Will the Supreme Court throw government regulation overboard?

The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. is seen from snow-covered U.S. Capitol grounds on January 17, 2024.
The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. is seen from snow-covered U.S. Capitol grounds on January 17, 2024.
Bryan Olin Dozier via Reuters Connect

The Supreme Court heard arguments in a case that could strip government agencies of their power to regulate industries.

The case was brought by fishermen in New Jersey and Rhode Island who contested a federal regulation that attempted to stop overfishing by requiring commercial fishermen to pay roughly $700 per day for federal monitors of their vessels.

The regulation has since been suspended and its costs refunded, but two conservative legal groups have brought the case to the Supreme Court because it is perfect for attacking the Chevron doctrine.

What is that?: The doctrine, which takes its name from the 1984 Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council decision, requires courts to defer to agencies’ reasonable interpretations of laws. This is the legal basis of most government regulation. It is also one of the most cited cases in American law, but this court has proven it isn’t afraid to overturn precedent.

Taking sides?: Conservative justices showed skepticism about Chevron, arguing that it allows agencies to change tack on regulation with each new administration. But Liberal justices worry that overturning it could mean that the courts and Congress – as opposed to exports and career professionals in federal agencies – will become the regulators of everything from AI to pharmaceuticals.

Why it matters: If Chevron is negated, it would give more power to the courts while ushering in a period of deregulation and a deluge of litigation from companies filing for their regulations to be overturned. Decades of regulation involving the environment, the stock market, on-the-job safety, health care, consumer safety, and guns are all expected to be affected if Chevron is thrown overboard.

More from GZERO Media

- YouTube

This week World Bank announced a bold initiative to bridge the gender divide by creating more economic opportunity, broadening female leadership, and reducing gender-based violence in the next 5 years as 2030 approaches.

Matthew Kendrick

When a country hits rock bottom financially, the International Monetary Fund is meant to step in with funds to stabilize the economy without damaging its society — or the gender gap. But studies show that these programs often push women out of work at a disproportionate rate to men as the economy contracts. Matthew Kendrick reports from the World Bank-IMF Annual Meetings on a push to build more equitable programs.

Russia's President Vladimir Putin and North Korea's leader Kim Jong Un attend a farewell ceremony before Putin's departure at an airport in Pyongyang, North Korea June 19, 2024.
Gavriil Grigorov/Reuters

Kyiv says that roughly 12,000 North Korean troops are in Russia, a far greater number than reported by the US, though it remains unclear precisely how many have entered what Ukraine referred to as the “combat zone.”

Supporters of the Georgian Dream party attend a final campaign rally ahead of the upcoming parliamentary elections in Tbilisi, Georgia October 23, 2024.
REUTERS/Irakli Gedenidze

Georgian Dream insists the country is still on track to join the EU, as critics accuse the party of pushing Georgia in an increasingly anti-Western, authoritarian direction.

Luisa Vieira

In 2001, a Goldman Sachs economist coined an acronym for the four largest and most promising “emerging market” economies: Brazil, Russia, India, and China became known as the “BRIC” countries.

October 23, 2024, Kamagaya, Japan - Japanese Prime Minister and leader of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) Shigeru Ishiba reacts to his supporters after he delivered a campaign speech for his party candidate Hisashi Matsumoto for the general election at Kamagaya in Chiba prefecture, suburban Tokyo on Wednesday, October 23, 2024.
(photo by Yoshio Tsunoda/AFLO)

As Japan heads to the polls this Sunday, Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba’s decision to call an early election just weeks after taking office is turning out to be a high-stakes gamble.

- YouTube

While the global economy shows signs of growth and decreasing inflation, the near future involves risks, including the escalation in the Middle East impacting oil prices, strained China-US relations, and an increasingly challenging tariff and trade environment, said Ayhan Kose, World Bank Deputy Chief Economist. He discussed the geopolitical tensions influencing the global economy with GZERO's Tony Maciulis at the IMF and World Bank Annual Meetings in Washington, DC, in a GZERO Global Stage interview.