We have updated our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for Eurasia Group and its affiliates, including GZERO Media, to clarify the types of data we collect, how we collect it, how we use data and with whom we share data. By using our website you consent to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, including the transfer of your personal data to the United States from your country of residence, and our use of cookies described in our Cookie Policy .
{{ subpage.title }}
What’s Nakhchivan, and could it spark yet another war in Europe?
OK, you may only recently have learned what “Nagorno-Karabakh” is (and if you didn’t, you can go here .) But when it rains it pours, especially in the Caucasus. So now it’s time to learn about a small exclave that could trigger the region’s next big conflict. Today, we are meeting “Nakhchivan.”
What’s Nakhchivan? Home to about half a million Azerbaijanis, Nakhchivan (pronounced NOCK-chee-vonn) is a part of Azerbaijan that is separated from the rest of the country by a thin sliver of Southern Armenia (see map above). Until 1991, those borders didn’t mean much, as both Armenia and Azerbaijan were glommed together as part of the larger Soviet Union.
But when the USSR collapsed and Armenia and Azerbaijan went to war over Nagorno-Karabakh in the early 1990s, Armenia cut Azerbaijan’s overland ties to Nakhchivan. That forced Azerbaijan to create new routes through neighboring Iran, and to rely more on Turkey, which has a small border with Nakhchivan as well.
Now, Azerbaijan has Nakhchivan in its sights again, perhaps literally. The reconquest of Nagorno-Karabakh means Azeri forces now control all of Azerbaijan’s territory again, right up to the Armenian border region of Syunik, which is all that separates Azerbaijan from the Nakhchivan exclave. It is a distance of barely 20 miles as the Azeri “qarğa” flies.
An emboldened Azerbaijan is now renewing longstanding calls to create an Azeri-controlled “corridor” that would slash across southern Armenia. Turkey — which has always strongly supported its ethnolinguistic cousins, the Azeris — also likes the idea. After all, linking Azerbaijan, Nakhchivan, and Turkey would create a pan-Turkic entity spanning from the Caspian Sea to the Mediterranean. Just days after retaking Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev met his Turkish counterpart Recep Erdogan in Nakhchivan to push for a new corridor.
The Armenians, not surprisingly, don’t like this at all. But if Azerbaijan moved to create facts on the ground, would anyone come to Armenia’s defense? The outcome of the Nagorno-Karabakh war leaves little reason to think so. Azerbaijan, with Turkish help, is now in a commanding position to dictate what the map of the South Caucasus looks like.
Now that you know what Nakhchivan is … keep an ear out for more news on it in the coming weeks.Men and paramedic staff help transport a man who was injured in a blast in Mastung to a hospital in Quetta, Pakistan.
Hard Numbers: Pakistan blast, mRNA Nobel win, Kaiser Permanente strike, escaping Nagorno-Karabakh, flights to Libya, cashing in rupees
59: Fifty-nine people were killed Saturday in a bomb blast at a mosque in Mastung, Pakistan, where people were gathering to mark the birthday of the Prophet Mohammad. Pakistan’s interior ministry accused India’s intelligence service of masterminding the attack, a charge Delhi denies.
2: Two scientists, Professors Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman, won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine on Monday for having developed the technology that led to the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. The same technology is now being tested to help fight other diseases.
75,000:
In what would be the largest healthcare strike in US history,
75,000 workers at care provider Kaiser Permanente
are threatening a three-day walkout as of Wednesday. While the company said hospitals and ERs would remain open, patients might see longer wait times and delays in lab work.
100,000: Over 100,000 ethnic Armenian refugees have fled to Armenia from Nagorno-Karabakh after Azerbaijan retook control of the territory. The UN has called for international assistance, and Armenia has asked the European Union for shelter assistance and medical supplies.
10: Flights resumed from Libya to Italy after a 10-year hiatus due to a ban imposed by the European Union. Medsky Airways is now offering twice-weekly service from Tunis to Rome, though it is unclear how it is getting around the EU ban that is still in force.
96: India is extending the deadline to Oct. 7 to cash in its 2,000 rupee notes, 96% of which have been returned to the national treasury. The bills, worth an estimated $24, were introduced in 2016 during a campaign to demonetize the economy in which higher-value notes were discontinued.
Kosovo-Serbia tensions worsen, hurting EU membership hopes
Carl Bildt, former prime minister of Sweden, shares his perspective on European politics - this week from Stockholm.
Are Serbia and Kosovo heading towards a confrontation?
It looks very bad. What happened in northern Kosovo the other day was distinctly bad. A collection of fairly well-armed and well-organized Serb thugs did an operation that was eventually beaten back by Kosovo police. It follows a cycle of escalation that was initiated on the Kosovo side, has to be said, last year, and has not been brought under control by rather intense diplomacy, both by the Europeans and by the Americans. At the moment, things look very bleak. This, of course, is damaging the EU integration prospects for both Serbia and Kosovo. Let's see what happens.
How can the EU react to what's happening in Nagorno-Karabakh?
Well, it was a very blatant military operation by the Azeris that sort of captured, de facto destroyed the autonomous functions of Nagorno-Karabakh. And it has encouraged, or forced, however you want to phrase it, practically all of the Armenians to evacuate in the direction of Armenia. It’s a huge political and humanitarian tragedy. How we can respond remains to be seen at the moment. It's very much a question of trying to alleviate the horrible humanitarian consequences.
Refugees from Nagorno-Karabakh region ride in a truck upon their arrival at the border village of Kornidzor, Armenia, September 27, 2023.
Hard Numbers: Armenians flee Nagorno-Karabakh, GOP debate falls flat, Evergrande stock drops, tragedy strikes Iraqi wedding, Commander strikes again
50,000: A torrent of at least 50,000 ethnic Armenians have fled Nagorno-Karabakh after Azerbaijani forces occupied the hotly contested enclave last week. The refugees constitute approximately one-third of the pre-war Armenian population. Among those fleeing was Russian-Armenian billionaire Ruben Vardanyan, who Azerbaijan’s border guard service said Wednesday it had arrested.
200,000:
A 30-second spot at last night’s
Republican debate
ran advertisers around $200,000 – not cheap, but less than half the $495,000 the same time slot cost during the first debate. The network clearly expected fewer viewers to tune in for the second round, probably because polls show the lion’s share of GOP voters know they will back Donald Trump.
19: Massive Chinese property developer Evergrande saw its stock price fall 19% on reports that its chairman has been placed under police surveillance . The company has lost an astonishing 99.9% of its value since a 2017 peak and is in the midst of a government-supervised restructuring, fueling fears of liquidation.
100: Over 100 people died and scores more were injured late Tuesday when a fire swept through a wedding party in Qaraqosh, a small town in Iraq's Nineveh region. It is just the latest tragedy to strike the tight-knit community of Assyrian Christians — one of the most ancient ethnic groups in Iraq — which was forced to flee between 2014 and 2017 by the Islamic State.
11: President Joe Biden’s dog Commander has bitten yet another Secret Service agent in the 11th known incident in which the canine has harmed people at the White House. Biden’s other dog, Major, was sent to live with friends in Delaware after displaying similar aggression, but he's not the only president to have had a misbehaving pet: America’s most animal-crazy president, Teddy Roosevelt, notoriously had a badger named Josiah who bit legs constantly – “but never faces,” according to the president’s son Archie.A map of Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding areas in the South Caucasus.
Is the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict over?
After more than a century of bitter clashes, the long-simmering conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the contested territory of Nagorno-Karabakh came to a boil last week as Azerbaijan seized full control of the enclave.
Nagorno-Karabakh is a historically Armenian enclave that is internationally recognized as part of Muslim-majority Azerbaijan but had been de facto governed by its ethnic Armenian Christian population since 1994. That is, until now.
So, how did we get here? What just happened? And is the conflict over?
A brief history of Nagorno-Karabakh
Throughout history, this mountainous region in the South Caucasus has come under the control of various empires, including Persians, Turks, Russians, Ottomans, and, mostly recently, the Soviet Union.
In the wake of the Russian Empire’s collapse in 1917, Armenia and Azerbaijan declared independence and laid claim to Karabakh (along with two other ethnically mixed regions, Nakhchivan and Zangezur). War broke out in 1920, but before the matter could be settled, the Soviet Union conquered the entire Caucasus, and by the following year Joseph Stalin had designated Nagorno-Karabakh an autonomous region within the Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic with no land connection to Armenia.
By the late 1980s, ethnic tensions between Armenia and Azerbaijan exploded in Nagorno-Karabakh amid broader Soviet disintegration, culminating in what would become known as the First Karabakh War. As the Soviet Union collapsed, the enclave’s majority Armenian population declared independence from Azerbaijan, triggering a bloody war for control of the region between the new republics of Armenia and Azerbaijan. After six years, over 30,000 dead, and more than one million (largely ethnic Azeris) displaced, the war ended in 1994 with ethnic Armenian forces backed by Yerevan asserting control not just of Nagorno-Karabakh itself, but also of large swaths of the Azerbaijani territory surrounding it. Absent a formal peace treaty, this area became an internationally unrecognized but de facto independent republic known to Armenians as the Republic of Artsakh.
Despite sporadic fighting, peace largely held over the ensuing decades as negotiations remained ongoing, though the conflict itself stayed unresolved. During this time, Yerevan formed a security partnership with Russia (which nonetheless sold weapons to both sides), while Azerbaijan developed close ties with Turkey.
The balance of power began to shift in Azerbaijan’s favor in the 2010s as the country’s growing energy wealth and ramped-up support from Turkey allowed it to build up its own military capabilities and bolster its geostrategic position. By the mid-2010s, Azerbaijan had cemented a meaningful military, economic, and geopolitical advantage over Armenia.
In late 2020, sensing an opportunity to turn the tide, Azerbaijan – backed by Turkey – launched an offensive that succeeded in reclaiming much of the territory Armenia had occupied since 1994 in and surrounding Nagorno-Karabakh. The Second Karabakh War lasted 44 days and ended with 6,500 dead and a Russian-brokered truce, to be enforced by nearly 2,000 Russian peacekeepers deployed along the three-mile-wide Lachin corridor – the sole overland route connecting Karabakh to Armenia. The ceasefire agreement granted Azerbaijan control of Karabakh’s cultural capital, Shusha (Shushi to Armenians), and several towns in Nagorno-Karabakh, as well as the surrounding Azeri territories that Armenians had held since 1994 as a security buffer. Local Armenians got to keep control of the northern half of the region along with the capital, Stepanakert. The sides agreed that the final political status of the enclave would be determined in future peace talks.
While the 2020 ceasefire agreement brought about an end to active hostilities, the fundamental disagreements between Armenia and Azerbaijan regarding the region’s status persisted. And yet, despite repeated ceasefire violations and low-level skirmishes, this uneasy truce mostly held.
A map of Nagorno-Karabakh.
The final showdown
Fast forward to December 2022, when Azerbaijan closed off the Lachin corridor to shift the facts on the ground to its advantage and force the local Armenians to the negotiating table. A blatant violation of the 2020 ceasefire agreement, the nearly year-long blockade caused a severe humanitarian crisis as the region’s 120,000 inhabitants were denied access to food, fuel, and medicine, to the indifference of the Russian peacekeepers charged with safeguarding the corridor.
In April, as the humanitarian situation turned more desperate, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan announced Yerevan would renounce its claim on Karabakh as long as Baku guaranteed the rights of ethnic Armenians there. But it was too little, too late.
By that point, Baku had correctly calculated that it held the definitive military and strategic upper hand in the conflict. Yerevan’s only ally, Moscow, had since 2020 demonstrated a weakened commitment to Armenian security as well as waning influence in the region more broadly. Russia’s disastrous invasion of Ukraine not only distracted Moscow further, but it also raised the value to Europe of Azerbaijan’s oil and gas reserves as alternatives to Russian energy. Moreover, Moscow increasingly relies on the North-South transport corridor that partially runs through Azerbaijan en route to Iran and the Persian Gulf. Absent serious pushback from Russia and backed by a more geopolitically active Turkey as well as expanded energy ties with the EU, Azerbaijan saw a chance to change a political status quo it had long seen as unacceptable but had been unable to correct by diplomatic means.
On Sept. 19, Azerbaijan launched a ground and artillery offensive to take full control of Nagorno-Karabakh after what it claimed were terrorist attacks on Azeri civilians by Karabakh Armenians. Moscow, occupied by its own war and chafed at Yerevan’s growing alignment with the West, did not intervene on behalf of the ethnic Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh. Neither did Yerevan. Within 24 hours, the overwhelmingly superior Azerbaijani military had killed more than 200, injured 400, and forced the local Armenian authorities to surrender, leaving Azerbaijan in effective control of the territory.
As part of the ceasefire brokered largely by Russian peacekeepers, the local authorities agreed to disband their armed forces and discuss the region’s reintegration into Azerbaijan in exchange for Azerbaijani promises to safeguard the rights of ethnic Armenians who remain in the region.
Not that those promises are credible, given the rich history of atrocities by both sides: As of Sept. 27, more than 50,000 of the about 120,000 local Armenians who live in Karabakh have already fled the breakaway region for Armenia, fearing persecution, violence, and even ethnic cleansing from Azerbaijan. Many more will surely follow.
All in all, the outcome of the third (and apparently final) Karabakh war represents a diplomatic setback for the West, a modest win for Russia, and a source of concern for Iran. Brussels’ and Washington’s attempts to sideline Moscow in its role as regional powerbroker failed. Russia lost (abandoned?) Armenia but won points with Azerbaijan and Turkey and will get to keep its peacekeepers on the ground. And Iran, which has a vested interest in both maintaining the status quo and preserving its clout in the South Caucasus, has reasons to worry about an emboldened Azerbaijan and Turkey’s growing geopolitical influence in its near abroad.
What’s next?
It seems that Nagorno-Karabakh’s disputed status has been effectively settled once and for all, with Azerbaijan now set to take full control of the breakaway enclave.
But a potentially bigger fight between Armenia and Azerbaijan may be brewing over a different region: Armenia’s southernmost province, Syunik. This 25-mile-wide territory separates mainland Azerbaijan from Nakhchivan, a landlocked, autonomous Azerbaijani territory that shares a slim border with Turkey – and a much bigger one with Iran. This majority ethnic Azeri exclave of about 460,000 people has been largely cut off from Azerbaijan proper since the end of the First Karabakh War, but the November 2020 ceasefire agreement called for Armenia to “guarantee safety” of transport and transit between them.
Not part of the agreement? The creation of the “Zangezur corridor,” a transport corridor linking Nakhchivan and mainland Azerbaijan that would run through Syunik province but without Armenian checkpoints. This project has been a goal of Baku and Ankara since 2020. The corridor would not only connect Turkey and Azerbaijan to each other, but it would also create a strategic new trade route between Europe, the Middle East, Central Asia, and China. Yerevan opposes the corridor as a violation of its sovereignty and would use military force to repel any Azerbaijani attempts to establish it against its wishes, as Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev threatened to do in 2021.
On Monday, Aliyev hosted his Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdogan in Nakhchivan, where the two leaders celebrated Azerbaijan’s victory in Nagorno-Karabakh and broke ground for a new gas pipeline from Turkey. At a joint news conference, Aliyev hinted at his Zangezur aspirations, days after Erdogan had done the same before the UN General Assembly. (Erdogan softened his tone on Tuesday, stressing that if Armenia doesn’t agree to the Zangezur corridor, they will simply shift the route to Iran.)
Should Azerbaijan hope to capitalize on the momentum created by its Karabakh win by accelerating the forcible creation of this so-called corridor, war in the Caucasus could break out again soon. And unlike Nagorno-Karabakh, this flashpoint could draw in other regional players like Iran and Turkey, threatening geopolitical stability in Eurasia and beyond.
Russian Black Sea Fleet commander still alive despite Ukraine's claims
Ian Bremmer shares his insights on global politics this week on World In :60.
Is Russian commander Sokolov still alive?
Black Sea fleet commander. The Ukrainians said he was killed in a missile strike, but after that missile strike, he's attending a meeting with the Kremlin and looks very much alive. Should all remember that there is a lot of disinformation and a lot of misinformation in the fog of war. You remember that Snake Island strike. And that, of course, turned out those guys didn't die. They were made prisoner and then they were released. So Russians are absolutely at fault for the invasion. Ukrainian information is meant to promote Ukrainian efforts in the war. And this is one of those instances.
Will the West intervene in Nagorno-Karabakh?
Intervene in the sense that they are trying to put pressure on the Turks and the Azeris not to engage in war crimes, not to support war crimes against the Armenians, the 120,000 Armenians living in this autonomous region that is part of Azerbaijan. Thousands and thousands are streaming out, getting out. They're not forced out, but they certainly don't feel that they're going to be safe in this region for long. The war has been lost pretty decisively by the Armenians. And the question I suspect that you are going to see a level of ethnic cleansing, ethnic migration of the Armenians from this space is going to be problematic. Armenia itself is a small country. It's going to be a serious burden for them to resettle these people. And of course, it's been their homes and their homes for generations. It's very sad to see like we've seen in the Balkans, like we've seen in Iraq after the Iraq war. But it's hard to imagine anybody intervening at this point to stop that from happening. That's where I think we are. Armenia's best friend has been Russia, and that's not very useful for them.
How is China's proactive approach to trilateral cooperation impacting its relations with South Korea and Japan?
Well, it's making them harder, especially because Japan right now is on a, their food, their seafood is being banned from China. It's a significant export because of the irradiated water from Fukushima that is being released into the Pacific. Certainly, I have a hard time seeing a friendly trilateral relationship given that and I don't think it would be fixed anytime soon. But the South Koreans and the Chinese are working hard to try to make this work, and it doesn't need to be at the head of state level. It historically hasn't been frequently. I suspect that comes off and it will be formulaic and incrementally positive, but won't lead to an immediate breakthrough in relations between those two countries.
- Disinformation the “biggest threat” from Russia – Anne-Marie Slaughter ›
- UN Security Council debates Nagorno-Karabakh ›
- Nagorno-Karabakh war flares again ›
- Armenia, Azerbaijan & the Nagorno-Karabakh crisis that needs attention ›
- Yoon leads South Korea away from China, toward the US ›
- Ian Explains: Why China’s era of high growth is over ›
- China to shake up Russia-Ukraine war ›
- Ukraine war sees escalation of weapons and words ›
- Russia-Ukraine war: How we got here ›
- “Crimea river”: Russia & Ukraine’s water conflict ›
Former U.S. President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump attends a 2024 presidential election campaign event at Sportsman Boats in Summerville, South Carolina, U.S. September 25, 2023.
Hard Numbers: Trump liable for fraud, Kenya signs a big defense pact, Thailand jails king’s critic, Mexican exports get stranded, Nigeria rescues students
2.2 billion: Donald Trump was found liable for fraud Tuesday by a New York judge for lying about his wealth on financial statements to banks and insurers, inflating his net worth by approximately $2.2 billion dollars. Justice Arthur Engoron stripped the former president of control over some of his properties and sanctioned his lawyers for their behavior. Despite extensive legal troubles, Trump remains the frontrunner – and by a wide margin – for the GOP 2024 presidential nomination.
5: The US and Kenya have signed a 5-year defense agreement under which Washington will support the East African country’s security operations. Kenya has been battling al-Shabab jihadists in neighboring Somalia for years and is now poised — with $100 million in new US support — to lead an anti-gang mission to Haiti. Read more about why Kenya wants the Haiti assignment here .
4: A prominent Thai lawyer and activist who has called for reform of the country’s monarchy was sentenced to 4 years in prison under Thailand’s strict lese-majeste laws. Arnon Nampa was one of the leaders of the mass youth-led protests against the junta-dominated government in 2020. Thai politics were recently upended by the return of exiled former PM Thaksin Shinawatra. Read more here .
125: At least 125 people were killed in an unexplained explosion at a crowded fuel depot in the Nagorno-Karabakh region of Azerbaijan on Tuesday. The victims were among thousands of ethnic Armenians fleeing Karabakh after Azerbaijan retook control over the Armenian-majority region last week for the first time in more than 30 years. Read more background here .
4: Nigerian security forces rescued 14 university students who had been abducted by gunmen in northwestern Nigeria. Half a dozen students remain unaccounted for. Kidnappings for ransom have grown common in the region in recent years, as part of a broader clash between nomadic and pastoral ethnic groups. It is the first major kidnapping of its kind since President Bola Tinubu took office earlier this year with promises to improve security.Refugees from Nagorno-Karabakh region arrive at a temporary accommodation centre in the town of Goris, Armenia, September 24, 2023.
Armenia faces Karabakh refugee crisis
Just days after Azerbaijan forced the surrender of ethnic Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh, a wave of thousands of refugees from the region is streaming toward the Armenian border.
For 30 years, Nagorno-Karabakh lived as a de facto independent state with an Armenian majority, despite being officially part of Azerbaijan. But with Baku now fully back in control, there are fears that Azeri forces may engage in ethnic cleansing of the region. Both sides have committed grave human rights abuses over the course of decades of conflict.
The numbers are daunting. There are officially about 150,000 ethnic Armenians in Karabakh — if many of them were to seek safety in Armenia, the small country of 2.7 million could quickly be overwhelmed. (For comparison, imagine if 5 million people suddenly arrived in Germany, or 18 million in the US).
A burgeoning refugee crisis is adding to the pressures on Armenian PM Nikol Pashinyan, who has not only recently fallen out with Armenia’s long-time security partner, Russia, but is also facing protests in Yerevan by those who say he mishandled the Karabakh crisis and allowed the region to slip away.
A blast at a Karabakh fuel depot late Monday killed 20 and injured nearly 300, many of whom are in critical condition. Gas stations in the region have been overwhelmed by the thousands of ethnic Armenians trying to flee.