing states where this whole election hinges?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcue22d3nv07lqjkpdzy5j" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>The presidential debate between former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris is shown at a watch party hosted by the Travis County and Hays County Republicans at Pinballz Kingdom in Buda on Tuesday, September 10, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcue22d3nv07lqjkpdzy5j" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We are now in the “debate over the debate” phase of the presidential campaign. Who actually won? Were the moderators biased? How will it impact votes in the swing states where this whole election hinges?</p><p>The general consensus is that Harris trounced Trump. Even on Fox News, chief political analyst <strong>Brit Hume</strong> admitted that “Trump had a bad night,” while Harris “kept her cool.”</p><p>The vice president successfully set up Trump with taunts about his crowd sizes, his deference to dictators, and his disrespect for the military.</p><p>Trump bit at the bait as if it were one of those delicious domestic pets in his unsubstantiated bloviation about immigrants eating cats and dogs in Ohio. He instantly reverted to his fulminating rally rants about doctors murdering babies after they are born (false) or how he dealt very strongly with a guy named Abdul, who he wrongly claimed was the head of the Taliban. (The name of the leader is actually <strong>Hibatullah</strong>.)</p><p>Still, it was the outrageous story about pet-eating Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, that has become the meme of choice. “They’re eating the dogs. They’re eating the cats,” Trump claimed. “They’re eating the pets of the people that live there.”</p><p>Immediately, ABC moderator <strong>David Muir</strong> corrected the former president, citing Springfield’s city manager, <strong>Bryan Heck</strong>, who wrote that there have been “no credible reports or specific claims of pets being harmed, injured or abused by individuals within the immigrant community.”</p><p><strong>Alas, credible reports have no credibility for the credulous.&nbsp;</strong>The Trump campaign has run with this story. His running mate, <strong>JD Vance</strong>,<strong>&nbsp;</strong>has encouraged people to spread the pet-eating lie <em>even though he&nbsp;</em><a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/JDVance/status/1833505359513661762"><em>admitted on X</em></a><em> that it might be false</em>. “It’s possible, of course,” he wrote, “that all of these rumors will turn out to be false.”</p><p>This is a remarkable admission by a major party candidate and merits a moment of reflection, if such moments still exist in the shyte-flooded zone of information. Vance is doing something different than Trump and other politicians. Trump tells a lie but pretends it is the truth. “I won the last election,” for example. That now seems old-fashioned. But listen to how Vance defends promoting the fake story. “If we have to meme about it to get the media to care,” <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.axios.com/2024/09/11/vance-immigrants-pets-conspiracy-theory"><u>Vance said</u></a>, “we’re going to keep doing it.”</p><p>It is not about a moral position on truth, or a leader’s responsibility to avoid divisive rhetoric. It’s merely a cost-benefit analysis in the campaign, and it works. So, as he says, they will keep doing it. Spreading disinformation is now not just normalized, it is actively encouraged.</p><p>In a similar vein, in the days since the debate, Trump has blamed the moderators for his performance, claimed the event was “rigged” against him, and suggested that ABC should lose its license. To be fair, he was fact-checked four times while Harris was not fact-checked at all, but he also got a full five minutes more speaking time than she did, which is a massive advantage in a debate.</p><p>And just like the Springfield stories, the notion that the debate was a “three on one” sham has taken hold as gospel truth in Trumpville. Why is that? Part of the reason is that the groundwork was laid beforehand, by bots and other online misinfo merchants.</p><p>To show how, GZERO partnered with Cyabra, a company that uses AI algorithms to track disinformation online. We looked specifically at trust in the presidential debate, <strong>analyzing more than 1,500 online profiles&nbsp;</strong>that discussed ABC News moderator <strong>David Muir</strong> in the run-up to the debate.</p><p>At least <strong>15% of these</strong> profiles were identified as <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/bonnie80101/status/1833273577522516165"><u>fake</u></a> … making it difficult for users to distinguish between authentic and<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/JosephSmth_010/status/1833310181129916687"> <u>inauthentic</u></a> conversations. And the fake profiles “specifically spread negative content about Muir, claiming his political bias was in favor of Kamala Harris, suggesting Muir would <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/lvakitas1/status/1833327414891663432"><u>undermine Trump</u></a> during the debate.”</p><p>Some of the fake profiles even “pushed a false narrative that ABC provided Harris with debate questions but withheld them from Trump.” That is to say: Before the debate even started, people were encouraged to believe that it was rigged against Trump.</p><p>As <strong>Mark Twain</strong> supposedly once said, “A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still putting on its shoes.”</p><p>But in today’s world, there isn’t even time for the truth to get out of bed, let alone put on footwear. The mere fact that there is more outrage over a journalist fact-checking a lie than about a politician actually telling a lie is perhaps the most revealing aspect of the normalized world of disinformation. The Trump campaign and its supporters know this, and they are feasting on the possibilities like so many, er, dogs and cats.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Conscious Uncouplings: Why Political Alliances Don’t Last</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/conscious-uncouplings-why-political-alliances-dont-last</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfus7xk41807myyboa22jh</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 05 Sep 2024 17:01:22 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>politics</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Every opposition party in Canada wants to run against Trudeau because they see him as deeply vulnerable. The wheel of change is turning.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrctt54cefv07my1n1pdusc" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>Liberal leader Justin Trudeau and NDP leader Jagmeet Singh take part in the federal election English-language Leaders debate in Gatineau, Canada, September 9, 2021.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrctt54cefv07my1n1pdusc" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Breakup alert, breakup alert!</p><p>No, this is not another report on Bennifer — the perpetually entropic relationship between <strong>Jennifer Lopez</strong> and <strong>Ben Affleck</strong>.</p><p>And no, it is not another story about the Democrats-Biden breakup, though that still resonates as the blockbuster <strong>Kamala Harris</strong> vs. <strong>Donald Trump</strong> debate tilt gets going next week.</p><p>No, this is about the big breakup in Canada that sets the clock ticking on the next federal election, which by law has to take place before Oct. 20, 2025. The only question is, how soon will it come?</p><p>It used to be that political breakups were a sign of things falling apart for a party, but after the Dems ditched Biden at the altar, they’re suddenly living their best lives with Harris, with money pouring in and momentum in the polls. Breakups have been rebranded as ... creative destruction. We had to destroy the leader of the party to save the party!</p><p>Democrats believe their shotgun political marriage with Harris and <strong>Tim Walz</strong> will prove long-lasting — and not end up like some crazy night in Vegas, where they wake up with a wedding ring and a face tattoo, reliving the electoral version of “The Hangover.” What the heck did we just do? But for now, no one there has any doubts: The change has been very good for them.</p><p>Which brings us to <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>, who yesterday got ditched by his lefty bestie, New Democratic leader <strong>Jagmeet Singh</strong>. For those of you not following the machinations of Canada’s parliamentary democracy, here’s the quick background:</p><p>After Trudeau won another minority government in 2021, he needed the support of another party to stay in power. He craved some stability and got it when he struck an unusual deal, called a “confidence and supply” agreement, with the NDP — the further-left-of-center fourth-place party. It wasn’t quite a coalition — no NDP member was in Trudeau’s cabinet — but rather more of a friends-with-benefits arrangement. The NDP agreed to keep the Liberals in power until 2025 in exchange for passing progressive policies like dental care and Pharmacare, which the Liberals finally did.</p><p>All that ended yesterday. According to reports from the CBC, Singh didn’t even dump Trudeau in person. At 12: 47 p.m., he informed Trudeau’s office that he was ending the deal. A mere seven minutes later, Singh released his now-famous breakup video. Ouch. Breaking up by video is modern, I guess, but it’s barely a step above ghosting someone. This was straight out of a “Mean Girls” script, but such is the nature of politics.</p><p>“Justin Trudeau has proven again and again he will always cave to corporate greed,” Singh said, hinting at things like the back-to-work legislation the Liberals recently passed to avoid a strike at CN rail, which could’ve wound the economy. “The Liberals have let people down. They don’t deserve another chance from Canadians,” Singh said, trying to distance himself from the very government he propped up so enthusiastically for years.</p><p>Why now?</p><p>First, the Liberals are so unpopular that the deal to support them has outlived its usefulness and become a liability. And for all their talk about taking credit for the Liberals' progressive legislation, the NDP has never benefited from working with the Liberals anyway. “The NDP has been polling around 17 to 19% now for over a few years,” says CEO and chair of Abacus <strong>David Coletto</strong>. “But the Liberal drop hasn’t translated into any net gains for them.”</p><p>Putting a barge pole between the NDP and the Liberals is important for Singh, who is being cross-contaminated by Trudeau’s unpopularity. “86% of Canadians want change,” Coletto told me. “It’s hard to be that change when you’re being held responsible for propping up the government and prime minister Canadians want to change. So it was inevitable the NDP would need to make a clear break from the government.”</p><p>Second, Singh believes the Liberals are at an all-time low and this moment may be the best time to beat them again, as they once did in 2011 under then-leader <strong>Jack Layton</strong>, who surfed on an orange wave that brought the NDP to official opposition status for the first time.</p><p>Still, the math is tricky as the NDP are stuck in the same pollster Hades as the Liberals. “There’s no reason from polls that they should want an election unless they believe we have hit the bottom of Liberal popularity,” says Coletto.</p><p>Every opposition party in Canada wants to run against Trudeau because they see him as deeply vulnerable. The wheel of change is turning. The big question: Will waiting to call an election give Trudeau time to leave and allow a new leader — Kamala Harris-like — to arrive and revive Liberal fortunes?</p><p>Third, with crucial provincial elections in BC and Saskatchewan and two key by-elections on Sept. 16 happening, the NDP needs to look like leaders, not junior partners, if they want to be taken seriously,<strong>&nbsp;</strong>so they can’t look too close to the Liberals. “New Democrats are working to take on the Conservatives across the country,” says <strong>Kathleen Munk</strong>, a longtime NDP strategist and Layton’s former communications director. “But that is harder to do so with one hand tied behind your back.”</p><p>Now what?</p><p>This does not mean the Liberal government will fall. The Conservatives will certainly try to test Singh’s commitment to change by calling a non-confidence vote, likely later this month, but I don’t see the NDP taking the bait right away. Instead, they will now function on a vote-by-vote basis as most minority parliaments have done, and likely prop up the Liberal government until the new year.</p><p>That’s why this is not a real breakup but more of a conscious uncoupling, a strategic way to look independent without letting the government fall and allowing the heavily favored Conservatives to swoop into power. “No question creating some daylight between them and the dark shadow of the Trudeau Liberals is politically advantageous,” says Munk. “The NDP need to make sure New Democrat voices are heard, clear of the noise coming from the Liberals.” This deal break is more like moving out of your parents’ house but still having them pay your rent and do your laundry.</p><p>The Conservatives are baiting Singh to take down the government, but insiders know not to hold their breath. “Like any good breakup, separating takes time,” says <strong>Tim Powers</strong>, founder of Summa Strategies and a longtime Conservative strategist. “You can say you aren’t together, but that usually only becomes true when you can be seen to be moving on. In this case, voting against the Liberals on a confidence motion would definitely be the case. But hard to see a set of scorned lovers here given the dog’s breakfast of polls that benefits only the Conservatives.”</p><p>If there is no immediate federal election, is this just a case of “Singh and the Fury” signifying nothing? In the short term, yes, but it has accelerated the likelihood of a federal election, even as the NDP uses this time to try to rebuild. It also forces Trudeau to decide whether he wants to run again or step aside. If Trudeau loses that critical Sept. 16 by-election in Montreal in what should be the safe seat of his former justice minister — and polls show it is a toss-up right now — his party will find its inner <strong>Nancy Pelosi</strong> and start a conscious uncoupling on its own.</p><p>Political alliances never last long, and minority governments in Canada usually have a shelf life of about two years. An election is overdue, and this deal was never going to last until 2025. But the notion that some kind of Kamala Harris-like creative destruction of the Liberal-NDP alliance will stop the Conservatives, who are 20 points ahead and cruising, is a hope, not a strategy.</p><p>Voters want change, for sure, but more than a change of strategic arrangements, they want a change in results. For a government that has been in office for as long as the Liberals, better results on home prices, inflation, and the cost of living might be the only thing to keep voters from executing a conscious uncoupling at the ballot box.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The tariffs strike back: Is this the end of globalization?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/the-tariffs-strike-back-is-this-the-end-of-globalization</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfujbtkupv07lq7lnxiwtb</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 29 Aug 2024 17:14:23 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>us election</category>
<category>2024 presidential election</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>globalization</category>
<category>tariffs</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>protectionism</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>It used to be that the conservative right supported free trade and globalization, while the progressive left wanted protectionism for local industries. But in this campaign cycle — it’s as if a sequel titled “The Tariffs Strike Back” has been released — we must wonder, writes Publisher Evan Solomon: Is this the beginning of the end of globalization and the rise of a new age of tariffs?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrbcfhp9of407lq2wwq2kbm" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Ari Winkleman</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrbcfhp9of407lq2wwq2kbm" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My political compass has been spinning lately, and not just because <strong>Robert F. Kennedy Jr.</strong> admitted to ditching a bear corpse in Central Park before finally endorsing <strong>Donald J. Trump</strong> (that one caused a bit of political vertigo). My deeper confusion stems from the political debate about protecting our jobs.</p><p>It used to be, reliably, that the conservative right supported free trade and globalization, while the progressive left wanted protectionism for local industries.</p><p>Elections were fought on this, libraries were filled with studies on it.</p><p>For Republicans, <strong>Ronald Reagan</strong>’s 1988 Thanksgiving address was considered economic theology. “One of the key factors behind our nation’s great prosperity is the open trade policy that allows the American people to freely exchange goods and services with free people around the world,” the Gipper said.</p><p>That era ended under Trump’s first administration when he used two tools to impose tariffs on a wide-ranging series of goods: Section 301 (tariffs that combat unfair trade practices) and Section 232 (tariffs that protect national security). These tariffs hit almost $280 billion of goods and, according to the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/the-total-cost-of-tariffs/"><u>American Action Forum</u></a>, increased consumer costs by over $51 billion a year. By the way, <strong>Joe Biden</strong> kept most of these in place. Recently, Biden went even further, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2024/05/14/fact-sheet-president-biden-takes-action-to-protect-american-workers-and-businesses-from-chinas-unfair-trade-practices/"><u>slapping</u></a> $18 billion worth of tariffs on Chinese-produced EVs, semiconductors, and critical minerals, among other things. This is all part of the industrial policy he ushered in under the Inflation Reduction Act. So both sides love a good tariff.</p><p>But in this campaign cycle — it’s as if a sequel titled “The Tariffs Strike Back” has been released — we must wonder: Is this the beginning of the end of globalization and the rise of a new age of tariffs?</p><p>Both Republicans and Democrats are making tariff-happy promises. Trump has mused on the campaign trail that he would like to impose a 10% tariff on all goods coming into the US.</p><p>“When companies come in and they dump their products in the United States, they should pay automatically, let’s say, a 10% tax … I do like the 10% for everybody,” the former president explained.</p><p>And it is not just in the US. Tariffs are being used everywhere.<strong>&nbsp;</strong>This week, Canadian Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> aligned with the US and<strong>&nbsp;</strong>announced tariffs on Chinese-made EVs starting Oct. 1, and another 25% tariff on Chinese steel and aluminum.</p><p>“Actors like China have chosen to give themselves an unfair advantage in the global marketplace,” Trudeau said, “compromising the security of our critical industries and displacing dedicated Canadian auto and metal workers.”</p><p>He’s not wrong. China does have widespread, unfair trading practices. Using tariffs to rebalance against factors like low-wage workers or weak environmental standards is useful, as they can be to deal with trade imbalances. But it’s a slippery slope. Tariffs beget tariffs, and that starts a trade war where everyone loses.</p><p>Tariffs were critical to Trump’s first administration, especially as he renegotiated the NAFTA agreement with Mexico and Canada. But economists at places like the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cato.org/blog/americans-paid-trump-tariffs-would-do-so-again"><u>CATO Institute concluded</u></a> that tariffs cost taxpayers anywhere from $50 to $80 billion in higher prices. “American consumers (both firms and individuals), not foreigners, paid for — and continue to pay for — the tariffs,” the experts wrote.</p><p>So why are they back? If Trump 1.0 taught politicians across the spectrum anything, it's that there are no votes in supporting globalization. Most states and provinces have lost jobs and plants to cheap labor in places like China and Mexico, and protecting jobs wins elections today, even if it means higher prices tomorrow.</p><p>And that’s exactly what it means. According to the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.americanprogressaction.org/article/trumps-tariff-would-cost-the-typical-american-household-roughly-1500-each-year/"><u>Center for American Progress Action Fund</u></a>, if Trump were to impose the across-the-board 10% tariff, it “would amount to a roughly $1,500 annual tax increase for the typical household, including a $90 tax increase on food, a $90 tax increase on prescription drugs, and a $120 tax increase on oil and petroleum products.” And there is a real debate as to whether higher tariffs, which aim to create jobs, actually do so.</p><p>A study from the US Department of Agriculture revealed that Trump’s 2018 tariffs on major trading partners like China, Canada, and Mexico cost billions due to retaliation. “From mid-2018 to the end of 2019, this study estimates that retaliatory tariffs caused a reduction of more than $27 billion (or annualized losses of $13.2 billion) in US agricultural exports,” the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/pub-details/?pubid=102979">study said</a>.</p><p>This is a case of Hobson’s choice: Keep some manufacturing jobs in your community, but face higher prices, lower productivity, and retaliation from other countries. After all, one tariff begets another, and the costs pile up. But the political gains are real, so protectionism is on the march again.</p><p>Trump’s VP running mate, Sen. <strong>JD Vance</strong>, recently defended tariffs and, to be fair, many countries have massive exceptions to free trade that include cutouts to protect certain industries with subsidies and quotas. In the US, national security is used extensively as a form of industrial policy — Trump, for example, imposed tariffs on steel and aluminum imports, citing national security concerns. And in Canada, banks and milk and cheese farmers in Quebec are protected.</p><p>But Vance has gone further, arguing that tariffs in principle are a net economic gain. A tariff “causes this dynamic effect where more jobs come into the country,” Vance <a target="_blank" href="https://www.nbcnews.com/meet-the-press/video/jd-vance-denies-that-trump-s-tariffs-would-be-a-tax-on-americans-full-interview-217925701890"><u>recently said</u></a> on “Meet the Press.” “Anything that you lose on the tariff from the perspective of the consumer, you gain in higher wages, so you’re ultimately much better off. You have more take-home pay, you have better jobs,” he added.</p><p>By that logic, more tariffs would keep growing the economy, so where will they stop? That is the road to end any form of free trade and globalization.</p><p>Strangely, Vance’s argument not only flies against the conventional wisdom of his own party — the GOP has long advocated for free trade and open markets — but it also parrots what the left argued for decades as they fought free trade and globalization even as they were ridiculed by people like Reagan.</p><p>During Trump’s first term, the Ronald Reagan Presidential Foundation published <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.reaganfoundation.org/reagan-institute/publications/is-the-gop-still-the-party-of-free-trade/?srsltid=AfmBOoo-89o000ybqzRdf9Sf0n29WNDKI_9nOrhg8VS8b2D6AbEQr3CC"><u>a piece</u></a> called “Is the GOP Still the Party of Free Trade?” and concluded that they are not, especially after Trump took the US out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership. That was a multilateral trade agreement with Asian countries meant to keep a strong US presence in Asia as a hedge against China. While 191 Republicans originally voted for it, <em>that</em> Republican Party no longer exists. “The effective abandonment of its free trade credentials sets the Republican Party on a perilous path,” wrote <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.reaganfoundation.org/reagan-institute/publications/is-the-gop-still-the-party-of-free-trade/?srsltid=AfmBOorlU22EveGS8eXDno5wrw9cYwi7AgRsUvmexWJc9Hz8LV8_zkXT"><u>Phil Levy</u></a> of the Reagan Foundation.</p><p>Democrats must be delighted that an argument they once lost so publicly is being relitigated. Now, both sides are arguing for the same thing and trying to outdo each other. It will be interesting to hear what <strong>Kamala Harris</strong> says about this as she finally reveals some policy.</p><p>We have now gone from embracing concepts like “nearshoring” and “friendshoring” for critical supply chain products like medicine and AI chips to picking winners and losers across the economy. This is 1970s industrial policy, and the distinction between the left and the right on this has become minimal.</p><p>Is this how globalization dies, one tariff at a time, in a series of trade wars and spats, Brexits and exits, until finally, the trade walls are back up, productivity plummets, and prices rise? Or is there a happy medium, where these global fights lead to a rise in both labor and environmental standards in places like China and Mexico and the cliched expression “fair trade, not free trade” actually becomes a reality?</p><p>Either way, it won’t be quick and, in the meantime, brace yourself for higher prices as your political compass keeps spinning wildly out of control.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The Framing of Kamala Harris</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/the-framing-of-kamala-harris</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfu6g6ktqt07lq24mau0ul</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 22 Aug 2024 17:59:01 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>politics</category>
<category>us election</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>democratic national convention</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>us politics</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Happy Thursday.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcsuuecd0407my5qkzbx2r" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675" />
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcsuuecd0407my5qkzbx2r" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Happy Thursday. We just are hours away from <strong>Kamala Harris</strong> wrapping up the Democratic National Convention with the biggest speech of her life. Here’s what is on our podium today:</p><ul><li>Vital signs: The ticking health care time bomb</li><li>Bye-bye, asylum-seekers</li><li>Rail shutdown threatens supply lines</li><li>DNC vibes &amp; partisan fervor</li><li><strong>Plus</strong><strong>:</strong> Brace yourself for record-breaking hurricane season</li></ul><p>But first, it’s Harris’ moment to lead the Democratic Party, and what she does tonight will shape the campaign over the next 75 days. What are her goals? How will this set up the rest of the campaign? And is the most surprising political battle of this cycle about which party really owns the word “freedom”?</p><p>Harris has three jobs as she takes over the ticket:</p><h3>1. Unite the party: Check</h3><p>Any thought there was lingering bitterness after <strong>Joe Biden</strong> was, um, <strong>Nancy Pelosi</strong>’ed to step down, has been banished. Harris has raised over $300 million and is currently fracking Bakken Formation–levels of enthusiasm from what many thought were dry Democratic wells.</p><p>Democrats will emerge from the convention — as Republicans did from the RNC — with big momentum, flush with money and a sense of hope and possibility that was nowhere to be seen when Biden was starring in the political version of “Thelma and Louise,” driving the party off an electoral cliff.</p><p>Hope matters in politics because it fuels volunteers to drive the get-out-the-vote machine, boosts fundraising, and resonates with key voting blocks like suburban women, Black and Latino voters, and young people, the core of the blue machine.</p><p>Harris’ biggest challenge remains connecting with white, working, and middle-class male voters in the seven swing states. The gender gap is a significant element of the campaign, and Democrats have been losing these voters by the bale load. Enter vice presidential candidate <strong>Tim Walz</strong>, whose folksy pep rally speech last night ditched virtually any mention of his years in Congress in favor of focusing on his military service, his hunting, and his football coaching career. Walz doesn’t bring a swing state like Pennsylvania with him, but he does bring the regular dad-in-flannel authenticity factor meant to move middle-class and working-class men back to the Democratic Party.</p><h3>2. Define herself before the opposition can define her: Check</h3><p>Elections are about framing three kinds of narrative. First, frame the narrative about your own candidate, then frame one around your opponent to create contrast, and, finally, frame the ballot box question urging a call to action.</p><p>The Obama folks used to call this <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.hks.harvard.edu/educational-programs/executive-education/public-narrative-leadership-storytelling-and-action"><u>Public Narrative theory</u></a>, based on the work of a guy called <strong>Marshall Ganz</strong>. The idea is to first tell the “story of self” — why you are here and what your purpose or mission is all about. Then tell the “story of us,” which is why we all have a common cause in the mission, and end the campaign with a call to action, the fierce urgency of the moment, which Ganz calls the “the story of now.”</p><p>You can track the four days of the DNC by how they hit these three key objectives, showing that the Ganz book is still very much the DNA of the party with Harris at the top.</p><p>Harris is essentially new as a presidential candidate, which means she is balancing both the celebration of Biden’s record and taking credit for its successes while distancing herself from it enough to introduce herself as an agent of change.</p><p>This is why she starts with the story of self. Ironically, Harris is helped by the fact that she was a somewhat invisible vice president, even if she was very present on the abortion issue. Her lack of public persona began as a shield issue (Who is she? What did she accomplish in three and half years?), but now it’s very much a sword. Harris is a blank slate, so her team has been able to define her with the story of a joyful warrior, a protector, a prosecutor, and someone who fights for the middle class. Tonight, she will try to set that frame in stone — and then put one around the Trump campaign, as her running mate, Tim Walz, started to do last night. Trump as “weird,” Trump as “felon,” and Trump as only about Trump.</p><p>The framing issue is bedeviling Trump, who until now has been a master at it. “Crooked Hillary.” “Sleepy Joe.” Those adolescent nicknames have worked because they have a ring of truth for his audience. Biden really is, well, kinda sleepy. On Wednesday, Trump admitted he’s having a really hard time trying to frame Harris. “I think her name will be Comrade,” he said, going off script. “Because that is the most accurate,” he continued, thinking out loud. “You know, I’ve been looking for a name, and people have been saying, ‘Sir, don’t do it' — you know, all my names, they have all worked, they have all been very successful — and I really didn’t find one with her!”</p><p>So far, “Comrade Kamala” is not sticking, though the strategy of calling her and <strong>Tim Walz</strong> radical communists is the playbook. But until Trump can figure something out, Harris has time to set her own frame.</p><p>Why hasn’t it worked for Trump?<strong>&nbsp;</strong>The "Commie" stuff is a stretch because it’s not the 1950s anymore. The Red Scare is generationally out of touch — and, besides, it’s Trump who has closer ties to Putin than the Democrats. Harris also has put out so little policy to date — a weakness in many ways but an asset in this instance — that there is no hook on which to hang the name. Meanwhile, the Harris team has adopted a kind of “haters-gonna-hate, shake-it-off” vibe, and instead of ignoring Trump (they’ve hopped off the “they go low, we go high” bandwagon), they have countered with a name of their own: “Weird.”</p><p>Trump has managed to avoid being defined by opponents because he’s always the one on offense, but the Harris folks have sidestepped him, effectively using the extreme parts of the Trump movement and his own bizarre conspiracy theories to push him out of the mainstream and marginalize him. Right now, she is winning the framing battle.</p><h3>3. Set the ballot box question: The toughest task ahead for both Harris and Trump</h3><p>This is the story of <em>now</em>, and what this campaign is all about. Trump is counting on the salience of issues like immigration, the economy, security, and the culture wars against “woke-ism” to define his campaign. He is back to his American carnage, “Après moi, le déluge” phase. It’s ominous stuff, but it works for him, and he is still very much in play in this election. But Trump’s support is not growing. Harris is pushing issues like abortion, anti-corporate greed, and anti-Trump to define her campaign. She <em>wants</em> the election to be about Trump because Dems believe he is an increasingly volatile liability, especially as he deepens his dive into <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/"><u>conspiracy theories</u></a>, comments about her racial identity, and simply lies about what he says are her AI-generated crowds.</p><p>There is one more fascinating framing battle going on: the battle over the word "freedom." Freedom has classically been the rallying cry of the right — freedom from big government, freedom to bear arms, freedom of the individual against the tyranny of Big Pharma, Big Tech, the Deep State, etc. It is the cornerstone of the victimization narrative and what is supposed to underpin the “fight, fight, fight” rallying cry.</p><p>“The right has traditionally owned patriotism and freedom in both its narrative and in how people view parties on the right or center-right,” pollster and CEO of Abacus Data <strong>David Coletto</strong> told me. “But I think freedom likely means different things to different people, which is why I think it’s smart for the left to try to gain some share back on it. This is especially true in the US, where abortion rights and freedom to make decisions about one’s life are salient.”</p><p>That’s why the Democrats have openly tried to yank back the word and flip the script. As you heard Walz last night repeat his Minnesota slogan, “Mind your own damn business,” the Dems argue that it’s Republicans who are infringing on freedoms for women and the LGBTQ community and infringing on the right to health care. On a more meta level, they are arguing that Dems will protect the institutions that are there to protect freedom — like safeguarding the US Capitol from an insurrection.</p><p>While Biden focused his campaign on the word “democracy,” under Harris, everyone from Walz and Oprah to Obama to Shapiro to Buttigieg has made sure the word “freedom” has been front and center. A recent<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/08/20/kamala-harris-freedom-democracy-biden/"> <u>Washington Post article</u></a> pointed out that “at 100 campaign events since launching his reelection in April 2023, Biden referenced “democracy” 386 times and “freedom” about 175 times. By comparison, in nine campaign rallies since Biden dropped out, Harris referenced “freedom” nearly 60 times and “democracy” around a dozen.</p><p>“The fight over the word matters,” says Coletto. “As the world has become more insecure, and as people witness the return of authoritarianism, we are less likely to take freedom for granted. I think the concept is on the ascendency again as people contrast their own lives and how they want to live with how they see others living in less free countries.”</p><p>At this moment, who protects freedom and who curtails it is not the ballot question — likely the economy will still be the decider for independents — but the freedom debate is the proxy war here.</p><p>As she speaks tonight, expect Kamala Harris to try to hang the “freedom” frame around the campaign.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Elon Musk and the Political Power of Young Men</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/elon-musk-and-the-political-power-of-young-men</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrftuftk19y07mynz6tmlo5</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 15 Aug 2024 20:01:27 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>elon musk</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>There is no shortage of polls showing that the race between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump is tighter than a pair of skinny jeans on Will Ferrell.Numbers in key swing states like Arizona and Pennsylvania have gone from a Trump lock to a toss-up or even a small Harris lead.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcs9mid0qa07lq92fxopya" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="4742" height="3161">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Gonzalo Fuentes/File Photo/File Photo</media:credit>
<media:text>Elon Musk, Chief Executive Officer of SpaceX and Tesla and owner of X,.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcs9mid0qa07lq92fxopya" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There is no shortage of polls showing that the race between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump is<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nv7Ts4v5_Bs"> <u>tighter than a pair of skinny jeans on Will Ferrell</u></a>.</p><p>Numbers in key swing states like Arizona and Pennsylvania have gone from a Trump lock to a toss-up or even a small Harris lead. But as the saying goes, you don’t win elections in August. Both campaigns still need to swing large constituencies of voters, and one group is emerging as critical: young men.</p><p>In this election, there are roughly 41 million Gen Z voters — people between the ages of 18 and 29, and while Dems have traditionally counted on their support, the war in Gaza and the slow growth economy have turned many of them away.</p><p>In particular, young men struggling with job prospects and rapidly changing notions of masculinity are seeking a new ideological home that gives them a sense of meaning, support, and respect.</p><p>Enter Elon Musk. The tech billionaire recently endorsed Trump, but it was their two-hour-long conversation on X this week that formally ended their 2022 feud, during which <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1546669610509799424?ref_src=twsrc^tfw|twcamp^tweetembed|twterm^1546669610509799424|twgr^743a2da9ea26c805e4ed45723f6253f8949f939f|twcon^s1_&amp;ref_url=https://www.thedailybeast.com/"><u>Trump called Musk a “bullshit artist” and Musk</u>&nbsp;</a>said it was “time for Trump to hang up his hat &amp; sail into the sunset.”</p><p>Musk has now pulled a JD Vance-level pivot to Trump. He’s even offered to work with the former president on a “government efficiency committee” to make sure federal money is “spent in a good way.” Trump said yes, he was very open to hiring “<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://ca.news.yahoo.com/elon-musks-chainsaw-strategy-does-165700382.html?guccounter=1&amp;guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&amp;guce_referrer_sig=AQAAACXAJJtbkG-yriCR5TE2C_lwlN1_CDo0JBZo_id4y4q2zlXz0JjxRJ_ROj86nyO51rWqyFXtAbE8J-HsGPLJ8gPzqIYm-8QXOjGWQb4Iss6dDqDm_1ufUZxmn_RqlCD6SdRi8QYCFK0jtk3W2pYjx6LdT0AdzjPiHFVTdYz2ct_S"><u>Chainsaw</u></a>” Elon to do some government clear-cutting.</p><p>So, how consequential is Elon’s endorsement of Trump? Very. Musk is a modern-day mashup of Thomas Edison and William Randolph Hearst — at once a transformational figure in business and technology but also, now that he owns X, an immensely powerful media influencer.</p><p>His publicly acknowledged journey from moderate Democrat to MAGA Republican has major appeal to certain voter segments — especially those with a Y chromosome who believe Call of Duty is not just a video game but a possible career.</p><p>To study those people, a group called the<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://substack.com/@youngmenresearchinitiative"> <u>Young Men’s Research Initiative</u></a> just ran a YouGov poll of key influencers on American young men between the ages of 18 and 29. They found Musk and X at the top of the list, with the next in line not even close.</p><p>“68% of young men in our survey said they ‘like’ Musk, among the highest influencers tested,” the YMRI team wrote on their Substack.</p><p>Why? First off, because of his career. “The survey found that ‘entrepreneur’ was the most admired career among young men, particularly for young Black men.”</p><p>But does Musk’s popularity among young men really give him the power to turn the election?</p><p>“Trump’s base is MAGA, but that’s not enough for him to win, so he is appealing to groups that have often been overlooked, particularly young men,” Shauna Daly, a Democrat who helped found YMRI, told me.</p><p>“Historically, they haven’t turned out in large numbers, but this year they are frustrated, and somewhat organized, thanks to right-leaning influencers and media who are urging them to get out and vote for Trump. Democrats ignore the potential of young men to make a difference in the election at our peril.”</p><p>This is why Trump undermined his own social media company, Truth Social, and went back to X. Because X marks the spot where these young male voters live.</p><p>YMRI found that a massive 52% of respondents said they used X in the last week—up from a Change Research poll last year that put the number at just 33%. Even more critically: 64% of young Black men say they’ve used X in the last week.</p><p>Who else do these young male voters look up to? Far-right, male-chauvinist influencers like Andrew Tate in the UK — where Musk has played a massive role in the unrest surrounding immigration — are highly influential. Fully 27% of respondents say they like and trust Tate’s views, which is surprising since Tate is essentially a UK figure. Podcaster Joe Rogan was also tested, and 36% of young men say they like and trust his views, while 34% say the same about author and polemicist Dr. Jordan Peterson.</p><p>“Young men’s movement to the right is being fueled by their consumption of right-leaning media and influencers, with little competition from comparable [male] figures on the left,” said Daly. “The trust young American men have in Elon Musk, Andrew Tate, and others impacts not only their vote choice but also their offline actions, as we have seen in the UK this month, and their views of women.”</p><p>The views on women are fascinating, and they give some insight into why Trump’s Veep pick JD Vance’s radioactive statements about “childless cat ladies” or Trump’s infidelities don’t seem to have any negative impact on the young Republican base. “38% of the cohort say they have never been in a serious relationship,” according to the YMRI/YouGov poll.</p><p>About half of respondents agreed with the following statements: “A serious relationship is too big an emotional commitment” and “When it comes to relationships, there are too many social norms and rules for what is expected of someone like me.”</p><p><em>Too many social norms and rules</em> is the key phrase. Trump’s campaign is fueled by a culture war on social norms which posits that everything from a “woke culture” to the “deep state,” from the courts to the education system, are out to curtail or crush the freedoms of young men.</p><p>For this group, then, the election is about something bigger: the very definition of masculinity.</p><p>The poll found that most men see key masculine qualities as “protecting your family,” “honesty,” “confidence,” and “helping people who need it,”which is confusing since the same young men don’t seem to want to be in a long-term relationship. How can you protect a family if you don’t have one?</p><p>But the bigger point is that for these young men, to be a “man” means playing by your own rules — as a maverick business entrepreneur stereotypically does — and projecting “strength.”</p><p>This finding illuminates why the Democrats, who have focused much of their efforts on suburban women and who rely on the salience of the abortion issue to rally support, are now scrambling to shore up their traditional “male” bona fides with Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz.</p><p>Selecting a military veteran, football coach, and hunter who sports Carhartt jackets and a camo hat — while defending trans rights and school breakfast for kids — is the Dems’ way of trying to redefine what masculinity means in a progressive context.</p><p>They know they need to offer young men a place in their party, and they have done a poor job of doing so up to this point. Which is why the Vance-Walz fight over their military service is playing out so openly: Each views it as the strongest card in their masculinity deck.</p><p>“Republicans believe they own masculinity and are campaigning on a belligerent and domineering version of it,” Daly told me. “But Democrats are embracing a different version, one that is centered on protecting those who need it and fighting back against the bullies trying to diminish the rest of us.”</p><p>As Kamala Harris heads to the Democratic National Convention next week, aiming to keep her enthusiasm train rolling and make history as the first female president in US history, the Musk-Trump interview has pushed a counter-narrative to the forefront of the election: What does it really mean to be a man in 2024?</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>President Panic and the Grievance Ceiling</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/president-panic-and-the-grievance-ceiling</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrftj32krpp07lq0s2sj8rp</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 08 Aug 2024 18:20:19 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>politics</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>presidential election</category>
<category>jd vance</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>tim walz</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>polling</category>
<category>kamala harris</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>The confidence the world saw at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee after Donald Trump survived a terrifying assassination attempt is suddenly gone. The rallying cry of “Fight, fight, fight!” has been replaced with “whine, whine, whine,” a transformation encapsulated in feverish social media posts Trump is sending from his baroque bunker in Mar-a-Lago.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcrqrdd00n07lqg5bh925k" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1191" height="675">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Umit Bektas</media:credit>
<media:text>Republican presidential nominee and former President Donald Trump gestures as he speaks during a campaign rally in Atlanta, Georgia, on Aug. 3, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcrqrdd00n07lqg5bh925k" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Has <strong>Donald Trump</strong> become President Panic and hit a grievance ceiling?</p><p>The confidence the world saw at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee after Trump survived a terrifying assassination attempt is suddenly gone. The rallying cry of “Fight, fight, fight!” has been replaced with “whine, whine, whine,” a transformation encapsulated in feverish social media posts Trump is sending from his baroque bunker in Mar-a-Lago.</p><p>Clearly caught off guard by Biden’s exit, the former president is struggling to find a way to frame <strong>Kamala Harris’</strong> sudden surge in momentum. After Harris picked Minnesota Gov. <strong>Tim Walz</strong> as her running mate and held a series of massive rallies, Trump released what ranked as one of his <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/112916846922600265"><u>most bizarre social media posts</u></a>. (OK, it’s not on the RFK Jr. <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://x.com/RobertKennedyJr/status/1820132549798347109"><u>level</u></a> of “After falconing with my pals, I picked a dead bear cub off the highway to skin it and eat it but instead decided to secretly dump it in Central Park and stage a fake crime scene by pretending the bear was killed by a cyclist,” but then, what is? Hold RFK’s animal cruelty beer, Gov. Kristi Noem!)</p><p>In any case, Trump just posted a panicky theory that Biden is going to fight Harris to reclaim the nomination. “What are the chances that Crooked Joe Biden, the WORST President in the history of the U.S., whose Presidency was Unconstitutionally STOLEN from him by Kamabla, Barrack HUSSEIN Obama, Crazy Nancy Pelosi, Shifty Adam Schiff, Cryin’ Chuck Schumer, and others on the Lunatic Left, CRASHES the Democrat National Convention and tries to take back the Nomination, beginning with challenging me to another DEBATE,” he wrote. “He feels that he made a historically tragic mistake by handing over the U.S. Presidency, a COUP, to the people in the World he most hates, and he wants it back, NOW!!!”</p><p>Hard to decode any of this, but let’s try. Does Trump know anything about the inner workings of the Biden circle? No. Was Biden’s presidency “unconstitutionally stolen”? No. Biden is still president, and he decided — under great pressure to be sure — not to run again. Both Johnson and Truman did the same thing, so it can happen. It was not a “COUP,” as Trump later called it, though the irony was not lost on anyone that Trump is the one accused of trying to unconstitutionally steal an election and stage a coup on Jan. 6, 2021.</p><p>The post also descends into his usual litany of name-calling, from “crooked” for Biden and “shifty” for Schiff to “crazy” for Nancy Pelosi. He notably changed “Kamala” to “Kamabla” — and has done so a few times — which no one understands.</p><p>There does not seem to be a coherent Trump strategy yet to combat Harris or Walz, except for trying to find the juvenile name that sticks, à la Sleepy Joe. “Laughing Kamala” — is that a thing? Nope. Is laughter now a liability in America? No. Crazy Kamala? It’s a classic one — but doesn’t it already belong to Pelosi?</p><p>When the name-calling fails, there is always the fallback on race, a strategy Trump used against <strong>Barack Obama</strong> with the birther theory. At the National Association of Black Journalists convention last week, Trump alleged that Harris had recently “turned Black,” dismissing her biracial identity. This made no sense, especially since his running mate, <strong>JD Vance</strong>, has biracial children. But Trump has doubled down on it anyway, bundling it with calling Harris a “DEI hire,” even though her record in politics is much longer than either his own or Vance’s.</p><p>This week, Republican pollster <strong>Frank Luntz</strong> said that Harris is now the front-runner and blamed the turn of fortunes on Trump’s empty personal attacks. “He’s losing it with speeches that have the same sort of ad hominem attacks to a public that has had enough and wants to look for something different, something new,” <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://vinnews.com/2024/08/06/frank-luntz-kamala-harris-now-the-front-runner-in-tight-election-race/"><u>he told Vinnews</u></a>.</p><p>In any election, a candidate has a floor of support — the base that will never leave them which, in Trump’s case, is the MAGA crowd that makes up about 43%-48% of the voting population — and a ceiling, the place they need to grow to win over swing states like Michigan, Arizona, Pennsylvania, or Nevada. A new <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.newsweek.com/kamala-harris-eight-point-lead-donald-trump-new-poll-presidential-election-1936246"><u>survey</u></a> conducted by Marquette Law School shows Harris leading Trump among likely voters by 50% to 42%, when third-party candidates are included, and by 47% to 41% with registered voters.</p><p>The goal is to recruit new voters, independents, suburban women, unions, the Black, Latino, Jewish, or Arab-American voters. It appears as if there may be a kind of “grievance ceiling” or an “anger ceiling” in US politics, and Trump might have just hit it.</p><p>Trump’s strategy of unhinged personal insults, race-baiting, grievance-fueled conspiracy theories, and self-pity might have made his floor the same as his ceiling, which is fatal for a campaign. How does he put new things on the menu to attract new customers if he keeps cooking with the same old sauce?</p><p>One of the things Harris and Walz have done remarkably well is find a tone that makes the Trump personal attacks seem old, out of touch, and ineffective. Walz in particular has owned the happy warrior role, dismissing the entire Trump campaign as “weird,” a deft response that allows Democrats to take Trump seriously without admitting that he’s actually serious about anything.</p><p>They smile, they laugh, and they appear unaffected by the personal attacks. But they are hitting back too, rejecting <strong>Michelle Obama</strong>'s maxim: “When they go low, we go high.” Walz and surrogates like Pennsylvania Gov. <strong>Josh Shapiro</strong> love fighting on the low ground and have taken to spicing up their speeches with the truffle sauce of four-letter profanity that lends the out-of-touch elitist Democrat image a folksy touch. “Hey, we can swear too,” they seem to say. Shapiro’s maxim of GSD or “Get Shit Done” is now a crowd chant. Democrats are fighting MAGA mud with their own mud, and they are enjoying it, which used to be Trump’s secret weapon.</p><p>Luntz’s point is that Trump needs to stop panicking and start talking about substance, policy, and record. Harris and Walz are vulnerable on lots of issues: the faltering economy, the porous border, and the bloody Middle East. But Trump can’t seem to focus on substantial issues long enough to make this stuff stick. That explains why he has become President Panic.</p><p>There are still over 90 days left in this volatile, wild campaign, so if there is one lesson, it’s that the past is not prologue. The election is still very much up for grabs. Harris and Walz have started strong, but it ain’t about the start. It’s about the finish. In politics, as in baseball, being the closer is a hard job that few can pull off. Is Harris a closer? Will she wilt under the barrage of Trump attacks — he will find a more coherent strategy — as so many others have? Will divisions inside her party over say the policy on Israel, Hamas, and Gaza undermine the Democrats’ momentum in key states like Michigan? And what about the economy and the stock market meltdown? That is the hard test ahead.</p><p>Harris and Walz are still popping corks at their sudden change of fortune, but elections can make a candidate’s bubbly go flat before the second sip. For now, however, they are watching President Panic hit the grievance ceiling, and they are drinking it up.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Civil Wars and Civil Exits</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/civil-wars-and-civil-exits</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfss1zjxzh07myc9e8wgh5</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 25 Jul 2024 17:11:01 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>civil war</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>2024 presidential election</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>us politics</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>For a moment last night, America lived up to its best ideals. GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon looks at President Joe Biden’s address to the nation about his reluctant decision to step away from the 2024 campaign — and how it showed genuine character. But Solomon also highlights the dangerous rhetoric on the campaign trail that is leading many, according to a new exclusive Abacus Data-GZERO poll, to fear that a second civil war looms in the US.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcqh7hc9ys07myux4yw6zf" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1197" height="676">
<media:credit>Evan Vucci/Pool via REUTERS</media:credit>
<media:text>President Joe Biden addresses the nation about his decision to step back from the 2024 presidential race on July 24, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcqh7hc9ys07myux4yw6zf" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For a moment last night, America lived up to its best ideals. It often does in the dark hours.<br></p><p>President <strong>Joe Biden&nbsp;</strong>addressed the nation from the Oval Office to explain his reluctant decision to step away from the 2024 campaign — a campaign he was forced to accept, in a humiliating but necessary way, that he could not win — in a rare moment of sacrifice over ego, service over ambition.</p><p>Though age has severely diminished Biden’s capacities, it has not diminished his dignity or character.</p><p>Character is not something we talk about a lot in politics these days. But as Biden raspily and haltingly defended his presidential record, his vision for the future, and his 50 years of service, he showed genuine character.</p><p>Character is more than just toughness, grit, and fortitude amid a fight, though surely it can encompass those qualities. Character is more than just grace in loss, and Biden knows more about that than most, having lost his wife Neilia and his 1-year-old daughter Naomi to a car accident in 1972, and then his son Beau to brain cancer in 2015. Character is what happens after those moments. It’s what you do with the time left, how you reassemble the pieces and build something with purpose. It’s reflected in the ideas you hold and the people you serve, even if those ideas fail and people turn on you. Character is the story your life tells when you might no longer have the strength to tell it yourself.</p><p>“Nearly all men can withstand adversity,” President <strong>Abraham Lincoln</strong> once said, “but if you want to test a man’s character, give him power.” You don’t have to agree with what Biden fought for, you don’t have to like his record, and you don’t have to support his party, but last night, President Joseph R. Biden, who still has more power than anyone on earth, passed the character test. And he asked a riven country to try to do the same.</p><p>Now let’s turn to the campaign, which, as ever, is a testing ground of character.<strong></strong></p><p>Campaign rallies are not known for their subtle rhetoric, so when a local politician is trying to juggle the twin duties of whipping up a partisan crowd while simultaneously kissing their candidate’s butt, it’s usually not surprising they get a little sloppy.</p><p>But it’s worth paying attention to what Ohio Sen. <strong>George Lang</strong> said to a crowd as he introduced former President <strong>Donald Trump</strong> and <strong>JD Vance</strong> the other day. Arriving at the podium chanting Trump’s now-famous epizeuxis “fight, fight, fight,” Lang <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9TUbvoL-dfU"><u>warned of an upcoming civil war</u></a> if Democrats win the election. “I believe wholeheartedly Donald Trump and Butler County’s JD Vance are the last chance to save our country politically,” Lang said, sweating with enthusiasm in the summer sun. “I’m afraid if we lose this one, it’s going to take a civil war to save the country.” And then, he added a little boost for those prepping for battle. “If we come down to a civil war, I’m glad we got people like Bikers for Trump on our side.”</p><p>No one followed Lang on stage and pushed back or suggested it was horrendously dangerous rhetoric. It wasn’t until much later when the recklessness of the comments began to circulate more widely that Lang was forced to apologize.</p><p>“Remarks I made earlier today at a rally in Middletown do not accurately reflect my view,” Lang said, as if somehow his mouth had gone rogue from his brain. “I regret the divisive remarks I made in the excitement of the moment on stage. Especially in light of the assassination attempt on President Trump last week, we should all be mindful of what is said at political events, myself included."</p><p>Amen to that.</p><p>Still, fears of a second civil war permeate the campaign, and while I don’t normally hyperventilate over these hypothetical, partisan-stoked fears because the institutions in the US have mostly proven to be resilient, the horrific assassination attempt on Trump and the events of Jan. 6, 2021, have made the descent in political violence a genuine scenario that demands attention. Stable democracies, like bankruptcy, end in two ways: gradually, and then suddenly.</p><p>People in the US are getting used to this sort of rhetoric by now — though normalizing it is one of the most dangerous signs of decline — but people outside the US, especially in the country’s closest allies, are deeply apprehensive. Is the US really inching toward a civil war?</p><p>To find out, we partnered on a poll with <strong>David Coletto</strong>, CEO and chair of Abacus Data, and the results are unsettling. Thirty-nine percent of Canadians say it is likely that the United States will descend into civil war, while another 23% believe it is somewhat likely. 39%? Yes. The numbers are starker among young people, with 48% of people between the ages of 18 and 29 saying a civil war is likely.</p><p>“Canadians are watching the increasing polarization and political violence in the US, and many of them are not shutting the door to that division escalating into full-scale civil war,” Coletto says. “Younger Canadians, in particular, are inclined to think that the very worst outcome is at least a possibility.”</p><p>While the polling figures are accurate, let’s hope the sentiments are wrong.</p><p>Abacus also asked about mandatory retirement ages for politicians in the wake of Biden’s agonizing decision to step aside and, again, most Canadians heartily agree that he is too old to lead. Seventy-three percent believe there should be a maximum age for a president or prime minister. What age? 28% say 71-plus while 48% say somewhere between 61 and 70, which is surprising.</p><p>“The whole Joe Biden saga put into clear perspective the effect aging can have on leaders charged with the most important executive functions in the world,” Coletto says. “Most Canadians think political leaders have a best-before date, and the average age of a president or prime minister is around the usual age of retirement, which is 65.”</p><p>You can see the full poll results and Coletto’s comments about it <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://abacusdata.ca/gzero-age-leadership-civil-war-usa/"><u>here</u></a>. GZERO will continue to work with Abacus Data, a well-respected Canadian polling firm, to explore how Canadians and Americans feel about their relationship, the US election, and more in the coming 100 days. Check out their work <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="http://abacusdata.ca/"><u>here</u></a>.<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="http://abacusdata.ca/"> <u><br></u><u><br></u><u><br></u></a></p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Political Mo: The price of a winning streak?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/political-mo-the-price-of-a-winning-streak</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfsezrko5s07lqucnnklx4</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 18 Jul 2024 18:53:58 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>presidential election</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>assassination</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Does the thrill of political momentum threaten to undermine the most important part of any campaign: the policies?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcptkzcxbk07lqi6766bk7" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1186" height="671">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Andrew Kelly</media:credit>
<media:text>Republican presidential nominee and former President Donald Trump raises his fist during Day 1 of the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, on July 15, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcptkzcxbk07lqi6766bk7" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Does the thrill of political momentum threaten to undermine the most important part of any campaign: the policies?<br></p><p>By any measure — polls, donor dollars, media attention — all the political momentum, or “mo,” in campaign 2024 has swung to <strong>Donald Trump</strong>. It started after <strong>Joe Biden</strong>’s disastrous debate performance — it was like a coming-out party for the erosions of old age — but hit speed records in the wake of the tragic assassination attempt. The former president’s now-iconic moment of badassery, when, blood trickling down his face, he pumped his fist and yelled, “Fight, fight, fight,” has animated Republicans. He says he even changed his convention speech to reflect the reality of political violence and polarization — and that will be one of the big things to watch for tonight. Many, like Sen. <strong>Marco Rubio</strong>, argued that Trump’s survival was proof of divine intervention (Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene called it a “miracle” and claimed the flag above<a target="_blank" href="https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/07/17/watch-exclusive-marjorie-taylor-greene-we-witnessed-miracle-saturday/"> <u>Donald Trump took the form of an angel</u></a> right before the gunshot), infusing the campaign with a Christian nationalism and eschatology.</p><p>Tech oligarch <strong>Elon Musk</strong> just announced that he is donating $45 million a month to Trump, joining his billionaire tech bro <strong>Peter Thiel</strong> on the MAGA train that is surprisingly making lucrative stops in Silicon Valley, once a bastion of Democratic support. Adding to the Trump “mo” is the ascension of 39-year-old Marine veteran, financier, lawyer, and “Hillbilly Elegy” author JD Vance as the VP nominee. Vance’s biographically marbled speech at the RNC on Wednesday night highlighted his background in an Ohio devastated by globalization and the opioid crisis. It featured his mother, who has struggled with addiction, a personal story that tenderized the red meat served up earlier by <strong>Donald Trump Jr.</strong> and <strong>Peter Navarro</strong>. Navarro had just been released from a four-month sentence for defying a subpoena from the Jan. 6 congressional committee — and was cheered as a hero, which was as telling about the new RNC anti-institution, radical culture as anything that has happened so far.</p><p>Vance directly appealed to working-class voters in key swing states like Michigan and Pennsylvania. At times, it sounded like an old-school pro-union, pro-tariff Democrat speech from the 1990s, and it was a starkly different pitch than the massive corporate tax cuts Trump pitches, but it’s now on-brand for the neo-Republican coalition of angry working-class males and right-wing, anti-regulatory tech, energy, and mining elites.</p><p>MAGA now has an heir but more importantly a license to think generationally as opposed to just four-year election cycles. This is no longer about just an impulsive “dictator-for-a-day” vengeance win over the Biden administration and the “wokeys.” It’s about a fundamental hard-right-wing rewiring of American politics and international relations. The battle plan is the Heritage Foundation’s <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/will-project-2025-become-trumps-2-0-playbook"><u>Platform 2025</u></a>, and the foot soldiers are the once-fringe MAGA-ites like Marjorie Taylor Greene, Donald Trump Jr., and <strong>Matt Gaetz</strong>, who will play significant roles in a Trump administration.</p><p>This is what the Trump “mo” looks like numerically: A new YouGov <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://news.az/news/trump-leading-biden-in-all-major-swing-states-poll-shows"><u>poll</u></a> has Trump ahead in key swing states like Arizona (+7 points), Georgia, (+4), Michigan (+2), North Carolina (+4), Wisconsin (+5), and Pennsylvania (+3). In other words, Trump and his MAGA-ites are out-polling, out-rolling, and out-trolling Democrats on all levels.</p><p>Meanwhile, it’s chaos in Bidenlandia, where the president is collecting bad news like a wool sock gathers burrs in the forest. On Wednesday, he revealed he has COVID as he was desperately trying to reset his campaign and get over his stilted, confused, mistake-riddled performances. He’s now picking up viruses faster than endorsements, and the odds that he will not make it to the convention as the nominee are rising.</p><p>A <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://apnews.com/article/biden-trump-poll-drop-out-debate-democrats-59eebaca6989985c2bfbf4f72bdfa112"><u>new poll</u></a> from the AP-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research revealed that most Democrats want Biden to step down, a sentiment buttressed by a stunning call from high-ranking Democrat Rep. <strong>Adam Schiff</strong>, who is running for the Senate in California. “I believe it is time for him to pass the torch,” Schiff said. Late Wednesday, New York Sen. Chuck Schumer reportedly joined the calls for Biden to leave, but he did so privately. Et tu, Chuck?</p><p>The thing about political momentum is that it’s often generated by factors that have nothing to do with the core reason elections exist: policy. Who has the best ideas to govern the country? That is the core question, not who looks best in an ad. This is an election to run a country, not an audition for a modeling agency, but it’s hard to tell the difference anymore. How much does an assassination attempt or a bad debate performance have to do with who is best to deal with a rogue Russia, an aggressive China, or a war in the Middle East? Who can tackle inflation, productivity issues, and climate change? Who will handle AI regulation or protect the rights of minorities? Who will handle the border crisis? Who will actually create jobs? Do tariffs help the economy, or drive up costs? Who will stand for a peaceful transition of power or an independent judiciary? Who should pick the seats on the Supreme Court?</p><p>On all these matters, there are real, consequential policy debates – on some, Republicans are stronger, and on others, Democrats are stronger. This is the battlefield on which Biden would like to fight because he believes Trump — with his 34 felonies and his readiness to throw Ukraine to Russia, Taiwan to China, and most judicial and governing checks and balances out the window — is vulnerable. But he can’t. The political momentum is against Biden, and when that happens, you lose the most important aspect of campaigning: setting the agenda.</p><p>Biden is totally reactive now, and even as he pitches policies to get on his front foot — on Wednesday he was courting Latinos with the promise that undocumented spouses of US citizens could avoid getting deported — they evaporate like a puddle in Death Valley. When he gets to a stage to talk about policy, he can barely articulate the words without stumbling, faltering, and losing his train of thought. For post-debate Biden, the mistakes are the message. That’s what happens when you lose the political mo.</p><p>Things can change, of course. Events happen, like the horrible shooting or the debate, and suddenly the big mo shifts, but it’s getting late and harder to see that happening. For now, the biggest story of the campaign is not policy, it’s momentum, and while that makes for dramatic storylines, it tells voters less about potential Gulf wars and more about fabricated golf scores. Political mo matters and is essential to winning, but it can be used to introduce policy ideas <em>or to avoid them</em> and focus only on attacks and slogans.</p><p>There is another consequence: Political mo speeds everything up and floods the zone with stories about snap polls and hot takes on winners and losers. But the whole point of campaigns is to debate the opposition, to pause from the pace of governing, and slow things down for a considered reset. Campaigns are meant for people to ask questions. Check facts. Read the details. Holds folks accountable. And make a considered decision.</p><p>That’s not political mo — it’s policy mo. Political mo and policy mo should be intimately linked, but with the dramatic events these past months — felony convictions, age-related floundering, shootings — the coverage is over-indexing on the politics and under-indexing on policy. When each candidate has such a radically different view of America, a little policy mo is badly needed. Sadly, it’s turning out that examining ideas closely and factually is a political loser.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Stepping up and stepping down: Biden and Trudeau’s two-step problems</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/stepping-up-and-stepping-down-biden-and-trudeaus-two-step-problems</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfs15vjvbh07myb9wv4vrx</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 11 Jul 2024 17:41:28 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>For Biden in 2024, stepping down would be his way of stepping up.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcp550cw7s07lqz574czvd" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein</media:credit>
<media:text>US President Joe Biden greets Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as they attend NATO&apos;s 75th anniversary summit in Washington, July 10, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcp550cw7s07lqz574czvd" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For President <strong>Joe Biden</strong> right now, his biggest challenge is stepping down.</p><p>Feverishly trying to quell the internal Democrat rebellion — which actor/democratic fundraiser <strong>George Clooney</strong> publicly joined yesterday — Biden is doing interviews and working backrooms to try to hold on to power. It’s not working. Despite many allies coming forward to defend him against the so-called nervous nellies, Biden cannot contain the daily calls to step down that are coming from inside the Democratic house. Instead of fighting <strong>Donald Trump</strong> on one front, as he should be right now, Biden is fighting a two-front war, one internally and one externally, and it looks increasingly like he will lose both. The center cannot hold.</p><p>Stepping up is often seen as an act of leadership and courage, leaning into a fight against all odds. Stepping down is viewed as weak, a retreat from the arena. So it’s natural that Biden insists on stepping up and continuing to fight. That’s a given for any political leader.</p><p>But after the disastrous debate revealed how diminished Biden has become, 10 House Democrats, one senator, and countless high-profile Democratic operators like <strong>James Carville</strong> are openly trying to rebrand Biden stepping down as an act of leadership, not surrender. They argue Biden has served well and his record is strong, but that the best way to protect his legacy is to step away and let someone else defend it. They are right.</p><p>Democrats are haunted by the ghost of <strong>Ruth Bader Ginsburg</strong>. Despite deep concerns about her age and her health, the legendary Supreme Court justice refused to step down to let President <strong>Barack Obama</strong> and the Democrat-controlled Senate appoint a new justice. Instead, she kept stepping up, clinging to her post for so long that when she finally passed away at 87, <strong>Donald Trump</strong> got to replace her. In the blink of an eye, RBG’s legacy was in tatters and Roe v. Wade was overturned. It was a generational error for Democrats, and many see it being repeated with Biden.</p><p>In 2008, when <strong>Hillary Clinton</strong> was running against Obama, she released the famous <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7yr7odFUARg"><u>“3 a.m. phone call”</u></a> ad. “It’s 3 a.m., your children are safe and asleep, who do you want answering the phone?,” the baritone phone asked, before cutting to a picture of Clinton on the phone dealing with a crisis. Does anyone believe Biden could take that call now? In four years? Biden recently announced — in a shocking own goal — that he won’t be doing events after 8 p.m. so he can get more sleep. So one thinks a guy Trump has dubbed “Sleepy Joe” needs <em>more</em> sleep. What happens at 3 a.m. when the phone rings? Biden might not even be able to hit the snooze button.</p><p>In parliamentary democracies, there are votes of no confidence, which can bring down a government and remove a leader. It is a key check and balance on power. In the US, this doesn’t exist. A motion to vacate can remove the Speaker of the House, as we saw recently with Kevin McCarthy, but outside of impeachment, removing a president is hard. Still, the growing calls for Biden to step down — especially from people who admire and have supported him — are a de facto vote of no confidence.</p><p>The next few days are crucial for Biden as he does public interviews and leads the NATO summit to try to show the world he is still in the game and ready to lead for four more years. It will not be enough. Biden can’t interview his way out of old age anymore than Trump can promise to stop lying. These are two immutable candidate qualities. The challenge for both parties is to either accept these profound flaws of their leaders — as Republicans clearly have — and damn the consequences <em>or</em> … to honestly assess the situation and do something about it.</p><p>For Biden in 2024, stepping down would be his way of stepping up.</p><p>For <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>, who is also facing multiple calls to step down, this week is a reversal: He has to answer calls to step <em>up</em> on national defense, and he just has. Today, Trudeau <a target="_blank" href="https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/nato-canada-trudeau-1.7260649"><u>announced</u></a> that Canada will finally reach the target of 2% of GDP to be spent on the military by 2032, though he has not revealed many details on how this will happen. We cover this later in the newsletter, but Trudeau clearly realizes that on the 75th anniversary of NATO, with a war raging in Ukraine and Trump possibly winning the next election, NATO laggards are losers. Hitting the 2% target is now table stakes if Canada is to be taken seriously in NATO or at the G7 or G20. But is it realistic?</p><p>As important as it is to hit the NATO target, it will not be cheap. Tens of billions of dollars will be added to the national defense budget, something the Trudeau government, or a potential Conservative government led by <strong>Pierre Poilievre</strong>, would have to find. That means either higher deficits or deep program cuts. The reason Canada has not hit the 2% mark before is simple: choices. There are more votes in health care transfer payments and social programs than in defense. But Trudeau knows that he has to make this promise to be taken seriously and to have any purchase with a future Trump administration. It is an open question to see if future governments actually fulfill it and stick to the timeline.</p><p>Is it enough to help Trudeau in the polls? No. It will make no difference. His dismal polling numbers are tied to inflation, the cost of housing, and nine years of governance, not national defense. But sometimes, even when facing calls to step down, you have to make the hard choice to step up.</p><p>Leadership is about knowing when to step down and when to step up.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>The hunt for the killer clip</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/the-hunt-for-the-killer-clip</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfrgrtjtcs07my0vlqgwxl</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 27 Jun 2024 19:22:03 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>debate</category>
<category>presidential debate</category>
<category>2024 presidential election</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>More than anything else tonight at the presidential debate, Joe Biden and Donald Trump will be hunting for the one viral video clip that will define their opponent and frame the campaign.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrco434cugz07lqnoellsfc" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta, GZERO</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrco434cugz07lqnoellsfc" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Happy debate night as we all hunker down for the face-to-face rematch in Atlanta of the Age vs. Rage election, now just hours away.</p><p>More than anything else tonight at the presidential debate, <strong>Joe Biden</strong> and <strong>Donald Trump</strong> will be hunting for the one viral video clip that will define their opponent and frame the campaign. For the first time in close to four years, they will share a stage, and millions of people across blue and red states will finally exit their bias-affirming bubbles and tune in collectively to a single program. Just that fact alone — that it’s a moment when tens of millions of people across the hyper-fractured country gather for a common, shared political reality — makes tonight critical.</p><p><strong>The three big factors:</strong> Age, Rage, and what happens on Stage. Make no mistake, policies and issues are critical and should be the main course tonight. Immigration, inflation, taxes, foreign affairs, abortion stance, and those pesky 34 felonies … all those matter and will be the focus of the moderators' agenda, according to CNN. But since the 1960 Nixon-Kennedy faceoff through today’s hyper-accelerated, viral social media culture, the impact of presidential debates has moved from policy to personality, from ideas to image. It is all about “the clip.”</p><p><strong>There are different kinds of clips.</strong></p><p><strong>The Stumble Clip:</strong> Biden is much more vulnerable here because the consensus narrative around him is that, at 81, he’s simply too old for the job. One verbal trip, a name mix-up, a fumble, or one inopportune freeze will have exponentially outsized impact. The<a target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MyMosJdIfdo"> worst stumble clip</a> might well be when former Texas Gov. Rick Perry ran for the Republican nomination in 2011 and famously forgot which government agency he promised to cut. “It is three agencies of government that are gone when I get there," he thundered on live TV. “Commerce, education, and … umm … uh, the, uh … what’s the third one there … let’s see …” He started to fumble desperately and, pressed to name the agency by the moderator, he checked his notes for a lifeline. Only there was nothing there. Perry’s blank space went viral long before <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e-ORhEE9VVg">Taylor Swift’s</a>, and he finally petered out, mumbling the politically radioactive word: “Oops.” It was over. Biden cannot have a Perry moment.</p><p>Even at his best, Biden speaks in a slow, raspy drawl, like the sludge-filled tributaries of the Lackawanna River, which cuts through his hometown of Scranton, Pennsylvania. Between awkward pauses, Biden often punctuates his words with sock-hop-era words like “malarkey,” which adds sepia tones to his already vintage vibe struggling to find a place in a hi-def world.</p><p>Trump will try to interrupt, even if they mute his mic, to throw Biden off, while attacking the president on the border, the Middle East, and inflation. So, more than anything else, Biden needs to look and sound alert, quick on his feet, on top of the details, and strong.</p><p>Though Trump also stumbles, makes multiple factual errors, and gets names wrong, that’s long been baked into his personality. What’s another 34 untruths or 34 stumbles next to his 34 felonies? None of it sticks. The age-related stumble is not Trump’s worry. He has to watch out for another trap: The Chaos Clip.</p><p><strong>The Chaos Clip:</strong> Trump is the great conductor of political chaos, culminating in the Jan. 6 attack on the US Capitol. Even fellow Republicans thought that was the end of Trump. It wasn’t. Trump has not only recovered, he’s transformed the Jan. 6 mob into heroes and hostages, a stunning rebranding exercise and one that takes center stage at his rallies. Still, if Trump coughs up a clip about not respecting the election results, lashes out at the justice system to repudiate his 34 felony charges, says he will pull out of NATO, or threatens to drop a nuke on Iran or otherwise destabilize the world order, it could undermine his campaign.</p><p>Too much chaos fueled by his bottomless pool of rage and resentment would be deeply damaging. Biden will try to bait him here, and I wonder if he gets so bold as to call Trump a “felon” to his face. Still, Trump loves the stage, doesn’t rely on notes, and if he looks strong, overpowering, and avoids the chaos, it is all upside for him.</p><p><strong>The Killer Clip:</strong> From <strong>Ronald Regan’s</strong> famed 1980 zinger, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qN7gDRjTNf4">“There you go again”</a> aimed at <strong>Jimmy Carter</strong> – which 44 years ago seemed nasty and today would barely register – to the 1988 uppercut Lloyd Bentsen landed in the vice presidential debate, telling Dan Quayle<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHtlbZpZUSs"> “Senator, You are no Jack Kennedy,”</a> this is the sought-after, white whale of political debates. Biden came close in the last debate with his “<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XF03SdCyfRI">Will you shut up man,”</a> showing he could punch off the ropes. He will need that again – look for it on Trump’s convictions, abortion, and foreign policy. But no one delivers nastier or more quotable quips than Trump. If he senses Biden is stumbling, he could deliver a killer clip from which Biden might not recover.</p><p>So as they hunt for the clip of the night – and as their staff prep as much for the post-debate social media moments as the debate itself – Biden needs to overcome age, Trump needs to contain rage, and both need to avoid a big gaffe on stage.</p><p>Can’t wait for 9 p.m. EDT.</p><p>We have lots of coverage of the debate for you.<strong> Ian Bremmer</strong> will be watching, and we will get a video of his insights into a Quick Take video tonight right after the debate, so check our<a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/sponsored-posts/smithsonians-national-portrait-gallery-boa-050125"> site</a> and social platforms for that. On Friday at 7 a.m., look for GZERO Daily, which will be filled with analysis. At 10 a.m. EDT Friday, I’ll be <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1BdGYrERemLJX">hosting a live X space</a> with our team and special guests to go over the hits, misses, and the impact of the debate. Join in and it will get spicy.</p><p><strong>John Lieber</strong> will also have his take on what’s next in our US election video series on Friday. And, oh yes, please play along with our<a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/search/?q=bingo"> debate bingo</a>, which is a great way to engage with things tonight.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Hey, progressives, it’s time to look in the mirror</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/hey-progressives-its-time-to-look-in-the-mirror</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfr2xtjs4107myrtmxcebb</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 20 Jun 2024 19:26:31 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>us election</category>
<category>us politics</category>
<category>white house</category>
<category>elections 2024</category>
<category>progressive</category>
<category>washington</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Progressives are looking for another Obama moment, and cannot understand why so many people are choosing Trump over Biden, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon. It’s like there&apos;s an invisible, Don DeLillo-esque cloud hanging overhead with the words, “How are we losing to him?”</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcnhmyctc907lq6muhbb5i" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcnhmyctc907lq6muhbb5i" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>He has the look of an aging but determined Rafael Nadal trying to make one last comeback. He heaves his body back and looks poised to crush a forehand, as he has a thousand times before. This time, however, it doesn’t go as expected. To his utter shock, the ball hits the net and limply falls to the ground. “Why?” his look implies. “Why are we losing here?” He resets to try for another point, but he nets it again.<br></p><p>Only this isn’t Nadal.</p><p>It’s <strong>Mitch Landrieu</strong>, the former mayor of New Orleans and current co-chair of <strong>Joe Biden</strong>’s reelection campaign. Landrieu, like so many progressives looking for another Obama moment, cannot understand why so many people are choosing Trump over Biden. It’s like there is an invisible, Don DeLillo-esque cloud hanging overhead with the words, “How are we losing to him?”</p><p>Make no mistake, Landrieu is very good at his job and not only deeply understands Biden’s policies — after all, he helped oversee the trillion-plus-dollar infrastructure bill — he’s also a Biden believer. That means he can’t stand <strong>Donald Trump</strong>. Or, more precisely, he cannot understand why so many people like the former president.</p><p>So here he was, playing the anti-Trump hits on stage in Toronto at our US-Canada Summit to a room that just kept shrugging: 34 felony convictions; sexual assault charge; Jan. 6 insurrection; can’t keep staff; Trump’s own attorney general, <strong>Bill Barr</strong>, called his claims of a stolen election "bogus.” Periodically, Landrieu would look at the crowd, seemingly exasperated by the lack of emotion, and ask, “Why are we normalizing Donald Trump?” But he never asked the more painful question: “Why are our policies so unpopular?” He was like the aging athlete, baffled as to why he is still not winning.</p><p>The Dems’ case against Trump has been made countless times, but it simply is not working. At Eurasia Group, we have the odds of Trump winning at 60%. David Axelrod, the former Obama campaign guru and current CNN political commentator, was with us watching Landrieu. As I wrote last week, I asked Axelrod whether Democrats need to spend more time reflecting on why their policies are not connecting with voters and less time trying to convince people that Trump is a big baddy.</p><p>“Absolutely,” he responded, going on to describe how Democrats have lost touch with large swaths of the American public, content with lecturing them in condescending tones about how to be better citizens and “more like us” — meaning the folks who run around Washington telling people what to say and what not to say. Democrats are like the kid in the front of the class with his hand up all the time. He may have the right answers, but no one likes him.</p><p>“Strong and wrong beats weak and right,” Axelrod said, repeating a <strong>Bill Clinton</strong> line. And Biden looks weak. Not only that, Axelrod made the point that Democrats focus too heavily on what they have done in the past, not what they will do in the future.</p><p>What’s next beats what was, and progressives are losing on that score. A<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.americansurveycenter.org/research/an-unsettled-electorate-how-uncertainty-and-apathy-are-shaping-the-2024-election/"> <u>new poll from the American Survey Center</u></a> found that “Nearly six in 10 (58 percent) say America’s best days are behind it. Forty percent say America’s best days are yet to come.” This marks a huge change since 2020 when most Americans were optimistic about the future.</p><p>As Daniel Cox <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.americansurveycenter.org/newsletter/how-trump-benefits-from-americas-growing-pessimism/#:~:text=Forty-three%20percent%20of%20Americans,a%20positive%20opinion%20of%20him."><u>writes</u></a>, while most candidates run on optimism, Trump runs on pessimism because it’s connecting with his large constituency — primarily white male voters. “Forty-three percent of Americans who believe people are not to be trusted have a favorable view of Trump compared to 28 percent of those who say people are generally trustworthy,” he writes. It’s not <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUMqic2IcWA"><u>morning again in America</u></a>, like under Ronald Reagan; this is Trump’s American carnage, reflecting how many people actually think.</p><p>Incumbents around the world are facing “Thelma &amp; Louise” moments right now: If they keep doing what they are doing, they will drive off a cliff. So it’s not just progressives. In the UK, Prime Minister<strong> Rishi Sunak</strong> is already airborne and plummeting toward the ground. <strong>Narendra Modi</strong> got punished in India. <strong>Emmanuel Macron</strong> is floundering in France, and Canadian Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> is in even worse political shape.</p><p>A new Ipsos poll done for Global News found that 68% of Canadians want Trudeau to step down. Snowstorms poll higher than that in Canada. “This is as bad as we’ve seen it for Trudeau,”<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://globalnews.ca/tag/ipsos"> <u>Ipsos</u></a> CEO Darrell Bricker<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://globalnews.ca/news/10574422/justin-trudeau-should-he-resign-ipsos/"> <u>told Global.</u></a> “It’s close to rock bottom.”</p><p>On June 24, Trudeau will face a major test with a byelection in what has long been one of the safest Liberal ridings in the country, St. Paul’s, in downtown Toronto. The Liberals should win easily, but it’s going to be close, and if they somehow lose, Trudeau will feel more heat than from today’s weather bomb to step down. (Conservatives don’t want him to go, preferring to run against a weakened Trudeau in the next election.)</p><p>Still, the point remains: Progressive ideas are not connecting. If the policies were actually working — a case both Biden and Trudeau are trying to make — poll results would look rosier. But they don’t.</p><p>Trudeau’s signature tax on carbon to deal with climate change is now a shield — not a sword — issue. His attempt to change the narrative by igniting a class war with his new capital gains tax on the rich has done little to reframe the narrative, but the poorly explained policy has alienated lots of centrist voters. In politics, the old saw “Explaining is losing” has always seemed trite to me — policy often takes time to be understood — but if the explanation is bad, then, yeah, you are losing.</p><p>Biden is trying to boost his image by offering undocumented spouses a pathway to permanent US residency and his student loan forgiveness. Both may be popular, but neither has really improved his polling. Why?</p><p>Trudeau is facing a change wave, and Biden an age wave, but the issues are deeper than that. The fundamental premise that progressives pitch — that their social and economic policies work to improve people’s quality of life — is losing its plausibility, weakened by inflation, a world in crisis, and a long-term, low-growth environment. Trump may not have solid answers — his self-absorbed victimization narrative lacks facts, optimism, and generosity — but his dark view of the world reflects a mood, and people mistake that for truth. Trump reflects how many people feel; Biden is promising things many no longer believe are possible.</p><p>Populism always has an angry protest strain to it, but the response to it is usually clear: Show growth. Build things that work: roads, hospitals, opportunities. Don’t go broke. And finally, get stuff done, and be seen to be getting it done. People have to feel better about their lives. And they are not.</p><p>Progressives keep looking in the mirror, and they only see opponents they believe are unfit for office. They have to start seeing themselves and figure out why their promises and policies are not connecting more widely. Self-reflection is hard, but tearing down the other guy only works for so long, especially for an incumbent. They need to reinvent themselves as credible leaders promising something better in the future, not just recycled defenders of their past glory days. They must prove their big new promises are doable in short periods of time. Otherwise, they risk looking like those aging athletes who criticize the skills of the new generation of competitors but keep losing. In politics, the past ain't prologue. It just doesn’t work that way. Just ask Rafa Nadal.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>American and Canadian voters yearn for something they might never get</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/american-and-canadian-voters-yearn-for-something-they-might-never-get</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfqtevkj1o07lqbtjav0gw</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 13 Jun 2024 18:28:05 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>border</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>migration</category>
<category>border wall</category>
<category>defense spending</category>
<category>democrats</category>
<category>republicans</category>
<category>globalization</category>
<category>us-canada summit</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Is there a deep, secret yearning from American and Canadian voters for a radically open border? Do people really want Canada and the US to be more like the EU, or is border politics all about isolationism, security fears, and building walls?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcn1imc47o07myxkzo77r3" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="800">
<media:credit>David Pike</media:credit>
<media:text>Ian Bremmer addresses the audience at the 2024 US-Canada Summit in Toronto.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcn1imc47o07myxkzo77r3" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Is there a deep, secret yearning from American and Canadian voters for a radically open border? Do people really want Canada and the US to be more like the EU? OR, is border politics all about isolationism, security fears, and building walls? The results of an exclusive new poll from GZERO and Data Science will surprise you – and ought to be shaping the election campaigns in both countries.<br></p><p>We revealed part of the poll at the US-Canada Summit that I had the pleasure of co-hosting in Toronto, put on by the teams at Eurasia Group and BMO. Led off by our own <strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> and BMO’s CEO <strong>Darryl White</strong>, it included a remarkable collection of over 500 people, including political leaders from across the spectrum in both countries who debated, speechified, conversed, and argued.</p><p>Why are so many people so keen to discuss the US-Canada relationship? As Bremmer said, this is a hinge moment in history, with three wars raging — one in Ukraine, one in the Middle East, and one in the United States — a remark that caused gasps and nods. On top of that, 60+ elections are reshaping the world this year (Modi humbled in India, Macron in a showdown with the far right in France, Sunak shambolically slinking off in the UK). Meanwhile, China is threatening Taiwan, and AI is grinding its way through our economies and imaginations.</p><p><strong>Gary Cohn</strong>, former director of the National Economic Council under Trump and the vice chairman of IBM, admitted that what worries him most is the collision between geopolitics and the economy. They are inextricably linked and making things worse. With the political bombs falling so close, people are desperately looking for a safe shelter, and that shelter is the US-Canada relationship. As Delaware Sen. <strong>Chris Coons</strong> said, squabbles between the two countries over tariffs or softwood lumber don’t add up to a pile of shell casing next to say China and Taiwan, which may be why the relationship is so often taken for granted or outright ignored. It is and remains one of the biggest bilateral trading relationships in the world.</p><p>Globalization is giving way to new forms of regionalism, or “friend-shoring with a vengeance.” But should the region have internal walls or not?</p><p>The mandate of the conference is to bring together people tired of partisan bickering, slogan swamping, and dizzying disinformationalizing – in other words, the bubble-blowing BS of everyday politics. They are urged to be authentic, honest, and, despite their political differences, get on with figuring out how to build something better and more secure than we have now. And they did.</p><p><strong>Who joined in?</strong></p><p>This is a partial list (pause for a long breath): Delaware Sen. <strong>Chris Coons</strong>, Illinois Gov. <strong>JB Pritzker</strong>, Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister <strong>Mélanie Joly</strong>, Industry Minister <strong>Francois Phillippe Champagne</strong>, Treasury Board President <strong>Anita Anand</strong>, who settled a major border strike during the conference, Ontario and Saskatchewan Premiers <strong>Doug Ford</strong> and <strong>Scott Moe</strong>, Alaska Gov. <strong>Mike</strong> <strong>Dunleavy</strong>, political wizards like <strong>David Axelrod</strong> from the Obama campaign and <strong>Christopher Liddell</strong>, the former White House Deputy Chief of Staff to <strong>Donald Trump</strong>.</p><p>Speaking of the Trump folks, there was <strong>Gary Cohn</strong>, mentioned above, giving Canada a shot and saying it can “tag along” on US economic progress. Former Bank of Canada and England Governor <strong>Mark Carney&nbsp;</strong>spoke about building together based on common values, and there was <strong>Mitch Landrieu</strong>, the Biden/Harris 2024 National Campaign Co-Chair, who was in full fight mode over Trump. They were joined by more than 150 CEOs, dozens of policy wonks, and experts on everything from AI, security, economic policy, and more.</p><p><strong>There were tray loads of interesting insights and ideas:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>On Trade:</strong> The 2026 review of the USMCA is widely seen as the most important framework for the economic future of North America, and there are genuine fears that if Trump wins (Turns out, Ivermectin may actually be a political vaccine against felony convictions) and senses that trade imbalances with the US have not changed, he will rip it up and send the economies reeling with nasty and counterproductive tariffs.</li><li><strong>On the Inflation Reduction Act:</strong> Candid admissions from US politicians that protectionism and US industrial policy can sideswipe Canada, simply because Canada gets forgotten.</li><li><strong>On Biden vs. Trump:</strong> A quote attributed to <strong>Bill Clinton</strong> was repeated as to why Biden’s good economic record is not reflected in his polling: “Strong and wrong beats weak and right.”</li><li><strong>On why Democrats are losing working-class voters:&nbsp;</strong>I asked David Axelrod why Democrats and progressives spend so much time convincing themselves that people like Trump are not fit for office but so little time reflecting on why their own policies are failing to connect with so many people. He told me — and later told the audience — that Democrats treat working-class Americans with such condescension it’s like anthropologist Margaret Mead studying what were then called “primitive societies” and telling them, “You need to be more like us, and we can teach you.” A devastating critique.</li><li><strong>Here is another Axe moment:</strong> Why are some independent and conservative voters tuning out Trump?” “Having Trump as president is like living next to someone who runs a leaf blower 24/7.”</li><li><strong>Personnel is policy:</strong> Gary Cohn spoke about why you need to know the people in power. “Any president gets to make 2,800 appointments — they make them all — but ‘personnel is policy,’ so if you want to know what Trump will do, see who he is appointing.” By the way, expect the USMCA trade negotiator <strong>Robert Leitheiser</strong>, the very guy who insisted on the six-year trade review, to be a senior member of the Trump team,</li><li><strong>Christopher Liddell of Trump White House 1.0</strong>, admitted that Trump didn’t know what he was doing in the first six months of his first term, but that it’s different this time, and that the planning and policies are already well underway. We should expect the first six months of a Trump 2.o to be rapid, decisive, and consequential, as he only has one term. His first target will be China and … his political enemies.</li><li><strong>On defense spending:&nbsp;</strong>Mark Carney said Canada has no more excuses and must reach 2% spending on NATO – just weeks before the NATO summit in Washington.</li></ul><p>But there was one issue that lurked beneath the surface of cross-border politics and wasn’t raised: Should the demand by many US politicians to close down their southern border be counterbalanced by a much quieter, almost secret demand from people to … open the Canadian border, EU style?</p><p>It is not as crazy as it sounds.</p><p>GZERO commissioned an exclusive poll from our partners at Data Sciences and asked: Would you support an EU-like arrangement between the US and Canada?</p><p><strong>The results are fascinating.</strong></p><p>Overall, 53% said they would support such an arrangement – 50% in Canada and 55% in the US, while 33% are neutral. And, get this, only 14% are against the idea. Not surprisingly, it breaks down on party lines: 71% of Biden supporters are far more supportive the idea, while 45% of Trump supporters want it. In Canada, it’s almost an even split: 50% LPC/NDP lime it while on the right, 54% of CPC/PPC support the idea.</p><p>The point? The longest undefended border in the world is still very defended, and millions of people would like to cross more easily, work more freely, and trade more efficiently. In 2022, US trade with Mexico was $855 billion, and with China it was $758 billion. With Canada? $908 billion.</p><p>So making US-Canada trade more efficient with an EU-style arrangement seems like a no-brainer. Last week, we all celebrated D-Day and the beginning of the fight for peace. So many people died in that bloody sacrifice, yet today, the French and the Germans, who fought two world wars that left millions on both sides slaughtered, can move, trade, and work freely across each other's borders in a way Americans and Canada can only dream about. It is baffling.</p><p>If anything is a warning about why closing borders and setting up tariffs is disastrous, look at the UK and Brexit, which has essentially tanked the UK economy. The Brexit-loving Conservatives under Rishi Sunak are now facing a potential political extinction event on par with the Canadian Conservative party of 1993, when Brian Mulroney went from winning the biggest majority in Canadian history to stepping down months before an election his party lost so badly they were left with two lonely seats.</p><p>We are heading into a US election and a possible Canadian election where low growth, high inflation, and fear of an unstable world might kill prosperity. Why aren’t the two best friends in the world campaigning on an idea that has proven to be one of Europe’s great drivers of growth? An open border.</p><p>We all get it. The politics of the southern border is driving politics at the northern border, but if voters can distinguish between the two, why can’t politicians?</p><p>They likely never will. And this may be the most 2024 political moment of all: Ignore the quiet ideas people want, and focus on the noisy fights no one can stand.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>From D-Day to E-Day: Legacy of the Longest Day</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/from-d-day-to-e-day-legacy-of-the-longest-day</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfqezijqbq07myhdlw1z88</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 06 Jun 2024 19:12:44 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>normandy</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>nato</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>global order</category>
<category>veterans</category>
<category>europe</category>
<category>d-day</category>
<category>alliance</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>This 80th anniversary of D-Day is particularly resonant as the West questions whether the alliances that have supported the world for 80 years are coming to an end. Will Election Day in the US lead to a Trump administration that backs out of NATO and moves toward realigning the global order around a new American isolationism?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcmeelc2x607mymkm9o48n" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="632">
<media:credit>Ammar Abd Rabbo/ABACAPRESS.COM via Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>Illustration of the graves at the Normandy American Cemetery and Memorial after the US ceremony marking the 80th anniversary of the World War II D- Day Allied landings in Normandy, in Colleville-sur-Mer, France, on June 6, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcmeelc2x607mymkm9o48n" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>At 5:52 a.m. on June 6, 1944, Private First Class Gene Sellers, a high-school football star who had just received a scholarship to play at the University of Arkansas, leaped from a plane to parachute behind Nazi lines in Normandy, France. As part of the Pathfinder unit, Sellers’ job was to set up a covert radio and communications base to help guide the rest of the American troops who would follow hours later as part of Operation Overlord. Tragically, Sellers drifted too far behind enemy lines and was spotted and killed, becoming the first American casualty of D-Day.<br></p><p>Later that morning, on a nearby strip of coastline, <a target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPiIu1v--BA"><u>Jim Parks</u></a>,<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPiIu1v--BA">&nbsp;</a>of the Royal Winnipeg Rifles, joined 21,000 other Canadians attempting to land at Juno Beach. They immediately came under heavy German fire, and Parks had to jump into the ocean.</p><p>“I was a mortar carrier,” Parks says in a remarkable video you can watch at the Juno Beach Centre. Weighed down by all his equipment, Parks thought he would drown, but somehow he managed to swim to shore. Once there, however, he had to go back into the heaving ocean and drag out the bodies of men who’d been shot in the first minutes of the operation. There were 359 Canadians among the 4,000 Allied troops who made the ultimate sacrifice on that day.</p><p>The 80th anniversary of D-Day is being marked today by world leaders, including President <strong>Joe Biden</strong> and Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>, both of whom are in France alongside the very few remaining veterans who witnessed the carnage.</p><p>This anniversary is particularly resonant as the West questions whether the alliances that have supported the world for 80 years are coming to an end. Will Election Day in the US lead to a Trump administration that backs out of NATO and moves toward realigning the global order around a new American isolationism?</p><p>On the one hand, NATO has never been stronger. With the additions of Sweden and Finland, the alliance that started with just 12 countries is now 32 members strong. The Russian invasion of Ukraine two years ago has reanimated the purpose of NATO and the need to protect and defend democracies. By that measure, alliances are stronger and more relevant than ever.</p><p>On the other hand, populist forces in the US are engaged in what might well be called “Operation Undermine”: an effort to defund NATO altogether. This week, Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) got the support of 46 Republican members for her “Defund NATO” amendment to the Military Construction and Veteran Affairs appropriations bill. She <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HOahKNjDYF8"><u>sought to remove</u></a> over $433 million of funding earmarked for NATO bases where US soldiers are stationed and to focus on what she calls the invasion of America on the southern border. Her amendment failed, but the effort to retreat into a radical form of US isolationism is real, robust, and ongoing.</p><p>Greene called out Canada, France, Germany, and others for failing to meet NATO’s 2% GDP defense target spending, which is a valid point. If you want insurance, you gotta pay for it.</p><p>As of this year, only 18 of the 32 countries in NATO will hit that target. Canada remains a laggard on this metric – an issue that will most certainly come up at next month’s crucial NATO summit in Washington.</p><p>This summit will mark the 75th anniversary of the alliance, and countries – including Canada – will be expected to make bigger commitments (though not enough to reach 2% in the near term) as the threats get bigger. But support will not be unanimous, and it will be interesting to see which Republicans show up and speak loudly about the importance of NATO given the fact that <strong>Donald Trump</strong> will secure the Republican nomination only days later.</p><p>Alliances, however, depend on trade as much as security. Since 1945, the small “l” liberal world order has been stitched together by global trade agreements; treaties on nuclear arms, space, AI, and climate; and myriad other issues. It has worked to achieve a period of peace and prosperity. But those structures are under threat by demagogues and isolationists who ignore their rules altogether.</p><p>The efficacy of the EU was deeply challenged by Brexit, while in North America, the next big challenge will be the 2026 renegotiation of the United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement on trade. If Trump is elected in November, he could rip it up, shredding a key alliance, hurting economic growth with tariffs, and sowing more distrust. Tariffs are always challenging to the global economy as they protect local industries but generally make goods more expensive and hurt local productivity. They also undermine global trade treaties.</p><p>That is why next week, Eurasia Group, GZERO’s parent company, and the Bank of Montreal are co-hosting a nonpartisan summit in Toronto, where they will take a deep dive into the US-Canada alliance on everything from trade and security resources to climate. This is the biggest trading relationship in the world, and ensuring that it is not disrupted is crucial for the prosperity of citizens in both countries. We will have a full report on the substance of next week’s US-Canada summit, including what guests from across the political spectrum had to say, in this newsletter.</p><p>D-Day is a reminder that alliances like ours are hard-won, obtained through the blood of people like Gene Sellers and seared in the memory of veterans like Jim Parks. Alliances like NATO allowed us all to secure our freedoms, turn former enemies into allies, and create an unprecedented period of prosperity and peace. They inspire generations of people to make sacrifices for the greater good and for the values we cherish in democracies. Those are all under threat, and today of all days, we might want to think twice before throwing away the rewards of D-Day for the politics of E-Day.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Sunak picks a generation fight</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/sunak-picks-a-generation-fight</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfq1xvkgpc07lqlrpk7qrh</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 30 May 2024 17:24:49 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united kingdom</category>
<category>elections</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>europe</category>
<category>rishi sunak</category>
<category>conservative party</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>In Britain, they are frantically rewriting dictionaries to ensure the word “desperate” is spelled “Sunak” after the poll-parched British PM Rishi Sunk – er Sunak – launched his campaign for the July 4th election, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrclsn4cq9k07lqpsu1lkwm" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="676">
<media:credit>Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>Prime Minister Rishi Sunak delivers a stump speech to party members at the MK Gallery in Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire, while on the General Election campaign trail.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrclsn4cq9k07lqpsu1lkwm" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The golden rule of desperate politicians? Find a target, pick a fight.</p><p>In Britain, they are frantically rewriting dictionaries to ensure the word “desperate” is spelled “Sunak” after the poll-parched British PM <strong>Rishi Sunk</strong> – I mean <strong>Sunak</strong> – launched his campaign for the July 4th election.</p><p>Because Ian wrote about <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/by-ian-bremmer/sunaks-gamble-leaves-tories-on-the-edge-of-defeat"><u>Sunak’s quizzical election call</u></a> yesterday in his GZERO newsletter, I won’t warm over the fandango of foozles that have left Sunak a gaping 27 points behind Labour – from the now infamous rain-soaked “Drowning Street” launch to his follow-up visit to the Titanic shipyard. But desperate times call for desperate policies, so as sure as Pimm’s at Wimbledon, Sunak has predictably picked a target: young people.</p><p>“There’s no doubt that our democratic values are under threat,” Sunak said as <strong>he sprung a new promise&nbsp;</strong>to bring back a compulsory service for young people in Britain decades after the last one was disbanded in 1960. “That is why we will introduce a bold new model of national service for 18-year-olds.” For once, a Sunak policy announcement made more headlines than his campaign clangers.<strong></strong></p><p>The plan would require that all 18-year-old Brits give a year of service in the military (up to 30,000 people could do this) or, for the rest of the 700,000 members of that demographic, some other form of community service for one weekend a month, working with organizations like the police, NHS, and fire service.</p><p>The plan would cost about 2.5 billion pounds a year and its goal is to unite diverse Britons in a shared mission of values, selflessness, and service.</p><p><strong>How popular is the idea?</strong> According to a new <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/survey-results/daily/2024/05/28/4a575/1">YouGov</a> poll, 47% of Brits support the idea, while 45% oppose it. Even better for Conservatives looking for a wedge: 63% of folks over age 65 – voters who go to the polls and who often vote Conservative! – support the idea, and 53% between the ages of 50-64 support it. That adds up to a winning issue for Sunak.</p><p><strong>Who’s against it?&nbsp;</strong>The vast majority of young people, with 65% of those aged 18 to 24 and 47% between the ages of 25 and 49 opposed to it.</p><p>This is what you call an intergenerational political war. For a policy meant to unite the country, the first thing it has done is divide it.</p><p>Still, to Sunak’s credit, the idea has got folks talking <strong>and it has merit</strong>. He has finally seized back some control of the agenda with a provocative idea instead of a pratfall. He has pointed out that a similar program has been successful in Sweden and that he is building on David Cameron’s 2010 volunteer program, the National Citizens Service, which is still in place.</p><p>There are also similar programs in the US and Canada. Every year over 200,000 young Americans participate in AmeriCorps, getting them to volunteer in community programs across the country, while generations have gone overseas to work in the Peace Corps, the famed international development program set up by President <strong>John F. Kennedy</strong> in 1961.</p><p>In Canada, Prime Minister <strong>Pierre Trudeau</strong> started a youth volunteer program called Katimavik in the late 1970s. It’s now funded under the larger <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.canada.ca/en/services/youth/canada-service-corps.html."><u>Canada Service Corps</u></a>, which gets young people experience in community-based programs.</p><p>All these programs are seeds of the Kennedy “ask not what your country can do for you” generation. In principle,<strong>&nbsp;</strong>it’s a very good thing for leaders to push for public service and to engage with youth, giving them guidance, skills, opportunity, and structure.</p><p>However, the difference between AmeriCorps or Katimavik and Sunak’s idea is that the former two are voluntary programs, not mandatory ones. If a government wants to impose mandatory service on a generation, it would be wise to spend a long time socializing the idea, getting support, and, in general, building a consensus. Springing it on the public and using it as a major campaign platform signals to young people that <em>they</em> are the problem Britain needs to fix.</p><p><strong>Really? The problem is young people?</strong> It’s not the self-inflicted wound of Brexit, which Sunak supported, that tanked the economy? It’s not the struggling NHS health care system? It’s not years of inflation, high housing prices, climate issues, security issues, immigration challenges, or the scandals that have riven the government for 14 years? Nope, forget all that. The problem is the 18-year-olds who inherited this screwed-up world. Now they are being told they must fix it.</p><p>No wonder they don’t like the idea. The young people who will be forced to start this program were only three and four years old when the Conservatives took power and steered the country to this desperate point. These same young people already had one mandated behavior policy forced on them during COVID, when they were told they must stay inside their homes for the good of the country. Now, the same folks who made them lose precious years of socializing while they held secret COVID parties at Downing Street and drinking merrily are telling youths they must “get out of the house for the good of the country.” Stay in. Get out. Make up your mind, old people.</p><p>Drafting young people into service to clean up a mess they did not make is as old as politics – every wartime draft faces this issue – but it can also point to a deep lack of accountability by governments, especially those that rely on older voters for success.</p><p>Encouraging public service is a good thing, but politicians might first want to do their jobs and create a high-growth economy before forcing young people to work (or “volunteer”) to fix the very system the politicians got paid to break.</p><p><strong>Here is an idea.&nbsp;</strong>Maybe Sunak &amp; Co. should offer to work as volunteers for one full year as politicians – do their job for free for 12 months – as an example of public service to young people.</p><p>Is that a fight worth picking? Politicians forced to work for free in service of the country they are leading? Outrageous. No way. Would never fly.</p><p>Especially when they can get young people to do the job for them.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>A summer of discontent</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/a-summer-of-discontent</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfpqnwkfp307lq3uesyo33</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 23 May 2024 18:03:21 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>inflation</category>
<category>united kingdom</category>
<category>elections</category>
<category>rishi sunak</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>politics</category>
<category>tariffs</category>
<category>us politics</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Facing elections and down in the polls, Joe Biden and Justin Trudeau have a lot of bogeys on their radar, but three are starting to stand out ...</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvram96k80ko07my0c9gtcvx" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1054" height="703" />
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvram96k80ko07my0c9gtcvx" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Facing elections and down in the polls, <strong>Joe Biden&nbsp;</strong>and <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> have a lot of bogeys on their radar, but three are starting to stand out: the election call in Britain, Labor strife in Canada, and the rising and potentially self-defeating political popularity of tariffs.<br></p><h3>1. Rishi Sunak’s Soggy Snap Election Surprise: Comeback Miracle or Cautionary Tale for Incumbents?</h3><p>After 14 years of Conservative rule in Britain, Labour now has a chance to take the helm. Beleaguered Prime Minister <strong>Rishi Sunak</strong> held a rain-drenched (read: pathetic) fallacy of a media conference yesterday to announce a surprise July 4 general election. Why did he do it? Most analysts expected Sunak to drag it out until late fall, giving himself at least two years as PM – 14.8 times longer than the wilting 49-day head-of-lettuce term of <strong>Liz Truss</strong>, who Sunak replaced in 2022. They were wrong. The Tories are down 20 points in the polls, so when Sunak saw inflation finally fall to the target rate of 2.3% – a rare win – he reckoned it wouldn’t get much better in the months ahead. A summer election could mean low voter turnout, which usually helps the incumbent.</p><p><strong>Joe Biden</strong> and <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> are watching closely. Both are also incumbents facing low polling numbers and an electorate that believes (facts be damned) that things are worse than ever. If Sunak can somehow turn it around – and that’s a big “if” – it would answer a core question: Can falling inflation rates reinflate incumbent popularity? Will people ever believe things are getting better? Biden and Trudeau hope so.</p><p>Sunak’s July 4 election will likely end in ashes, not fireworks, for British conservatives, but Biden and Trudeau will pick through the coals and see what they can learn from the fire.</p><h3>2. How to Fight Your Own Base Without Losing Their Vote?</h3><p>Everyone reading this column will be familiar with the return-to-work debate. How often are you required to go back to the office post-pandemic, and how much do you want to work from home? Two days, three days, or more? I would be interested to hear your thoughts on that, and you can send them my way <a>here</a>.</p><p>In Canada, the debate has been reignited by the federal government’s decision to get public servants back in the office … wait for it … three days a week starting in September. Currently, they work two days a week at the office.</p><p>This is not a pay cut. This is not a downsizing. This is simply a back-to-work policy that is in line with almost every other industry. But the unions have gone ballistic, threatening a “summer of discontent” that could include disrupting borders.</p><p>File this one under the department of “With friends like these …” After all, the Liberal government has increased the size of the federal civil service by 42% since 2015. Last year, the feds signed a deal with the union leading the call to protest, the Public Service Alliance of Canada, giving them a pay increase. But here is the kicker: The deal both agreed on gave the federal government power to decide on back-to-office schedules. The same union that agreed to that is protesting it now.</p><p>There is no such thing as a permanent friend in politics, only permanent interests, but this is a classic stab in the front. Trudeau needs the public sector unions to win a federal election in the next year, and like Sunak he is nearly 20 points behind in the polls. He does not want to pick a fight with a powerfully motivated base. Except for one problem: This is a fight he can win because this is a fight the public supports.</p><p>In a new <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://angusreid.org/federal-government-remote-work-return-to-office-ottawa-business/">poll out today</a>, Angus Reid found that 50% of Canadians agree with the Federal government and want workers back in the office. Voters over age 55 — the kind who show up at polling stations – really can’t stand the union position, with 79% of them saying “get back to the office.”</p><p>Meanwhile, 28% of Canadians “view federal government employees as overpaid,” while 75% say federal workers “have better working conditions than others,” including 73% of Liberal voters. In other words, <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> could win this fight and would have the support of the electorate, but he needs every part of his base possible, so he is desperate to avoid this one as well.</p><p>The same is true for his main opponent, Conservative leader <strong>Pierre Poilievre</strong>. You might expect him to be taking huge swings at unions and entitlements as his goal is to cut the size of government, but he’s staying out of this one as much as he can. His own riding is in the Ottawa area, the ground zero of public servants, and he doesn’t want their ire turned on him, which could hurt his electoral chances and take the pressure off Trudeau. So who is afraid of public servants going back to work three days a week? Everyone.</p><p>Like Biden, who supports Israel’s fight against Hamas but is now losing the support of young voters, Trudeau has to be careful about the battles he picks. Since 2022, he has had a supply and confidence deal with the far-left NDP in order to remain in power. That means the public servants are core to his survival. Despite the polls, if the union folks do have a summer of discontent, Trudeau will be in the worst possible position for a politician: fighting a two-front battle, with Conservatives on the right and the union on the left.</p><p>Finally, a half note on tariffs, as Biden is also caught in a pincer move here. As Donald Trump pushes for more trade tariffs to protect American workers, (remember he put a 25% tariff on steel imports), Biden is keeping up the tariff pace, especially with ones directed at goods from China. This week, he announced tariffs on EVs, batteries, and other Chinese exports.</p><p>Protectionism is clearly good politics in the US, especially when it comes to China. That is as much about geopolitical rivalry and security as it is about economics, but in general, tariffs are self-defeating economics that lead to higher prices and inflation.</p><p>No amount of political hustling on talk shows is going to upend the logic of basic economics. Biden is jammed: On one hand, the average American believes things are worse than ever, but on the other they want him to stand up to China and protect the American worker. Does he risk higher prices and lingering inflation with more tariffs or does he risk alienating his labor base by pushing back against economic isolationism that is suddenly so faddish? For now, he is tiptoeing toward tariffs and trying to avoid the price blowback.</p><p>The summer of discontent for Biden and Trudeau is just getting started.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Does Palestine pass the state test?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/does-palestine-pass-the-state-test</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfpfl4jn9p07mytumk6tjq</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 16 May 2024 17:00:40 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>middle-east</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>united nations</category>
<category>hamas</category>
<category>israel</category>
<category>gaza</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Did Hamas score a big win at the United Nations, or was it actually a win for the much-maligned idea of the two-state solution? To find out, GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon turned to Canada’s Ambassador to the United Nations Bob Rae for answers.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrckt42c00b07my4wt6acqn" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrckt42c00b07my4wt6acqn" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Did Hamas score a big win at the United Nations, or was it actually a win for the much-maligned idea of the two-state solution?<br></p><p>Forgive yourself if you ignored the critical UN vote last week. Like the blaring horns on the streets of New York, many folks tune out the UN as meaningless background noise to the real action in global politics: sound and fury signifying bias. That is a mistake. The controversial May 9 vote on granting Palestine full membership to the UN bears real scrutiny. After all, in plain terms, the vote effectively means recognizing a Palestinian state.</p><p>The vote was supported by 143 of the 193 countries that make up the General Assembly – that’s more countries supporting this idea in 2024 than the last time something like this was voted on, back in 2012. Just seven months after the Oct. 7 Hamas terror attack on Israel, Palestine has won more support, not less. And Israel is more isolated, not less. Nine countries, including the US and Israel, voted no, but this next bit is telling: 25 countries, including Canada, abstained. This signals a major shift in Canadian policy, as it has historically voted “no” alongside the US.</p><p>What changed, and what exactly was the vote saying about who would represent the Palestine state if it was granted full status– the Palestinian Authority or Hamas? Can there be a Palestinian state with Hamas playing a role? Is the current Israeli government trying to kill the idea of a viable two-state solution?</p><p>To find out, I spoke with Canada’s Ambassador to the United Nations <strong>Bob Rae</strong>.</p><p><strong>Evan Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>Ambassador, 143 countries at the UN General Assembly just voted to grant Palestine full member status — essentially recognizing a Palestinian state. Canada was among the 25 countries that abstained, which is a change in policy from a hard “no.” Why the shift in policy?</p><p><strong>Ambassador Bob Rae:&nbsp;</strong>Largely because we think the situation on the ground is changing so fast. We wanted to make it clear that we still favor a two-state solution, but that we also recognize that it’s going to take a lot of work for that to happen. There’s going to have to be significant changes, frankly, on both sides to get there. Most dramatically on the side of Hamas, which continues to wage war after its Oct. 7 attack on Israel, and is not, by any means, defeated. We have to be clear that there can’t be a terrorist group in charge of a state. Israel will never accept the notion of a terrorist state being granted a status in international law, and we would never do it. The only way we can proceed is if that changes.</p><p>The other thing that needs to change is the policies that are currently being pursued by the Israelis in political terms, which is refusing to countenance the idea of two states coexisting.</p><p>The argument that we’ve always made in the past with this kind of resolution is to say, “No, we can’t support that, but we want to ensure that the parties will get back to the table, and that’s where things will get resolved.” But it's clear that at the moment, the current Israeli government has no intention of negotiating anything approaching sovereignty for Palestinians. So we don’t see how we can simply vote “no” anymore. We also don’t see how we can simply say “yes” either. We don’t think we can responsibly do that either. So that’s why we’ve taken the position we’ve taken.</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>Was this a position that was true before Oct. 7, or has it changed because of the attack and the aftermath?</p><p><strong>Rae:</strong> The feeling was that you had more of a discussion going on within Israel about the possibilities of two states. However, we know that Mr. Netanyahu has never been enthusiastic and never really admitted to the possibility of a Palestinian state, and now it’d become even clearer that’s not on the table.</p><p>On the other side, I do think that there has been, in the last 20 years, a strong endorsement of the two-state position by the Palestinian Authority leadership on the political side in the West Bank, but that has not been matched by Hamas. So that’s why we changed the position from 2012.</p><p><strong>Solomon:</strong> Back in 2012, only 138 countries voted for the resolution that upgraded the status of Palestine to a non-member observer state within the UN, but Canada voted against it. What does the increase of support tell you? Is this, essentially, a vote for the Hamas cause? Does this show that their horrifying terror attack was a strategic success?</p><p><strong>Rae:</strong> I don’t think so. I think that this whole “reward theory” is wrongheaded. The support in the General Assembly for two states is overwhelming. If you actually read the speeches of the countries that voted no, and the countries that voted to abstain, and the countries that voted yes, the support for two states was unanimous going from the United States and Hungary and other countries that voted no to the countries that abstained like us.</p><p><strong>Solomon:</strong> But you had countries voting yes, like Denmark, the Aussies, and New Zealanders. What does that say?</p><p><strong>Rae:&nbsp;</strong> I think it is a question of asking if a Palestinian state is prepared for membership in the United Nations. Canada looked at that question and we decided it doesn’t meet the test of what it means to be a state. The state is a place that has control over a territory, and the Palestinian Authority doesn't. Now, the Palestinians say, “Yeah, we haven’t been able to exercise control over the territory because of Israel.” And that's partly true. But it's also true to say now that they don't have control over the territory because of Hamas terrorism, which they have not been able to deal with effectively or to the extent that you can say, “This is a state that's ready to go.” The point is that there's real work to be done in the creation of two states, and we've still got to get there.</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>Did the vote at the UN signal that most countries are ready to recognize a Palestinian state, even if Hamas is part of the governing body?</p><p><strong>Rae:&nbsp;</strong>No, I don’t think that’s the case. I really don’t. What has to be very clear is that there's no room for a Hamas state at the UN. That’s something where there’s a very strong consensus.</p><p><strong>Solomon:</strong> But the vote doesn’t make that distinction.</p><p><strong>Rae:</strong> That’s why I say the decision on who gets admitted to the UN is not based on high hopes. It is based on what are the realities on the ground. We have to get real about it. That's where I think Canada is not alone. Many other countries feel the same way. The real work starts now with saying: How do you get to a cease-fire? How do you get to where you want to go, which is a two-state solution?</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>Is a two-state solution effectively dead?</p><p><strong>Rae:&nbsp;</strong>The trouble with that argument, Evan, is that you’ve got to then say, ok, if the two-state solution is dead, then what? When you look at the other alternatives, they don’t work either. For example, if you take a “river to the sea” approach, whether it's from a terrorist position or an Israeli perspective, that doesn't work. So it's really important for people to come to grips with the fact that the most fact-based, realistic solution has got to be based on the notion of two sovereign states living side by side in security and in peace. And, one hopes, eventually in partnership. It takes a long time to get there. But if you drop the idea of any possibility of sovereignty to realize Palestinian aspirations, then you've really abandoned all hope.</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>From the Netanyahu government point of view, the argument is that Hamas doesn’t even recognize Israel’s right to exist, and neither do many other countries in the region. So a two-state solution is, at best, a naive hope. At worst, a serious security risk.</p><p><strong>Rae:&nbsp;</strong>All that is part of the solution. That’s all part of what needs to happen. These things can change. We've seen things can change. It's all about building the basis for change. To rule it out entirely is a mistake.</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>Does Hamas, a listed terror group in Canada and the US, need to be destroyed, as Netanyahu argues, or can they evolve out of that status, and transition toward governance?</p><p><strong>Rae:&nbsp;</strong>No terrorist entity can become part of a state. That’s not possible. Can terrorist groups change? History points to some examples of that. The IRA, the African National Union, which was listed in many countries as a terrorist organization. It transformed itself. It changed. But the problem with Hamas — and it is in their charter — is that it is based on the obliteration of the state of Israel. That's not something that anybody can accept. It isn't good enough to say if this and if that. We can't get into too many hypotheticals. Right now Hamas' official policy is to obliterate the state of Israel. Israel is a sovereign state and a member of the United Nations, so while Canada has strong disagreements with the current policies of the current government, that's very different from saying that we are going to pretend that Hamas is not Hamas. I mean, that would be wrong.</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong> Neither Joe Biden nor Justin Trudeau gets on well with Benjamin Netanyahu. How isolated is this Israeli government right now?<br></p><p><strong>Rae:&nbsp;</strong>That’s a very important question. My own view is it’s not simply about Prime Minister Netanyahu or the state of Israel. Anybody with any degree of empathy would understand that the activities of Hamas – the sexual and gender atrocities, the atrocities on children and families, and the sheer brutality of the attacks on civilians – are unprecedented. It's been deeply traumatic for the Israeli people. So if you ask them, “How do you feel about two states?,” you can understand them saying, “For God's sake, don't talk to me about that until you've dealt with what we're dealing with.” You have to understand that the current disagreement that we have with Israel is not irreparable. It's not like we're stopping talking or engaging.</p><p>It’s important for everybody to be clearheaded about how we need to go forward and the work that’s involved. But any tactic or strategy that doesn't recognize the democratic rights of either the Israeli people or the Palestinian people is doomed to fail.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Stormy embarrassments about the wrong things</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/stormy-embarrassments-about-the-wrong-things</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfp2vhjlyj07mywd91mhdi</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 09 May 2024 17:28:54 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>stormy daniels</category>
<category>literacy</category>
<category>literacy rates</category>
<category>quayle</category>
<category>trump indictment</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>numeracy</category>
<category>michael cohen</category>
<category>trump trial</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Not everything needs to be said, especially by political leaders, but that doesn’t mean the public shouldn’t demand that leaders be embarrassed by their misconduct.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrck7wqcn6b07lqvy5m6hc6" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="800">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Jane Rosenberg</media:credit>
<media:text>Stormy Daniels is questioned by prosecutor Susan Hoffinger before Justice Juan Merchan during former President Donald Trump&apos;s criminal trial.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrck7wqcn6b07lqvy5m6hc6" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Of all the salaciously sloppy moments in <strong>Donald Trump’s</strong> hush-money trial unfolding just a short walk from GZERO HQ — and there are a lot – one stands out.</p><p>No, it’s not the anecdote about <strong>Stormy Daniels&nbsp;</strong>allegedly spanking Trump with a magazine — a detail that unintentionally evoked nostalgia for the fading benefits of print media. Try spanking a candidate with a digital edition!</p><p>No, it’s something far more modest. As the adult entertainer poured out presidential peccadillos about his penchant for satin pajamas, Trump’s lawyer declared that it all was so embarrassing that the jury was now prejudiced against his client. He demanded a mistrial.</p><p>State Supreme Court Justice <strong>Juan Merchan&nbsp;</strong>had to rule on the nature of embarrassment. What level is so harmful that it erodes the system, in this case, forcing a mistrial? In a sense, this is the core question of our confessional culture: Are there conventions of decorum that preserve human dignity and, if so, how do we adhere to them?</p><p>Merchan didn’t ponder this too long. He denied the mistrial but admitted that much of Daniels’ testimony was “better left unsaid.”</p><p>It was a cultural comment on the age of oversharing and a flimsy protest against the strategy that <strong>Steve Bannon</strong> once called “flooding the zone with shit,” but it warrants some attention. Would it help our political culture if some things were left unsaid, or are we actually leaving the most embarrassingly important things unsaid?</p><p>It was not lost on anyone that the judge presiding over a case about an adult film star, a president, and a tabloid catch-and-kill hush-money case is perhaps not in the best position to be setting standards of decorum inside the courtroom, let alone outside of it.</p><p>Justice <strong>Juan Merchan</strong> long ago lost control over <strong>Donald Trump’s</strong> conduct, reduced to threatening him with jail if the former president keeps speaking publicly about witnesses and the court. Trump has already been fined 10 times and doesn’t appear to give a gavel’s bang what Merchan says.</p><p>Does jail time scare Trump? Why would it? He’s already turned one mug shot into a fundraising tool. Jail time might be a campaign bonanza.</p><p>If there is one quality that the judge and jury take as a given, it’s that Trump is unembarrassable. Long before he defeated Hillary Clinton, he first had to defeat shame itself. And he has.</p><p>Caught on tape talking about grabbing women by the “p****,” he went on to win the election. Found guilty of sexually abusing E. Jean Carroll and forced to pay her over $83 million in punitive and compensatory damage, he’s now the front-runner in the 2024 campaign.</p><p>So it is not like details of this case will prejudice anyone, as the judge ruled. As Trump’s supporters like to say, they want him as their president, not their priest. He’s not the first. Bill Clinton – whose supporters try to forget the blue dress and the cigar – didn’t exactly elevate the office with his behavior, but he remains a powerful political force.</p><p>Back in 1992, while visiting some grade six schoolkids in New Jersey for a spelling bee, then Vice President Dan Quayle misspelled the word <em>potato</em>, adding a fateful “e” to the end. That tiny goof ended his political career. He was dubbed a dummy and that was it. Imagine a time when making a simple spelling error was enough to disqualify you from the presidency.</p><p>Quayle was embarrassed by it, but, more remarkably, the country was embarrassed that a veep couldn’t spell a basic word. They wanted a leader who was better, and who embodied the standards and ideals the country promises to live up to. That’s the hope that renews the sordid, shabby political process we call democracy and what all great leaders tap into. They are embarrassed <em>not</em> to be better.</p><p>This all sounds pretty naïve right now. This week, South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem is trying to burnish her bona fides as a potential running mate for Trump. She published a book called “No Going Back,” in which she describes gunning down her 14-month-old puppy, a wirehair pointer named Cricket. Poor Cricket had an “aggressive personality” and had allegedly killed some chickens. So the guv took Cricket to a gravel pit and shot him.</p><p>Later that day, she also shot a mean old goat.</p><p>Noem admits in the book that “if I were a better politician, I wouldn’t tell the story here.” True. Some things, like shooting your puppy, are better left unsaid. And undone. But she is far from embarrassed. While her book also includes a blatant lie about meeting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, Noem presses ever onward. Judging by the number of talk show appearances, the book is just as likely to sink her politically as it is to turn her into a national figure, a victim of the woke left condemning a hard-nosed politician with a penchant for shooting pets. The shamelessness is breathtaking.</p><p>This is not a defense of some old school culture of shame, which has led to much misery for generations of marginalized groups like the LGBTQ community, and people with mental health or addictions. Their lives, identities, and struggles have been pushed into the dark for fear of being shamed and it still happens today, where suicide rates among LGBTQ kids run rampant. Speaking out and saying the once unspeakable is one of the great cultural advances of modernity.</p><p>But that doesn’t mean <em>everything</em> needs to be said, especially by political leaders, and it also doesn’t mean the public shouldn’t demand that leaders be embarrassed by their misconduct.</p><p>Apologize. Get help. Resign. Don’t run again. Leaders caught in embarrassing moments have options that can lead to wider cultural benefits like raising standards and enforcing accountability. Not every playbook needs to be about pushing through the noise, blaming others, declaring yourself the victim, and generally transforming all politics into a social media campaign for clout and clicks.</p><p>But this is all a tired culture war, isn’t it? The truth is, the most embarrassing things about our culture all too often remain unsaid. Let’s go back to poor Dan Quayle for a moment and his inability to spell. Instead of making it a forgotten political joke, it actually opens a space to talk about something truly shameful: literacy rates.</p><p>One in five American adults, or 43 million Americans, are <a target="_blank" href="https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2019/2019179/index.asp"><u>functionally illiterate</u></a>. They cannot complete a basic test designed to measure “the ability to understand, evaluate, use and engage with written texts.”<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2019/2019179/index.asp"></a></p><p>Over half of US adults have a literacy rate below the sixth-grade level, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.thenationalliteracyinstitute.com/post/literacy-statistics-2022-2023"><u>according to the National Literacy Institute</u></a>. If you think education is expensive, the cost of not educating kids is higher. Three-quarters of people on welfare can’t read, while kids who drop out of school end up costing society over $40 billion a year in social services and lost tax dollars. Numeracy rates are even lower.</p><p>Has this stuff been mentioned on the campaign trail? I must have missed it.</p><p>I think one reason no one talks about things like literacy is that it’s just too embarrassing to admit that, in the richest countries in the world, literary rates are so low. Talking about a president's sex life is now normal, but when it comes to reading and writing … it seems that’s better left unsaid.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>From mission creep to political creep</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/from-mission-creep-to-political-creep</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfor08kcbo07lqu5ztclu4</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 02 May 2024 18:22:15 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>israel-hamas war</category>
<category>protests</category>
<category>mission creep</category>
<category>protest creep</category>
<category>us campuses</category>
<category>columbia</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>What started as a reaction to the Hamas-orchestrated massacre of Oct. 7 and the extent of the deadly counteroffensive by the Israeli military has now grown to encompass wider, more amorphous issues, writes GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcjp6lcm2k07lqkx48o0yi" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="676">
<media:credit>Reuters</media:credit>
<media:text>Pro-Palestinian protesters clash with law enforcement as officials clear demonstrator encampments on UCLA&apos;s campus on May 2, 2024 in Los Angeles, CA.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcjp6lcm2k07lqkx48o0yi" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Early today, police in riot gear moved against protest encampments at UCLA, taking down tents, arresting people, and removing demonstrators from campus. This came after similar actions on campuses ranging from Columbia to Dartmouth.</p><p>Where is this headed?</p><p>What started as a reaction to the Hamas-orchestrated massacre of Oct. 7 and the extent of the deadly counteroffensive by the Israeli military has now grown to encompass wider, more amorphous issues. These include everything from the validity of Zionism to the viability of a two-state solution and now, depending on where you go, climate justice, over-militarized policing, and even capitalism itself.</p><p>In the military, this would be called mission creep. That’s when a mission starts with a specific goal, but over time the scope widens so much that the initial objective is lost and the new goals become too complex to be attainable. This usually ends in failure.</p><p>“Mission creep” was coined by a Washington Post columnist in 1993 to describe the disastrous American-supported UN intervention in Somalia — the famous Black Hawk Down incident in which 18 US service members were killed. It became more prominent after 9/11 when the initial objective of wiping out al-Qaida spread into overthrowing Saddam Hussein and the Taliban, which morphed again into the idea of setting up stable democracies in Afghanistan and Iraq. Mission creep is a trap, setting impossible goals that erase the possibility of an exit strategy.</p><p>This is starting to happen with the campus protests as well. It’s not mission creep exactly. Call it protest creep – where the scope of subjects now being debated is so vast that it is starting to undermine the very real issues the demonstrators wanted to bring to light.</p><figure><img src="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvr9i40d6ui007lqbcwh3aiv" alt="from-mission-creep-to-political-creep-52163549.png" width="1200" height="880"><figcaption>Protests are spreading to campuses throughout the US and to a few schools in\u00a0Canada. Credit: Luisa Vieira</figcaption></figure><p>Protests are spreading to campuses throughout the US and to a few schools in Canada.Luisa Vieira</p><p>Whatever position you hold, the right to ask uncomfortable questions about Hamas’s attack or about Israel’s response is what a democracy is all about. Is the Israeli invasion of Gaza a justified response to a terror group’s massacre, as some say, or has it morphed into a genocidal war on Palestinians, as others argue?</p><p>Should universities boycott, sanction, and divest from any company doing business with Israel or support the defeat of a genocidal terror group like Hamas? These questions rightly evoke passionate responses and make some people feel uncomfortable. Of course they do. But democracies are not built to protect people from feeling uncomfortable; they are built to protect individual and collective civil liberties. Being exposed to and living with ideas you disagree with is the foundation of an open society – and frankly, one of the purposes of going to university in the first place.</p><p>That doesn’t mean there should be no red lines. For example, the space between support for the people of Gaza and criticism of Israel’s response has moved into a full debate about Zionism itself – and whether anti-Zionism is a form of antisemitism. On April 26, the office of the president of Columbia University <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://president.columbia.edu/news/statement-david-greenwald-claire-shipman-minouche-shafik-and-angela-olinto">issued a letter</a> acknowledging “the antisemitism being expressed by some individuals,” going on to say, “Chants, signs, taunts, and social media posts from our own students that mock and threaten to ‘kill’ Jewish people are totally unacceptable, and Columbia students who are involved in such incidents will be held accountable.”</p><p>Some students have pushed back, arguing that most demonstrations are not antisemitic and that their views are being willfully mischaracterized by some politicians who are cherry-picking bad moments to justify a heavy-handed police response to peaceful protests about the Palestinian people.</p><p>It’s naïve to pretend that political manipulation is not a factor here, and much of this is also <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/how-campus-protests-in-the-south-could-foreshadow-the-2024-election"><u>being filtered</u></a> by the US presidential campaign. But it’s also naive to suggest that there’s not a disturbing element of dynamics like anti-semitism as well. But that’s not what protest creep is about.</p><p>As Jeremy Peters<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/01/us/pro-palestinian-college-protests.html?campaign_id=9&amp;emc=edit_nn_20240502&amp;instance_id=122128&amp;nl=the-morning&amp;regi_id=91113034&amp;segment_id=165401&amp;te=1&amp;user_id=085e47f7a4165ed572c6d726f29d26f1"> wrote</a> in the New York Times, many student demonstrators are not only motivated by the events in Gaza, but have linked those to “policing, mistreatment of Indigenous people, discrimination toward Black Americans, and the impact of global warming.”</p><p>It’s not surprising to see acts of solidarity among groups, but is it helpful? What about when the protests veer into issues like Zionism itself? If the debate is now so wide that it includes asking if Israel has a right to exist as a Jewish state–and that is common–should there be debates around the right of Muslim countries, theocracies, or kingdoms to exist? Will there be debates about Jordan’s right to exist, a country carved out of the British mandate in 1946, two years before Israel was founded? What about countries like Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Syria, or others whose lines were randomly drawn on a map by Western governments after the war?</p><p>These are interesting questions, but are they helpful for the current crisis? At best, they force an endless regression into debates about settlers and nationalism – questions that have no simple answers. At worst, they suggest a double standard of morality and accountability.</p><p>Canada, the US, and Australia, for example, all struggle to find answers to painful and real questions about Indigenous rights and land claims, but outside of some basic sense of solidarity, is blending these with the crisis in Gaza useful? Do these debates bring clarity, or is the chaos today being used opportunistically by some radical elements to amplify any cause?</p><p>Finally, who is responsible for protest creep? Part of it lies with the media for using loose terms to lump disparate groups together and blurring messages so nuanced distinctions get lost. Part of it lies with the protesters, who are caught in their own momentum and are losing control of the narrative. And lastly, part lies with the politicians and the authorities, who label groups and torque up fears to bolster their agendas. It’s a mess, and it looks like there is no way out.</p><p>No way out.</p><p>That’s always the problem with mission creep – and now with protest creep. There’s no exit strategy. The aims become so big, so endless, that the whole idea of a peaceful, practical solution is lost. The fight itself has become the whole point.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Slogans of war</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/slogans-of-war</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfoejlkay507lqyvk7dgms</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 25 Apr 2024 18:08:51 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>pro-palestinian</category>
<category>columbia university</category>
<category>protests</category>
<category>israel</category>
<category>palestine</category>
<category>middle-east</category>
<category>free speech</category>
<category>benjamin netanyahu</category>
<category>pro-israel</category>
<category>Analysis</category>
<description>Of the many complex, painful issues contributing to the tension stemming from the Oct. 7 Hamas massacre and the ongoing Israeli attacks in Gaza, dividing groups into two basic camps, pro-Israel and pro-Palestine, is only making this worse. GZERO Publisher Evan Solomon explains the need to solve this category problem.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcj5kobwr007myne4epuob" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="729">
<media:credit>Alex Kliment</media:credit>
<media:text>Flags from across the divide wave in the air over protests at Columbia University on Thursday, April 25, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcj5kobwr007myne4epuob" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Where do we draw the line between free speech and a safe space? That’s the core question posed by the protests and the arrests raging on campuses right now over the Hamas-Israel war.<br></p><p>Of the many complex, painful issues contributing to the tension stemming from the Oct. 7 Hamas massacre and the ongoing Israeli attacks in Gaza, dividing groups into two basic camps, pro-Israel and pro-Palestine, is only making this worse. Call it a category problem.</p><p>What do these terms, pro-Israel and pro-Palestinian, even mean? Are they helpful, or is it time to stop using them altogether?</p><p>The fundamental flaw with these terms is that they conflate support for the existence of a country with support for the government or leaders in power. For example, does pro-Israel mean support for the existence of the state of Israel, or for the policies of the current government? They are wildly different things.</p><p>Before Oct. 7, there were already massive rallies against <strong>Benjamin Netanyahu’s</strong> government, and they have only grown louder. Are the people protesting him anti-Israel? Of course not. Patriotism and partisanship are not always the same thing. The same person who supports the right of Israel to exist – and may even fight for Israel against a group like Hamas – might just as well protest the Likud government, support a two-state solution, and want a cease-fire in Gaza. Read the popular Israeli newspaper Ha’aretz and see the diverse views and critical opinions on Israeli policy.</p><p>The same is true for the Palestinian cause. Supporting a viable, safe, prosperous Palestinian state is the normative position of most governments around the world, but that does not mean supporting the murderous agenda of Hamas, which is listed as a terrorist organization in Canada and the US. Palestinians and millions of others who are deeply furious at the Israeli actions in Gaza and Netanyahu’s policies should not necessarily be equated with supporting Hamas and their eliminationist goals. Are you anti-Palestinian if you do not support Hamas? Of course not.</p><p>The same is true anywhere. No one asks if you are, say, pro-France, pro-Italy, pro-Canada, or pro-America when they are debating a specific policy. Instead, they ask if you support a particular position or action of the government in power. Reducing this to a conflict about the right to exist as a country – for Israel or Palestine – is a road to endless war. Making this, as it ought to be, about a conflict of policy and leadership – however deadly it is right now – is the path toward resolution.</p><p>With the war in Gaza raging, it is understandable that people are being forced to take a side: Are you pro-Israel or pro-Palestinian? That gives the patina of a firm moral stance, but it plays into the hands of the most radical forces on both sides who strategically want to co-opt the reasonable middle ground for their own purposes.</p><p>Among the great propaganda victories of this war are the Hamasification of the Palestinian cause on one side and the Netanyahuization of the Israeli voices on the other (and no, this is not meant to make a false equivalence between the two, but simply to describe the political dynamics).</p><p>That’s why you see, say, signs supporting Hamas on campuses and chants that celebrate Oct. 7. That’s why there is a rise in antisemitism or, on the other side, a refusal in some places to acknowledge the deaths and suffering of the people of Gaza.</p><p>The category problem supports this dynamic and undermines the rational middle ground where, for generations, there has been a genuine if fruitless effort to find a peaceful two-state solution. It is now parodied as a sinkhole of mushy naivete, offensive bothsidesism, and false equivalencies, and protesters and their slogans shout it down. But it remains the only hope.</p><p>There isn’t a lot people can do in the face of such a long-standing bloody conflict – though joining protests is certainly one thing. But perhaps adhering to the middle ground and avoiding the broad categories that help radicals on each side is a small but effective action.</p><p>You might think that the one place you’d find this middle ground would be on university campuses, where details, nuance, and debate are supposed to thrive. That’s not happening. On many campuses today, it is now impossible to distinguish between free speech and safe space.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Biden and Trudeau: A political eclipse?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/biden-and-trudeau-a-political-eclipse</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfnni8jgqp07mytx23k7zz</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 11 Apr 2024 17:05:02 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>pierre poilievre</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>eclipse</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Why are Joe Biden and Justin Trudeau getting so badly eclipsed by the great totality of critics? Can good policies seize back the agenda of a lagging campaign?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrchzoccias07lqvffnihfx" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrchzoccias07lqvffnihfx" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why are <strong>Joe Biden</strong> and <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> getting so badly eclipsed by the great totality of critics? Can good policies seize back the agenda of a lagging campaign?<br></p><p>President Biden is busy touting his positive economic record but is baffled when it gets eclipsed by issues like his age. He rightly touts creating 300,000 new jobs in March and dropping the unemployment rate to 3.8%, but the headlines still say he looks like a guy who might as well have watched a solar eclipse alongside Moses.</p><p>Want to brag about the bullish stock market? Biden could, but that’s overshadowed by news this week about stubbornly high prices on gas, rent, and groceries. Want to shed some light on an economic recovery? Nice try. Word that the Fed may delay rate cuts clouds it over. How about projecting US strength in the world and containing a wider war with Iran, which the US has been doing? That’s undermined by the Hamas-Israel war and the casualties in Gaza that the US appears to have little influence over.</p><p>Meanwhile, every day <strong>Donald Trump</strong> does something so astronomically weird – selling golden shoes or hawking mash-up Constitution-Bibles – that all political telescopes end up turning his way first. So all that good economic result and that big fundraising advantage, so far, has not done much for Biden.</p><p>In Canada, Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> is also having trouble staying unblocked. After eight long years in office, you now need to consult with Stephen Hawking on black holes to figure out if any light can escape from the event horizon of the Liberal campaign. This morning,<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://abacusdata.ca/conservative-open-up-largest-lead-yet/"> <u>Abacus Data released a poll</u></a> showing the Conservative Party is 20 points ahead of the Liberals, the highest ever.</p><p>That kind of polling eulogy is why Mr. Trudeau is hemorrhaging leaks about his upcoming April 16 federal budget in order to recapture the penumbra of popularity he had when he was first elected. Can these new shiny programs do the trick?</p><ul><li>On April 1 came the CA$1 billion national school food program to ensure over 400,000 kids get school meals annually over the next five years.</li><li>Then came the new national defense policy, “Our North, Strong and Free,” which focuses on Arctic and cyber security, increasing spending by <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.canada.ca/en/department-national-defence/news/2024/04/our-north-strong-and-free-a-renewed-vision-for-canadas-defence.html"><u>CA$8.1 billion</u></a> over the next five years, which will push Canada’s spending up to 1.76% of GDP. It’s not quite at the NATO prenup agreement of 2%, but closer.</li><li>There is another CA$1.5 billion for a new <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canada-rental-protection-fund-1.7163429"><u>Canada Rental Protection Fund</u></a> to spur more affordable housing and rental units and then, boom, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://halifax.citynews.ca/2024/04/05/trudeau-announces-600-million-in-loans-funding-to-jump-start-homebuilding-rentals/"><u>another</u></a> $600 million in loans and funds to help new owners and renters.</li><li>Oh yes, and CA$2.4 billion for the AI industry to make sure Canada doesn’t take the Large Language Model hit on the chin.</li></ul><p>Has it worked? Have the giant budget leaks reframed the Trudeau government’s political fortunes? And more broadly for any government, can new ideas actually change political fortunes?</p><p>So far, the evidence is scant. The Abacus poll actually asked the question, “do budgets move votes?” and used the national school food program as a case study. Turns out, most folks didn’t even know about it yet. “Less than half of Canadians were aware of the program announcement” and worse, “parents with kids aged 3 to 14 years of age were actually <em>less</em> likely to be aware of the announcement (41%) than everyone else.”</p><p>What does that tell us? That no one is listening to Trudeau – that he’s being tuned out? Or is it more that the media is so fragmented that it takes more time to sell programs these days? Or, maybe that program got drowned out by the other four or five other announcements that spilled out.</p><p>Instead of selling voters on one big, new idea to frame the election, Trudeau has set out a smorgasbord of bureaucratic bonanzas with no central theme. Restaurants that serve buffets rarely get Michelin stars.</p><p>But here is where the political eclipse gets really weird: The programs being pitched by the Liberal leader … are extremely popular, even with people who oppose Trudeau.</p><p>“68% of current Conservative supporters think [the national school food program] is a good or acceptable idea,” according to the Abacus poll. And even stranger, “2 in 3 of those who have a very negative impression of Justin Trudeau think it's a good idea.”</p><p>That means even if you have ideas people really like, sometimes it will not change voter intention. “It is like the Prime Minister is a shepherd with no flock,” Abacus CEO <strong>David Coletto</strong> told me. Biden has the same issue. Even though the economic numbers are good, the narrative frame of negativity is hard to shatter.</p><p>That doesn’t mean that opposition leaders – <strong>Pierre Poilievre</strong> or <strong>Donald Trump</strong> – have a lock on winning. There is lots of time ahead, and campaigns matter. Trump will have to do more than be a vindictive doomsayer campaigning as the Count of Counterfactuals (“none of these terrible events would have happened if I were President!!!,”<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/108589511889733302"> <u>he says</u></a> of inflation and the war in Ukraine, claims which are, of course unprovable), and Poilievre might have to get off Mean Street and move to Main Street. But at least people are listening to them.</p><p>Politicians think if people look directly at their records, they will see something truly beautiful. But it turns out that direct scrutiny often blinds the electorate to their message, and voters either turn away or grab a set of glasses the opposition conveniently gives them in order to change their view.</p><p>And that’s why a political eclipse is so fascinating: When even the best policies, the ones people really like, no longer illuminate the way, it’s hard to know which way to look.</p><p><em>– Evan Solomon, Publisher</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Secret sauce of the boom: immigration</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/secret-sauce-of-the-boom-immigration</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfn810jfg807mym8k2q1i3</guid>
<pubDate>Fri, 05 Apr 2024 00:59:11 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>economic performance</category>
<category>democrats</category>
<category>2024 presidential election</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>economy</category>
<category>republicans</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Is the economy broken, or is it booming? And is there a secret accelerant no elected official wants to talk about?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcf089cbsv07lqf98p5krl" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Jess Frampton</media:credit>
<media:text>Joe Biden and Donald Trump</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcf089cbsv07lqf98p5krl" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The riddle of recovery: Is the economy broken, or is it booming? And is there a secret accelerant no elected official wants to talk about?<br></p><p>Turns out, how folks perceive the economy is often tied more closely to how they vote than to reality. <strong>Donald Trump's</strong> supporters argue the economy is a disaster of debt and inflation, made worse by an immigration nightmare playing out at the borders. To prove their case, they wander into the Cherry Orchard of Convenient Stats and pick a few choice numbers to make their case.</p><ul><li>US debt has passed $34 trillion and will exceed the dangerous 99% debt-to-GDP ratio.</li><li>Between 60%-78% of US <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.forbes.com/advisor/banking/living-paycheck-to-paycheck-statistics-2024/">households</a> are living paycheck to paycheck, depending on the survey.</li><li>Credit card debt has hit record levels, with 50% of <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2024/03/10/credit-card-debt-swamps-savings/72894537007/">consumers unable</a> to pay off their monthly bills.</li><li>Food prices are going up even as inflation is down, rising over 2.2% from last year, <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/finance/price-of-food#:~:text=Food%20prices%20%E2%80%94%20which%20includes%20both,one-year%20period%20in%202023.">according</a> to the Consumer Price Index.</li><li>Big layoffs are hitting the tech, financial, retail, media, and energy sectors.</li><li>Home affordability: Most people with an average income can no longer afford a home, which in most cities now requires an income of over $100,000.</li></ul><ul></ul><p>The harvest from that side looks rotten. But walk over to the <strong>Joe Biden</strong> side of the Cherry Orchard of Convenient Stats, and things look pretty darn good:</p><ul><li>Post-pandemic, the US has been the fastest-growing economy in the G7.</li><li>Job growth is shattering expectations with over <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.wsj.com/economy/jobs/jobs-report-january-today-unemployment-economy-4f3a772e">353,000 jobs</a> in January, and unemployment is <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.google.com/search?q=us+unemployment+rate&amp;rlz=1C5GCEA_enUS1104US1104&amp;oq=US+unem&amp;gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUqCggAEAAYsQMYgAQyCggAEAAYsQMYgAQyDQgBEAAYgwEYsQMYgAQyBggCEEUYOTIHCAMQABiABDIHCAQQABiABDIHCAUQABiABDIHCAYQABiABDIHCAcQABiABDIGCAgQABgDMgcICRAAGIAEqAIAsAIB&amp;sourceid=chrome&amp;ie=UTF-8">under 4%</a>.</li><li>Inflation has <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/current-inflation-rates/">fallen</a> to 3.2% from over 9% two years ago.</li><li>Real wage growth is way up.</li><li>The stock market is on a bull run.</li></ul><p>Overall, it’s a pretty tasty harvest, if that’s all you pick.</p><p>Still, Gallup’s famed <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/642692/march-economic-confidence-steady-improved-fall.aspx">Economic Confidence Index</a> – though ticking up a bit last month – is shockingly negative, revealing most Americans think things are bad. So consumers are doing boom-like things, like spending, while perceiving bust-like things – and complaining.</p><p>Plenty has been written about the lens of partisanship distorting economic reality: People believe the economy is bad, just not for THEM! “It’s now a well-established fact that partisan orientation affects expressed views about the economy,” economist Paul Krugman <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/14/opinion/partisanship-economy-polling.html?searchResultPosition=1">wrote</a> in the New York Times. “Democrats are more positive when a Democrat holds the White House; Republicans are more positive when the president is a Republican … but the partisan effect on sentiment is two and a half times as large for Republicans as it is for Democrats.” Krugman argues that this so-called “asymmetric amplification” accounts for 30% of the “gap between economic sentiment and economic fundamentals.”</p><p>There is, however, a reality that should not be wiped aside: The post-pandemic recovery for some has not been post-pandemic recovery for all. “I think the old name for this was ‘K-shaped recovery,’ the idea that different parts of the country are experiencing vastly different conditions,” <strong>Robert Kahn</strong>, the global head of macrogeoeconomics at Eurasia Group, told me. “Rising numbers living paycheck to paycheck or getting squeezed by high debt. Conversely, many still cash flush from pandemic support/policies.”</p><p>The K-shaped recovery also means that while, say, the stock market is booming, there are painful layoffs in sectors across the economy, like tech, finance, media, and retail. When Nike is slashing $2 billion dollars, people start to notice.</p><p>Sure, some of this is a correction from over-hiring in recent years, and some might be the impact of AI, but combine that with debt levels, worries about commercial real estate, and layoffs, and you see this could be a ... Special-K kind of recovery. There is a lot of optimistic froth covering some big pain points.</p><p>But there is a deeply inconvenient political truth here: Things would be much worse for everyone without the single most controversial, politically radioactive issue: immigration.</p><p>Trump is making his entire campaign about immigration, and his fiery rhetoric about it – he recently called illegal immigrants “<a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-expected-highlight-murder-michigan-woman-immigration-speech-2024-04-02/">animals</a>” – is now a staple. So he is not about to discuss the benefits of immigration.</p><p>Even in Canada, Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong>, who has presided over massive increases in immigration levels, is now saying temporary immigration – foreign workers and international students – needs to be brought “under control.” This week he admitted it has “grown at a rate far beyond what Canada has been able to absorb.” Okay…</p><p>The thing is, immigration likely saved the economy and continues to do so. “The US let in about 3 million additional people last year,” my colleague <strong>Jon Lieber</strong>, head of research at EG, told me. “That puts downward pressure on wages and is a source of new consumer spending. There are some economists who attribute the continuing strength of the American economy to this factor.”</p><p>To dig deeper – and what GZERO reader doesn’t like to dig deeper? – it’s worth checking out the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.briefingbook.info/p/immigration-and-the-us-economy-since">analysis</a> done by <strong>Ernie Tedeschi</strong>, the former chief economist for the White House Council of Economic Advisers. “Immigration since the pandemic has strongly bolstered US labor supply and employment,” Tedeschi wrote. “The US economy is 8.2% larger in inflation-adjusted terms than just before the pandemic. Of this, 1.6 percentage points – about a fifth of US post-2019 growth – can be accounted for directly by foreign-born workers.”</p><p>Well, that isn’t something you hear about very much on the campaign trail. Immigration is the super-charge factor of the economy? “Politically, this is pretty ironic,” says Lieber, “if the immigration crisis that is weighing on Biden’s approval rating is actually saving the US economy.”</p><p>Is it naïve to think that citizens could one day turn to their politicians to get the facts straight about the economy – or admit that some of the very things they are demonizing and running against are the things that are boosting the economy and saving their political hides?</p><p>That’s likely the biggest riddle of this recovery story.</p><ul></ul><p><em>– Evan Solomon, Publisher</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Are US elections Safe? Chris Krebs is optimistic</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/are-us-elections-safe-chris-krebs-is-optimistic</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfmxw9jeej07my4t32ok15</guid>
<pubDate>Sun, 31 Mar 2024 18:15:51 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>politics</category>
<category>science-tech</category>
<category>chris krebs</category>
<category>technology</category>
<category>interview</category>
<category>economy</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>china</category>
<category>cybersecurity</category>
<category>espionage</category>
<category>russia</category>
<category>ukraine</category>
<category>ai</category>
<category>misinformation</category>
<category>Analysis</category>
<description>The debate around the US banning TikTok is a proxy for a larger question: How safe are democracies from high-tech threats, especially from places like China and Russia?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcgsvxbry907mykq8gqye6" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="676" />
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcgsvxbry907mykq8gqye6" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The debate around the US banning TikTok is a proxy for a larger question: How safe are democracies from high-tech threats, especially from places like China and Russia?</p><p>There are genuine concerns about the integrity of elections. What are the threats out there and what can be done about it? No one understands this issue better than <strong>Chris Krebs</strong>. Krebs is best known as the former director of the US Department of Homeland Security’s Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency.</p><p>In a high-profile showdown, <strong>Donald Trump</strong> fired Krebs in November 2020, after CISA publicly affirmed that the election was among the “most secure in history” and that the allegations of election corruption were flat-out wrong. Since then, Krebs has become the chief public policy officer at SentinelOne and cochairs the Aspen Institute’s U.S. Cybersecurity Working Group, and he remains at the forefront of the cyber threat world.</p><p>GZERO Publisher <strong>Evan Solomon</strong> spoke to him this week about what we should expect in this volatile election year.</p><p><strong>Solomon:</strong> How would you compare the cyber threat landscape now to the election four years ago? Have the rapid advances in AI made a material difference?</p><p><strong>Chris Krebs:&nbsp;</strong>The general threat environment related to elections tracks against the broader cyber threat environment. The difference here is that beyond just pure technical attacks on election systems, election infrastructure, and on campaigns themselves, we have a parallel threat of information operations, and influence operations —what we more broadly call disinformation.</p><p>This has picked up almost exponentially since 2016, when the Russians, as detailed in the Intelligence Community Assessment of January 2017, showed that you can get into the middle of domestic elections and pour kerosene on that conversation. That means it jumps into the real world, potentially even culminating in political violence like we saw on Jan. 6.</p><p>We saw the Iranians follow the lead in 2020. The intelligence community released another report in December that talked about how the Chinese attempted to influence the 2022 elections. We've seen the Russians are active too through a group we track called Doppelganger, specifically targeting the debate around the border and immigration in the US.</p><p><strong>Solomon:&nbsp;</strong>When you say Doppelganger is “active,” what exactly does that mean in real terms?</p><p><strong>Krebs:&nbsp;</strong>They use synthetic personas or take over existing personas that have some element of credibility and jump into the online discourse. They also use Pink Slime websites, which is basically fake media, and then get picked up through social media and move over to traditional media. They are taking existing divides and amplifying the discontent.</p><p><strong>Solomon:</strong> Does it have a material impact on, say, election results?</p><p><strong>Krebs:&nbsp;</strong>I was at an event back in 2019, and a former governor came up to me as we were talking about prepping for the 2020 election and said: “Hey, everything you just talked about sounds like opposition research, typical electioneering, and hijinks.”</p><p>And you know what? That's not totally wrong. But there is a difference.</p><p>Rather than just being normal domestic politics, now we have a foreign security service that's inserting itself in driving discourse domestically. And that's where there are tools that the intelligence services here in the US as well as our allies in the West have the ability to go in and disrupt.</p><p>They can get onto foreign networks and say, “Hey, I know that account right there. I am able to determine that the account which is pushing this narrative is controlled by the Russian security services, and we can do something with that.”</p><p>But here is the key: Once you have a social media influencer here in the US that picks up that narrative and runs with it, well, now, it's effectively fair game. It's part of the conversation, First Amendment protected.</p><p><strong>Solomon: Let's move to the other side. What do you do about it without violating the privacy and free speech civil liberties of citizens?</strong></p><p><strong>Krebs:</strong> This is really the political question of the day. In fact, just last week there was a Supreme Court hearing on Murthy v. Missouri that gets to this question of government and platforms working together. <em>(Editor’s note: The case hinges on whether the government’s efforts to combat misinformation online around elections and COVID constitute a form of censorship).</em> Based on my read, the Supreme Court was largely being dismissive of Missouri and Louisiana's arguments in that case. But we'll see what happens.</p><p>I think the bigger issue is that there is this broader conflict, particularly with China, and it is a hot cyber war. Cyber war from their military doctrine has a technical leg and there's a psychological leg. And as we see it, there are a number of different approaches.</p><p>For example, India has outlawed and banned hundreds of Chinese origin apps, including WeChat and TikTok and a few others. The US has been much more discreet in combating Chinese technology. The recent actions by the US Congress and the House of Representatives are much more focused on getting the foreign control piece out of the conversation and requiring divestitures.</p><p><strong>Solomon: Chris, what’s the biggest cyber threat to the elections?</strong></p><p><strong>Krebs:</strong> Based on my conversations with law enforcement and the national security community, the number one request that they're getting from election officials isn't on the cyber side. It isn't on the disinformation side. It's on physical threats to election workers. We're talking about doxing, we're talking about swatting, we're talking about people physically intimidating at the polls and at offices. And this is resulting in election officials resigning and quitting and not showing up.</p><p>How do we protect those real American heroes who are making sure that we get to follow through on our civic duty of voting and elections? If those election workers aren't there, it's going to be a lot harder for you and me to get out there and vote.</p><p><strong>Solomon: What is your biggest concern about AI technology galloping ahead of regulations?</strong></p><p><strong>Krebs:</strong> Here in the United States, I'm not too worried about regulation getting in front of AI. When you look at the recent AI executive order out of the Biden administration, it's about transparency and even the threshold they set for compute power and operations is about four times higher than the most advanced publicly available generative AI. And even if you cross that threshold, the most you have to do is tell the government that you're building or training that model and show safety and red teaming results, which hardly seems onerous to me.</p><p>The Europeans are taking a different approach, more of a regulate first, ask questions later, which I think is going to limit some of their ability to truly be at the bleeding edge of AI.</p><p>But I'll tell you this: We are using AI and cybersecurity to a much greater effect and impact than the bad guys right now. The best they can do right now is use it for social engineering, for writing better phishing emails, for some research, and for functionality. We are not seeing credible reports of AI being used to write new innovative malware. But in the meantime, we are giving tools that are AI powered to the threat hunters that have really advanced capabilities to go find bad stuff, to improve configurations, and ultimately take the security operations piece and supercharge it.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Preparing for Trump 2.0</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/2667628423</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfmwj2k64207lqq18toxw5</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 28 Mar 2024 20:12:32 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>canada</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Alongside dealing with inflation, war, AI and hyper-polarizing politics — a full cart of problems already — every US ally and opponent are also busily drawing up their Preparing For Trump (PFT) playbook.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcgr4gcftv07lqvoq95lgx" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Marco Bello</media:credit>
<media:text>Former President Donald Trump attends the 2024 Senior Club Championship award ceremony at his Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida, March 24, 2024.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcgr4gcftv07lqvoq95lgx" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Alongside dealing with inflation, war, AI and hyper-polarizing politics — a full cart of problems already — every US ally and opponent are also busily drawing up their Preparing For Trump (PFT) playbook. What happens if Trump 2.0 cancels trade deals? What if he pulls out of NATO? Will he use nuclear bombs? Will US isolationism cede global influence to China and Russia? Could reliable, prosperous, long-standing alliances and treaties… collapse?</p><p>This week, a colleague and I had an interesting meeting with a senior Canadian minister and PFT was the main topic. Of all countries, Canada has one of the most successful past playbooks, based on the successful renegotiation of the NAFTA deal in <strong>Donald Trump</strong>’s first term. Remember that gilded time, in 2017, when <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong> had a hot political minute playing the role of “Trump Whisperer”? His Team Canada, backed by another Trump Whisperer — former Prime Minister <strong>Brian Mulroney</strong>, who sadly just passed away — poured their maple syrup charms up and down the Beltway and it worked. But here’s the question: Is that playbook still relevant?</p><p>The short answer? No.</p><p>First off, the Trudeau and Trump bromance ended in ashes. By 2018, at the G7 summit in Canada, Trump was calling Trudeau “very dishonest and weak.” A year later, Trump said his northern neighbor was “two faced,” so let’s just say there were no invitations to go golfing.</p><p>Trump carries a grudge the way Thor wields a hammer — so expect carnage if Trudeau is still in power when the new trade deal is renegotiated in 2026.</p><p>That leaves the other key PFT route: The Logic of Mutually Beneficial Trade. The strategy, as the minister explained to me, is to play the economic hits, just like last time.</p><ul><li>Canada is the US’s largest trading partner: US exports to Canada surpassed $307 Billion in 2021, while imports from Canada were $357.2 billion.</li><li>The US imports more oil from Canada than anywhere else.</li><li>The largest market for key swing states like Michigan? Canada.</li><li>Critical minerals and the AI future: Canada can weaken China’s dominance of the critical mineral supply chain with reliable sources of lithium, nickel, graphite and rare earth minerals.</li></ul><p>And on it goes. In other words, these are powerful, rational arguments in favor of open trade and against protectionism and Buy America that have the benefit of truth. On a state level these arguments are still effective, and might still be convincing to members of Congress. But as my colleague pointed out to the minister — what if rational arguments like these don’t work for the Trump administration?</p><p>The first Trump administration was, like all presidencies, a mixture of political ideology and political policy, with the president surrounded by advisors who acted as guardrails to his impulsive aggressions. They kept the alliances intact. That’s no longer the case. Those internal guards have been purged in favor of hardened partisans running a permanent war room campaign that has a strong animating force: Revenge. Just this past week Trump’s own Truth Social media channel raised billions of dollars, feeding a media ecosystem that insulates him and his team from any uncomfortable intrusions of facts that might upend his self-reinforcing political narrative. Political appetites will devour logical policymaking. So, what is the strategy in that scenario?</p><p>In 2024, PFT means trying to find a way to give Trump something that he can publicly claim as a “win,” without looking weak to your own voters.</p><p>And what is that?</p><p>Jobs.</p><p>But trying to simultaneously create jobs in America without selling out your own industries is a political magic trick most foreign leaders have yet to master, and one they may not want to. That is the challenge to the Team Canada folks who are crafting the PFT and to every country doing the same thing.</p><p>The only bright side? They had practice over the last three years. President <strong>Joe Biden</strong> has proven equally protectionist on many industries and the same arguments apply to him, only it’s much more behind closed doors, which makes the negotiations easier.</p><p>Maybe the PFT industry is why Trump supporters say he’s so effective. Before he’s even in power, he already has the upper hand. His threat of over-the-top retaliations has effectively put the US in a stronger negotiating position on trade, security and diplomacy — and he’s not yet in office. His plausible threat to collapse the status quo is his most effective negotiating tool. It may make for less trustworthy alliances, weaker international treaties and a more dangerous, less prosperous world, but it fulfills the number one Trump promise to his supporters: America First.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Bloodbaths vs. Patriots</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/bloodbaths-vs-patriots</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfmlpck56h07lqw2r5tws8</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 21 Mar 2024 22:22:31 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>white house</category>
<category>2024 presidential election</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>This is a historic moment of testing that merits deeper coverage. That’s why we at GZERO are boosting our coverage of the US election and its impact on global politics.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcf089cbsv07lqf98p5krl" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>Jess Frampton</media:credit>
<media:text>Joe Biden and Donald Trump</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcf089cbsv07lqf98p5krl" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the traffic jam of elections that is 2024 – there are over 50 this year worldwide – the US is still the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BelAZ_75710">BelAZ 75710 mega hauler</a> of elections, the biggest rig that carries more payload than any other on the political road. So when it tips over, it’s impossible to ignore. Everything matters about the US 2024 election, and we have to stay within the nonpartisan lines to avoid veering off-road.</p><p>So after <strong>Donald Trump</strong> gave a fiery speech in Ohio last weekend about an impending “bloodbath” if he’s not elected, it’s worth sorting through the carnage of coverage to see what he meant. “Now, if I don’t get elected, it’s going to be a bloodbath for the whole…” he said. “That’s going to be the least of it, it’s going to be a bloodbath for the country. That’ll be the least of it.”</p><p>Did he mean another civil war, as some thought? Or, more plausibly and as his campaign <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4539933-blood-bath-remarks-give-trump-a-new-firestorm-to-rally-around/">has claimed</a>, did he say it in the context of the auto industry and his concerns about high tariffs from China and Mexico?</p><p>That matters. Still, even the most charitable interpretation of Trump’s remarks – and I do think he was referring to the auto industry – doesn’t mean he wasn’t also playing footsie with apocalyptic, blood-soaked rhetoric, as he has long done. Warning people about illegal immigrants “poisoning the bloodstream" of the nation and openly talking about being a “dictator” are now standard parts of his campaign playbook.</p><p>The bigger problem is that the fallout obscured a much less difficult-to-interpret and more important moment in Trump's speech in which he openly rebranded the insurrectionists of Jan. 6, 2021, as “patriots” and those who went to prison after fair trials as “hostages.” It’s as if Jan. 6 is some 1979 redux of the Iranian hostage crisis and not a deadly attempt to overturn a free and fair US election. “You see the spirit from the hostages, and that's what they are, is hostages,” he said, adding: “And we’re going to be working on that as soon as the first day we get into office. We’re going to save our country, and we’re going to work with the people to treat those unbelievable patriots.”</p><p>The point is that this election is already overturning political norms in ways we have never seen in the US. There are other dynamics worth examining as well. Are <strong>Joe Biden</strong> and the Democrats radically shifting their support not only away from just the Netanyahu government’s wartime policy, but from Israel in general? What could that mean over the long term in the Middle East? What about getting more support for Ukraine? Or, as <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/by-ian-bremmer/the-greatest-energy-boom-youve-never-heard-of"><strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> wrote</a> for GZERO yesterday, how will America's new role as a fossil fuel superpower under a Democratic president play out politically and from a climate change perspective?</p><p>These are the core election questions this year. Is the US on the precipice of making fundamental changes to its role in the world and to its core democratic values? In her peerless book, “These Truths,” historian <strong>Jill Lepore</strong> surveys US history and asks whether the country has always lived up to its foundational values. It is the most important modern history book about the US, and its core thesis is playing out in real-time in the 2024 election.</p><p>This is a historic moment of testing that merits deeper coverage. That’s why we at GZERO are boosting our coverage of the US election and its impact on global politics.</p><p>First, check out our <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/election-watch/">Election Watch</a> section on the website, where we will aggregate our US and global elections coverage so you can get a clearer picture of what’s happening and what it means.</p><p>From April, we will also be changing our weekly video series with Eurasia Group’s Managing Director and lead Washington analyst <strong>Jon Lieber</strong> to “US Politics: Election 2024” and combining that with the weekly series “3 Big Things to Watch in the Election.”</p><p>We will also be continuing to track disinformation and the impact it has on the election as we did<a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/tracking-anti-navalny-bot-armies"> last month</a> with the death of <strong>Alexei Navalny</strong>.</p><p>This weekend, on our weekly PBS TV program “<a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/video/gzero-world-with-ian-bremmer/">GZERO World</a>,” <strong>Ian Bremmer</strong> dives into the impact US foreign policy may have on the 2024 presidential election. The big question: Would a Trump second term bring considerable change to the way the US does business abroad? Ian’s guest this week, Harvard Kennedy School professor and acclaimed political scientist <strong>Stephen Walt</strong>, says it probably <em>won’t</em>. Ian disagrees. Tune in for a great debate.</p><p>It’s the first of several episodes Ian will devote to covering the US election and America’s impact on the world over the coming critical months.</p><p>So, get ready for more coverage and what we do best: more insight into what it means, why it matters, and where we are all headed. Let us know what else you want to see us cover.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Should Canada give three F’s?</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/should-canada-give-three-fs</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfm83cjc5l07mysdivpsqz</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 14 Mar 2024 18:22:53 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>us-canada relations</category>
<category>trade</category>
<category>perrin beatty</category>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>usmca</category>
<category>brian mulroney</category>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>Perrin Beatty, who served as defense minister under Prime Minister Brian Mulroney in the late 1980s, gave me his view of what to watch for in this volatile election year and why Canada’s three F’s matter more than people think.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcfqobbq2y07myt4aqw46z" type="image/png" medium="image" width="1920" height="1080">
<media:credit>Annie Gugliotta</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcfqobbq2y07myt4aqw46z" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For the past 17 years, <strong>Perrin Beatty</strong> has been the voice of business in Canada. And that means he cares about one key thing: the United States. After all, Beatty has long understood that for Canadian business, the biggest customer, opportunity, market, threat — you name it — has always been the United States. And Canada has been the biggest or second biggest market for the US. Beatty, who served as defense minister under Prime Minister <strong>Brian Mulroney</strong> in the late 1980s, gave me his view of what to watch for in this volatile election year and why Canada’s three F’s matter more than people think.</p><p><strong>You’re leaving your role as president of the Canadian Chamber of Commerce after 17 years, which has been a transformative time. What is the biggest economic challenge facing Canada's trade with the US?</strong><br></p><p><strong>Perrin:</strong> The politics of trade has undergone a sea change in the US under the last two presidents. Previous presidents, from Ronald Reagan on, viewed America's interactions in the global economy as an opportunity to foster American prosperity, and they saw an integrated North American economy as a source of strength. More recently, however, US politicians have started to turn inward, increasingly viewing their country as a victim, and not as the primary beneficiary of international engagement. This change has led them to increasingly align themselves with domestic protectionists who want to build economic walls along the US border.</p><p>Unfortunately, this turn inward has coincided with a complacency here in Canada about our most important bilateral relationship. Even the best of friends can't afford to take each other for granted, or they will soon drift apart.</p><p>As Canada's relationship with the US has moved from being strategic to being transactional, American leaders are increasingly looking at each issue as a standalone, and they are making their decisions, not on what is in America's long-term best interest, but on where they can find immediate political advantage at home.</p><p>We need to rebuild that strategic relationship. It's vital for Canada to be seen as bringing solutions to the major problems confronting the United States, as opposed to simply pleading to be exempted from the latest punitive measure. We need to demonstrate, both in Washington and far away from it that Canada should be treated not as a problem, but as a partner.</p><figure><img src="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvr9i04369vq07myzkvz1c5s" alt="should-canada-give-three-fs-51741434.jpg" width="400" height="318"><figcaption>Perrin Beatty, outgoing president and CEO of Canadian Chamber of Commerce. Credit: REUTERS/Rebecca Cook</figcaption></figure><p>Perrin Beatty, outgoing president and CEO of Canadian Chamber of Commerce.&nbsp;REUTERS/Rebecca Cook</p><p><strong>You recently said: “Canada is increasingly being viewed by our partners in the region as a well-meaning but unserious player on the international stage." In what ways has Canada become an "unserious player," and what needs to happen to change that reputation?</strong></p><p><strong>Perrin:&nbsp;</strong>Unfortunately, we have come to see ourselves as a moral superpower whose job is to tell everyone else what they are doing wrong. And we expect them to be grateful to us for it. Too often, we are driven more by a desire for good feelings than for good results. In contrast, other countries are both faster-moving and more engaged in the issues their interlocutors consider most important. The consequence is that, where the US and other countries used to ask, “How do we get the Canadians involved?” their question is now, “Should we inform the Canadians?” The fact that we learned about the AUKUS agreement at the same time as everyone else is just one example.</p><p>The Russian invasion of Ukraine two years ago should have been seen by Canada as world-changing, and our response should have been both meaningful and swift, with us marshaling what we have to offer in defense of the democracies. For example, Canada has an abundance of the “three F’s” – food, fuel, and fertilizer – and critical minerals that are essential to global stability. What we lack is the infrastructure, the vision, and the will to bring them to global markets to give countries an alternative to sending dollars to despots. This could be Canada's moment, but only if we are prepared to seize it.</p><p><strong>You were a former defense minister under Mr. Mulroney, so you know about dealing with a dangerous world. But now, everyone is looking at the impact of the US election. Are we headed into a period of instability, conflict, and the dismantling of both trade and defense alliances that have been built since World War II?</strong></p><p><strong>Perrin:</strong> The problems we face, from global poverty to pandemics to wars to global climate change, all require an effective, coordinated international response. Instead of that, we are witnessing countries turning inward on themselves, as well as the increasing ineffectiveness of global institutions like the UN, the World Trade Organization, and the WHO in actually resolving issues that go to our very survival.</p><p>When I was privileged to be in government, there was a sense that, when the leaders of the G7 – leaders who included <strong>Reagan, Thatcher, Mitterrand, Kohl,&nbsp;</strong>and<strong> Mulroney&nbsp;</strong>– came together, problems would be resolved. Today, when international meetings take place, you get the feeling that our problems are bigger than our leaders. In fairness, the world is a much more complex and dangerous place today, but that's precisely why we need leaders whose vision, determination, and morality are up to the challenge. As your question suggests, we're at a crossroads that will determine whether we will be able to maintain the institutions and strategies that have guaranteed democracy, peace, and prosperity since the Second World War. The stakes have never been higher.</p><p><strong>AI is both a transformative opportunity and a destabilizing threat. What is your view of how will impact business?</strong></p><p><strong>Perrin:&nbsp;</strong>Like businesses the world over, Canadian businesses will be transformed either for the better or for the worse by AI. AI, like the nuclear genie, can't be put back into the bottle. Our challenge is first to understand it, then to decide how to mitigate its potential bad effects, and then to determine how to unleash its positive aspects. In this instance, the technology is developing at a pace that far outstrips our capacity to understand it and manage it well. However, calls to initiate some sort of a standstill until we have thought these things through are naïve and unworkable; all that would happen is that the unscrupulous players would widen their lead.</p><p>The challenge for Canadian policymakers is how to successfully work with others on coordinated policies that limit the dangerous aspects of AI without denying its benefits to our industry and our society.</p><p><strong>If there is a second Trump Presidency, what should Canada expect from the 2026 review/renegotiation of USMCA trade deal?</strong></p><p><strong>Perrin:&nbsp;</strong>Many Canadians expected that when <strong>Joe Biden</strong> became president, he would reverse the Trump protectionist measures. However, that assumption overlooked the fact that, in the past, Republicans were more in favor of free trade, while Democrats were more protectionist. In fact, the Biden administration has actually deepened some of the protectionist policies initiated by Donald Trump.</p><p>The danger is that the election will be a contest between two candidates trying to demonstrate who is more protectionist. Canadians must respect the right of US voters to determine their own government, just as we would insist on the Americans respecting our rights, but we need to demonstrate that it is in Americans' self-interest to foster a stronger relationship with their closest neighbor and best friend. And we must do that, not by special pleading, but by coming up with solutions to problems.</p><p><strong>Finally, what is the best-case scenario for the US-Canada relationship in terms of economic prosperity and security? Is there a way to slalom through the protectionism, AI disruptions, political polarization, climate challenges, and conflicts and see a time of increased joint prosperity?</strong></p><p><strong>Perrin:</strong> The best-case scenario is that we restore a strategic partnership with the world's greatest superpower. We've let the relationship slide for too long, and it won't be easy to regain that position. But I believe it can be done if we muster the vision and the will to make it happen.</p><p><strong>Last thing: You worked for Brian Mulroney, who recently passed away. He was the architect of the North American Free Trade Agreement and worked closely with Ronald Reagan. What lesson can today’s leaders learn from that time?</strong></p><p><strong>Perrin:</strong> As Canadians commemorate <strong>Brian Mulroney</strong>, our leaders should ask what they can learn from Canada's last great transformative prime minister. Brian Mulroney understood that governments don't create jobs and prosperity, businesses do. He also knew that the best way to solve problems was not to shut people out but to bring them in.</p><p>It's impossible to say exactly what policies a different government would follow, but what we do know is that our economy and our country are under severe strain today. The leader history will remember best will be the one who brings people together again in what remains the most fortunate country on the face of the globe.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Fake clouds, seeding doubt</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/fake-clouds-seeding-doubt</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfljqek16p07lqjugfu0eo</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 29 Feb 2024 20:59:19 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>donald trump</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>If someone doesn’t believe the clouds are real, why would they believe the facts about the economy are real?</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcen4obm3x07myl449bjeq" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1200" height="675">
<media:credit>REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque</media:credit>
<media:text>President Joe Biden looks up as he mentions his mother during addressing the Irish Parliament at Leinster House, in Dublin, Ireland, April 13, 2023.</media:text>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrcen4obm3x07myl449bjeq" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Those clouds are not real,” the woman standing next me at the car pickup spot said, pointing to the overcast skies above San Diego.</p><p>I had just arrived here to speak to a group of business leaders about Eurasia Group’s Top Risk <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.eurasiagroup.net/issues/top-risks-2024">report</a> and the political landscape ahead in a year of polarizing elections.</p><p>“Sorry?”</p><p>“It’s usually beautiful and sunny here, but now with the cloud seeding, all we get is this,” she explained, adopting that apologetic tone proud locals use when their home isn’t exhibiting its best for a visitor. She interrupted her weather flow to give me some other tips about local restaurants — “check out Roberto’s taco stand” — and hiking in the area, before returning to the weather.</p><p>“Yeah, you know all those floods we had this past month?” she asked rhetorically. “They’re from these clouds the climate folks created with their cloud seeding because they want to block out the sun to cool the Earth down.”</p><p>And then she added the kicker: “And it’s poison, you know.”</p><p>Of all the risks I had come here to talk about, the poison-fake-clouds-causing-floods risk did not make the agenda. But the theory is so pervasive in California that the LA Times just wrote a <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2024-02-24/the-latest-unfounded-conspiracy-theory-cloud-seeding-is-to-blame-for-californias-storms-and-flooding">long story</a> in order to, well, rain on the conspiracy parade.</p><p>A quick background might be in order.</p><p>Cloud seeding is not new. It’s been around since the late 1940s, when a meteorologist named Vincent Schaefer first tried to stop ice from forming on airplane wings by firing chemicals like silver iodide into the air to stimulate condensation. Since then it’s been happening all over the world to induce rain or reduce hail storms — but it’s not a Harry Potter magic trick that can cause mass flooding. Cloud seeding, at best, can increase precipitation by about 5%-10%, which won’t get Noah rushing to build an ark.</p><p>Silver iodide is the chemical most often used and there are legitimate health and environmental questions about the levels. The EPA and state governments regulate all cloud seeding programs. And there are multiple <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27517140/">studies</a> that show the levels of silver collected from cloud seeding are more than a 1000 times lower than EPA standards for drinking water and therefore have very minor environmental, toxicological or health impacts.</p><p>So, did cloud seeding cause the two flooding events that took place between Feb. 3-8 and 18-19? Nope. As the Times reported, the body in charge of the project, the Santa Ana Watershed Project Authority (SAWPA), hadn’t even conducted any cloud seeding operations since Feb. 1, and even then, they didn’t do it in the San Diego area.</p><p>I didn’t intend to go up the whole cloud seeding hole, but the short encounter prompted me to think about the polarization in both the US and Canada, where people no longer debate different ideas based on a shared set of facts, but believe in different realities. Genuine, substantial conversations between people who disagree on key events, like say, the war in Gaza, are just not happening in places like college campuses — where they should — because each side sees the other as illegitimate, as if one is looking at fake clouds and the other at the real thing.</p><p>University administrators are now so fearful of getting involved in any way other than making anodyne statements — they don’t want to be “Harvarded” and alienate students, donors, and politicians or all three — that campuses have become bunkers of protest, not bastions of political debate.</p><p>It's also playing out politically in the US election cycle, where perception is driving reality. Look at the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-fourth-quarter-economic-growth-revised-slightly-lower-2024-02-28/">strong economic news</a>. Last quarter, US GDP increased at a 3.2% annualized rate, business investment is up, consumer spending is up, the market is up and wages are up — but Biden’s poll numbers are down.</p><p>Biden is getting no credit for strong economic news and Donald Trump is sustaining no damage from bad legal news because partisan voters simply see what they want to see. Biden’s problem is no longer inflation itself — it has come down dramatically — it’s <em>vibe-flation</em>. Biden simply doesn’t look like the good news he’s delivering. He looks weak while his facts are strong. Trump looks strong while his facts are weak. And it’s working for Trump.</p><p>The self-reinforcing reality bubbles of partisan politics make it next to impossible to break out of these myopic views because there are no institutions with enough trust to set a benchmark of consensus and corrective facts.</p><p>As Gallup <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/508169/historically-low-faith-institutions-continues.aspx">polling</a> on trust consistently shows, confidence in US institutions is at all-time lows and going down: “The five worst-rated institutions — newspapers, the criminal justice system, television news, big business and Congress — stir confidence in less than 20% of Americans, with Congress, at 8%, the only one in single digits,” wrote Gallup’s Lydia Saad.</p><p>If someone doesn’t believe the clouds are real, why would they believe the facts about the economy are real?</p><p>Everything is political. That’s our mandate here at GZERO, but it doesn’t mean everything is up for grabs. Seeding clouds of doubt with conspiracy theories everywhere erodes the foundational gift of our democracy, which is to have passionate disagreements respectfully with our neighbors and still manage to get big things done together. To do that, facts matter.</p><p>That’s why, with crises growing all around the world and the election cycle whirling ever faster, we at GZERO are committed to having humane, non-partisan, robust coverage about different, conflicting points of view — but at least with an agreed upon set of basic facts. To alter an old saying, you are entitled to your own opinions, but not your own clouds.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
<item>
<title>Tracking anti-Navalny bot armies</title>
<link>https://www.gzeromedia.com/gzero-north/tracking-anti-navalny-bot-armies</link>
<guid isPermaLink="false">cmvrfl5xek00x07lqgswsuigg</guid>
<pubDate>Thu, 22 Feb 2024 17:44:05 +0000</pubDate>
<dc:creator>Evan Solomon</dc:creator>
<category>united states</category>
<category>canada</category>
<category>joe biden</category>
<category>dissent</category>
<category>justin trudeau</category>
<category>alexei navalny</category>
<category>cyabra</category>
<category>vladimir putin</category>
<category>bots</category>
<category>russia</category>
<category>evan solomon</category>
<category>twitter</category>
<category>misinformation</category>
<category>cybersecurity</category>
<category>dissident</category>
<category>europe</category>
<category>dan brahmy</category>
<category>ukraine</category>
<category>GZERO North</category>
<description>In an exclusive investigation into online disinformation surrounding online reaction to Alexei Navalny&apos;s death, GZERO asks whether it is possible to track the birth of a bot army. Was Navalny&apos;s tragic death accompanied by a massive online propaganda campaign? We investigated, with the help of a company called Cyabra.</description>
<media:content url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrce0w6c9kt07lq8lncuht9" type="image/jpeg" medium="image" width="1920" height="1080">
<media:credit>Jess Frampton</media:credit>
</media:content>
<media:thumbnail url="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvrce0w6c9kt07lq8lncuht9" />
<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>In an exclusive investigation into online disinformation surrounding online reaction to </em><strong>Alexei Navalny's</strong><em> death, GZERO asks whether it is possible to track the birth of a bot army. Was Navalny's tragic death accompanied by a massive online propaganda campaign? We investigated, with the help of a company called Cyabra.</em></p><p><strong>Alexei Navalny</strong> knew he was a dead man the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FsXM2Emq-M">moment he returned to Moscow</a> in January 2021. <strong>Vladimir Putin</strong> had already tried to kill him with the nerve agent Novichok, and he was sent to Germany for treatment. The poison is one of Putin’s signatures, like pushing opponents out of windows or shooting them in the street. Navalny knew Putin would try again.</p><p>Still, he came home.</p><p>“If your beliefs are worth something,” Navalny <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/17/world/europe/why-navalny-returned-to-russia.html">wrote</a> on Facebook, “you must be willing to stand up for them. And if necessary, make some sacrifices.”</p><p>He made the ultimate sacrifice on Feb. 16, when Russian authorities announced, with Arctic banality, that he had “died” at the IK-3 penal colony more than 1,200 miles north of Moscow. A frozen gulag. “Convict Navalny A.A. felt unwell after a walk, almost immediately losing consciousness,” they announced as if quoting a passage from Koestler’s “Darkness at Noon.” Later, deploying the pitch-black doublespeak of all dictators, they decided to call it, “sudden death syndrome.”</p><p>Worth noting: Navalny was filmed the day before, looking well. There is no body for his wife and two kids to see. No autopsy.</p><p>As we wrote this morning, <a href="https://www.gzeromedia.com/news/analysis/yes-vladimir-putin-is-winning">Putin is winning</a> on all fronts. Sensing NATO support for the war in Ukraine is wavering – over to you, US Congress – Putin is acting with confident impunity. His army is gaining ground in Ukraine. He scored a propaganda coup when he toyed with dictator-fanboy Tucker Carlson during his two-hour PR session thinly camouflaged as an “interview.” And just days after Navalny was declared dead, the Russian pilot Maksim Kuzminov, who defected to Ukraine with his helicopter last August, was gunned down in Spain.</p><p>And then, of course, there is the disinformation war, another Putin battleground. Navalny’s death got me wondering if there would be an orchestrated disinformation campaign around the event, and if so, whether there was any way to track it? Would there be, say, an online release of shock bot troops to combat Western condemnation of Navalny’s death and blunt the blowback?</p><p>It turns out there was.</p><p>To investigate, GZERO asked the “social threat information company” <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://cyabra.com/">Cyabra</a>, which specializes in tracking bots, to look for disinformation surrounding the online reactions to the news about Navalny. The Israeli company says its job is to uncover “threats” on social platforms. It has built AI-driven software to track “attacks such as impersonation, data leakage, and online executive perils as they occur.”</p><p>Cyabra’s team focused on the tweets <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/POTUS/status/1758597239927103903">President <strong>Joe Biden</strong></a><strong>&nbsp;</strong>and <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/JustinTrudeau/status/1758516187451855311a">Prime Minister <strong>Justin Trudeau</strong></a> posted condemning Navalny’s death. Their software analyzed the number of bots that targeted these official accounts. And what they found was fascinating.</p><p>According to Cyabra, “29% of the Twitter profiles interacting with Biden’s post about Navalny on X were identified as inauthentic.” For Trudeau, the number was 25%.</p><figure><img src="https://us-west-2.graphassets.com/cmrcgvnh6064507n8hhitfmjj/cmvr9hrmi69kp07my0v3g79e8" alt="tracking-anti-navalny-bot-armies-51539570.png" width="1200" height="675"><figcaption>Credit: Courtesy of Cyabra</figcaption></figure><p>Courtesy of Cyabra</p><p>So, according to Cyabra, more than a quarter of the reaction you saw on X related to Navalny’s death and these two leaders’ reactions came from bots, not humans. In other words, a bullshit campaign of misinformation.</p><p>This finding raises a lot of questions. What’s the baseline of corruption to get a good sense of comparison? For example, is 27% bot traffic on Biden’s tweet about Navalny’s death a lot, or is everything on social media flooded with the same amount of crap? How does Cyabra's team actually track bots, and how accurate is their data? Are they missing bots that are well-disguised, or, on the other side, are some humans being labeled as “inauthentic”? In short, what does this really tell us?</p><p>In the year of elections, with multiple wars festering and AI galloping ahead of regulation, the battle against disinformation and bots is more consequential than ever. The bot armies of the night are marching. We need to find a torch to see where they are and if there are any tools that can help us separate fact from fiction.</p><p>Tracking bot armies is a job that often happens in the shadows, and it comes with a lot of challenges. Can this be done without violating people’s privacy? How hard is this to combat? I spoke with the CEO of Cyabra, <strong>Dan Brahmy</strong>, to get his view.</p><p><strong>Solomon</strong>: When Cyabra tracked the reactions to the tweets from President Joe Biden and Prime Minister Trudeau about the “death” of Navalny, you found more than 25% of the accounts were inauthentic. What does this tell us about social media and what people can actually trust is real?</p><p><strong>Brahmy:</strong> From elections to sporting events to other significant international headline events, social media is often the destination for millions of people to follow the news and share their opinion. Consequently, it is also the venue of choice for malicious actors to manipulate the narrative.</p><p>This was also the case when Cyabra looked into President Biden and Prime Minister Trudeau’s X post directly blaming Putin for Navalny’s death. These posts turned out to be the ideal playing ground for narrative-manipulating bots. Inauthentic accounts on a large scale attacked Biden and Trudeau and blamed them for their foreign and domestic policies while attempting to divert attention from Putin and the negative narrative surrounding him.</p><p>The high number of fake accounts detected by Cyabra, together with the speed at which those accounts engaged in the conversation to divert and distract following the announcement of Navalny’s death, shows the capabilities of malicious actors and their intentions to conduct sophisticated influence operations.</p><p><strong>Solomon</strong>: Can you tell where these are from and who is doing it?</p><p><strong>Brahmy</strong>: Cyabra monitors for publicly available information on social media and does not track IP addresses or any private information. The publicly shared location of the account is collected by Cyabra. When analyzing the Navalny conversation, Cyabra saw that the majority of the accounts claimed themselves as coming from the US.</p><p><strong>Solomon</strong>: There is always the benchmark question: How much “bot” traffic or inauthentic traffic do you expect at any time, for any online event? Put the numbers we see here for Trudeau and Biden in perspective.</p><p><strong>Brahmy:</strong> The average percentage of fake accounts participating in an everyday conversation online typically varies between 4 and 8%. Cyabra’s discovery of 25-29% fake accounts related to this conversation is alarming, significant, and should give us cause for concern.</p><p><strong>Solomon</strong>: Ok, then there is the accuracy question. How do you actually identify a bot and how do you know, given the sophistication of AI and new bots, that you are not missing a lot of them? Is it easier to find “obvious bots”— i.e., something that tweets every two minutes 24 hours a day, then say, a series of bots that look and act very human?</p><p><strong>Brahmy:</strong> Using advanced AI and machine learning, Cyabra analyzes a profile’s activity and interactions to determine if it demonstrates non-human behaviors. Cyabra’s proprietary algorithm consists of over 500 behavioral parameters. Some parameters are more intuitive, like the use of multiple languages, while others require in-depth expertise and advanced machine learning. Cyabra’s technology works at scale and in almost real-time.</p><p><strong>Solomon</strong>: There is so much disinformation anyway – actual people who lie, mislead, falsify, scam – how much does this matter?</p><p><strong>Brahmy:</strong> The creation and activities of fake accounts on social media (whether it be a bot, sock puppet, troll, or otherwise) should be treated with the utmost seriousness. Fake accounts are almost exclusively created for nefarious purposes. By identifying inauthentic profiles and then analyzing their behaviors and the false narratives they are spreading, we can understand the intentions of malicious actors and remedy them as a society.</p><p>While we all understand that the challenge of disinformation is pervasive and a threat to society, being able to conduct the equivalent of an online CT scan reveals the areas that most urgently need our attention.</p><p><strong>Solomon</strong>: Why does it matter in a big election year?</p><p><strong>Brahmy:&nbsp;</strong>More than 4 billion people globally are eligible to vote in 2024, with over 50 countries holding elections. That’s 40% of the world’s population. Particularly during an election year, tracking disinformation is important – from protecting the democratic process, ensuring informed decision-making, preventing foreign interference, and promoting transparency, to protecting national security. By tracking and educating the public on the prevalence of inauthentic accounts, we slowly move closer to creating a digital environment that fosters informed, constructive, and authentic discourse.</p><p>You can check out part of the Cybara report <a rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank" href="https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:EU:3cc20367-c198-414f-9efc-3872e0a13249">here</a>.</p>]]></content:encoded>
</item>
</channel>
</rss>